Aller au contenu

Photo

Vivienne's opinions on rebel mages (maybe spoilers)


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1751 réponses à ce sujet

#176
andar91

andar91
  • Members
  • 4 752 messages

 

 

This is more or less the solution I feel is best but what do you think about mages who have completed their training?

 

 

I would say they should be allowed to seek dispensation to do what they want. But the key word is dispensation - they would be checked up on. Like...a family being checked on by social services once in a while or something. I think they should be free to live in a small village with a family (with templars stationed there), or in the Circle as an Enchanter/Scholar/Teacher, or open a business / work through the Circle by selling magical thingamajigs or magical services to those who need them. Heck, healers could set up shop and even form freaking hospitals in larger cities. Maybe some just want to travel. Again, I think it's all good as long as they check in along the way or have some supervision at some point. True, some mages might abuse this relative freedom, but I think the goodwill it earns would prevent more bad things in the big picture - more flies with honey and all that.

 

I think I might see it a bit like the Aes Sedai in Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time series. It's like a vast guild that governs itself and divides itself into sub-guilds that perform functions (mercenary mages / scholarly mages / business mages / healers / spy mages lol / political and justice mages /) and so on.


  • cardinalally et mikeymoonshine aiment ceci

#177
Medhia_Nox

Medhia_Nox
  • Members
  • 3 530 messages

@Lanavis:  You would not find me disagreeing.  The Chantry and the Templars had a "good idea" given to them by Andraste.  "Magic is men to serve man, and never to rule over him."  Very sound premise.

 

But - then the people embraced it, the Chantry and Templars abused it a "little" - nobody made a stink about it but mages... so a little became a lot... and here we have the tyrannical abuse of a "good idea" a thousand years later. 

 

The Chanty - being the administrative branch - was, in my opinion, more at fault for not leashing their dogs when they should have.  The Templars have gone completely off the rails of course and honestly, shouldn't even be needed.

 

Mages should have filled the templar role.  Mages trained in anti-magic and given authority to police their fellows.  Then a group should have policed those mages like an Internal Affairs.

 

But since both sides are incredibly incompetent... there's conflict...

But now, there's the Inquisition.


  • The Baconer et Imported_beer aiment ceci

#178
metalfenix

metalfenix
  • Members
  • 771 messages

Somehow I didn't like her...and now I know why. Ah well, I wasn't planning to use her anyways.



#179
HeyCal

HeyCal
  • Members
  • 593 messages
Just hearing her say those things kind of solidified the fact that I am not going to like her and thusly probably never use her. I'm super pro Mage so I just wanted to roll my eyes at everything she said, haha.

I may try and use her for my own semi pro circle Mage (pro Harry potter type circle) though if she gets on my nerves she'll forever stay on her balcony,

#180
GipsyDangeresque

GipsyDangeresque
  • Members
  • 565 messages

Yeah, not only does she hold controversial views but she was very obnoxious about them.

 

I have a feeling Vivienne is going to be just as annoying as Anders about mage issues, even though she stands on the other side.



#181
Darkly Tranquil

Darkly Tranquil
  • Members
  • 2 095 messages
I think I am going to dislike Vivienne a great deal. Not so much because she is pro-Circle, but because of her snotty, arrogant, elitist attitude. I have no patience for people who think their s**t don't stink. I think Vivienne will be exiting via the airlock of the SSV Inquisition.

#182
mikeymoonshine

mikeymoonshine
  • Members
  • 3 493 messages

I would say they should be allowed to seek dispensation to do what they want. But the key word is dispensation - they would be checked up on. Like...a family being checked on by social services once in a while or something. I think they should be free to live in a small village with a family (with templars stationed there), or in the Circle as an Enchanter/Scholar/Teacher, or open a business / work through the Circle by selling magical thingamajigs or magical services to those who need them. Heck, healers could set up shop and even form freaking hospitals in larger cities. Maybe some just want to travel. Again, I think it's all good as long as they check in along the way or have some supervision at some point. True, some mages might abuse this relative freedom, but I think the goodwill it earns would prevent more bad things in the big picture - more flies with honey and all that.

 

I think I might see it a bit like the Aes Sedai in Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time series. It's like a vast guild that governs itself and divides itself into sub-guilds that perform functions (mercenary mages / scholarly mages / business mages / healers / spy mages lol / political and justice mages /) and so on.

 

Yep I agree completely. You would still have the Templars, seekers and maybe even the Inquisition to deal with mages who do abuse their freedom and power. I wonder what Vivienne would think of this idea. 



#183
leaguer of one

leaguer of one
  • Members
  • 9 995 messages

She has a point. When I played my mage warden, and I was in full role as him, he felt that the outside world was a disorganized mess that was far from the quality of the circle. The mages technically are living a better quality life then most of the people of thedus. But there's is a huge counter to her point. It's a guilded cage and even well treated pets are at the mercy of the wills of their masters. Giving mages more freedom would not of been a problem.



#184
greywatch

greywatch
  • Members
  • 76 messages

I really liked Vivienne in that video today; she seems funny and on point. That said, I definitely support the mage rebellion, so she and I will have to disagree in this area. =P


  • mikeymoonshine aime ceci

#185
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages

Why not have mages in each Chantry within the world? There are already Templars there, so a mage presence shouldn't be taken with that much concern. Instead of carting mages off to a circle tower way far away from their families, they can live and learn in the chantry, in familiar surroundings, whilst still being watched.



#186
sandalisthemaker

sandalisthemaker
  • Members
  • 5 387 messages

Vivienne will just be too fabulous and fierce for many it seems.  Gurl knows how to WURK.


  • eyezonlyii aime ceci

#187
Giantdeathrobot

Giantdeathrobot
  • Members
  • 2 942 messages

Personally, I'd think Circles should stay, but run by mages for mages, with the Templars (or a similar organisation, preferably secular) serving as a police hunting down mages who abuse their powers. Attendance is compulsory for all mages, but they get chances to visit their family once in a while, under supervision pre-Harrowing, alone post. They could also not be locked in a tower, have the run of an area around their designated Circle to actually be able to see the world a bit. But humans being humans, there will never be a perfect solution so long as someone gets to shoot fire out of their hands and control other's minds if they dabble in dark powers.

 

Vivienne was definitely snooty about her opinion, but given that the Mage rebellion has by and large been a huge disaster, it's kinda hard to blame her. 



#188
Sifr

Sifr
  • Members
  • 6 788 messages

I like that she's forthright with her beliefs, even if she does come a cross a somewhat of an elitist snob.

 

It must be nice to suck up to the prison wardens in exchange for a nice and comfortable cell and special privileges, then act disdainful of the rest of your fellow inmates when they choose to riot because they're unhappy with the accomodation, lack of privacy, lack of time in the fresh air, constant supervision etc?

 

Hopefully we can call her out on this at some point?


  • Kimarous, efd731, HeyCal et 3 autres aiment ceci

#189
AshenEndymion

AshenEndymion
  • Members
  • 1 225 messages

Why not have mages in each Chantry within the world? There are already Templars there, so a mage presence shouldn't be taken with that much concern. Instead of carting mages off to a circle tower way far away from their families, they can live and learn in the chantry, in familiar surroundings, whilst still being watched.

 

In what capacity?  Mages are allowed within the Chantry to worship(and I'm sure someone lights the fires)...  But mages as religious leaders?  That idea is the fundamental one behind the schism between the Imperial Chantry and the Andrastian Chantry.  I highly doubt the Andrastian Chantry would ever allow that.



#190
Tevinter Soldier

Tevinter Soldier
  • Members
  • 1 635 messages

I'm reminded of average people who spoke out against rebelling against monarch's or government's arguing about them being selfish and talking as if they should be grateful for what they have and in fact have no right to ask for more. 

 

Their will always be those willing to accept having their rights and independence trodden on in the name of protection, especially so if they have some modicum of power from doing so.

 

Take into account Vivenne's position in the circle as well as her support of the chantry, along with her vanity and it's easy to see why she was more comfortable within the confines of the circle.

 

the rebels of course back an idealism that's solely based around their own liberty, suggesting its selfish is like saying a fast ball is fast. people outside the circles opinions do not matter to the rebels just as the right of mages is not cared about those outsiders.

 

the line about reminding people why their scared of magi, well nobody was crying about the horrible confined conditions of mages themselves, it was "i'm scared of them lock them up" it matters not how they justify locking them up, to the Magi the only reason they are locked up is because the mudanes fear them.....end of story.

 

those unwilling to accept confinement no longer care about those outside it and why should they? to the rebel's their confinement is as much the fault of the average person of thedas as it is the templars themselves. and for those mage that supported the towers the greatest contempt would be reserved.

 

It is in fact lucky that Bioware have chosen not to go as dark as real life, If you look at the atrocities committed in the name of liberty against those who sided with their keepers even their fellow citizens its horrific, Vivienne likely wouldn't be in Inquisition but a ditch somewhere along the imperial highway. 

 

From arson to beatings, to rape, torture and of course murder, lots and lots of murder. some of the punishments carried out by revolutionaries against their own people for supporting the other side are some of the most despicable crimes around and yet for the most part today these self serving blind rebels that only cared about themselves are celebrated by those countries that succeeded in their rebellion.

 

is mage rebellion selfish? yes of course.............. unless you support them then their your people fighting for you. then they are hero's. One man's freedom fighter is another man's terrorist, as they say. 

 

suggesting they should consider the rest of society when it is the rest of society is what keeps them caged is suggesting they should accept the oppressive conditions they are in. bringing up anders and the hit on the divine also misses the point. Nobody listened to the mages or what they wanted.

 

these crimes came about because they were ignored, To them the crimes against them go unpunished. these weren't crimes to the rebel's but protests, forcing people to start listening to them. the rebellion came about because even these protests were met with more oppression. the circle was always doomed to fail because people generally will never accept being ruled over by others, not matter how necessary the others deem it to be.

 

the fact is to the Rebel's Vivienne is the one who is blind and detriment to her own people, a traitor in fact. the problem is we have a habit of looking at things from a 21st century point of view, one where people accept less rights and freedoms in favour of security because of the comforts it affords us. But the less rights people have the more militant they are about them. history is riddled with rebellions that today are considered nuts.

 

hell the us war of independence started over the rate of taxes to pay for a war they demanded. removing yourself from the situation makes the whole thing sound stupid. but the reason was because they had no say in paying those taxes it was a right denied to them.


  • Kimarous, Drasanil, mcsupersport et 7 autres aiment ceci

#191
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages

Vivienne will just be too fabulous and fierce for many it seems.  Gurl knows how to WURK.

tumblr_m61fmiFR761qzl2xuo1_r1_500.gif

In what capacity?  Mages are allowed within the Chantry to worship(and I'm sure someone lights the fires)...  But mages as religious leaders?  That idea is the fundamental one behind the schism between the Imperial Chantry and the Andrastian Chantry.  I highly doubt the Andrastian Chantry would ever allow that.

 

 

Instead of locked in a tower. Bring the Circle to the Chantry. Show a united face. They wouldn't have to be a religious presence, though I can't see how that would hurt things, because people would be able to see tha tyes, magic can actually serve man, and not rule over him.

In what capacity?  Mages are allowed within the Chantry to worship(and I'm sure someone lights the fires)...  But mages as religious leaders?  That idea is the fundamental one behind the schism between the Imperial Chantry and the Andrastian Chantry.  I highly doubt the Andrastian Chantry would ever allow that.



#192
Jaison1986

Jaison1986
  • Members
  • 3 315 messages

I like that she's forthright with her beliefs, even if she does come a cross a somewhat of an elitist snob.

 

It must be nice to suck up to the prison wardens in exchange for a nice and comfortable cell and special privileges, then act disdainful of the rest of your fellow inmates when they choose to riot because they're unhappy with the accomodation, lack of privacy, lack of time in the fresh air, constant supervision etc?

 

Hopefully we can call her out on this at some point?

 

This just about sums it up nicely. She was granted privileges that very few have, and acts dismissive because those below her wanted an better life. She reminds me of an corrupt politician. She will probally be thrown out of the airlock once I get the knight enchanter specialization.


  • Sifr aime ceci

#193
sandalisthemaker

sandalisthemaker
  • Members
  • 5 387 messages

 

tumblr_m61fmiFR761qzl2xuo1_r1_500.gif

 

 

 

YESSS.

 

And she doesn't even need the hair to give off the same impression.


  • eyezonlyii aime ceci

#194
Jackums

Jackums
  • Members
  • 1 479 messages

I think her view is very limited and/or clouded by ambition.



#195
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

 

tumblr_m61fmiFR761qzl2xuo1_r1_500.gif

 

:wub:  :wub:



#196
mikeymoonshine

mikeymoonshine
  • Members
  • 3 493 messages

I'm reminded of average people who spoke out against rebelling against monarch's or government's arguing about them being selfish and talking as if they should be grateful for what they have and in fact have no right to ask for more. 

 

Interesting that you are reminded of that seeing as she didn't say anything at all like that. 

 

 

 

the rebels of course back an idealism that's solely based around their own liberty, suggesting its selfish is like saying a fast ball is fast. people outside the circles opinions do not matter to the rebels just as the right of mages is not cared about those outsiders.

 

 

She didn't say the rebels were selfish for wanting freedom. She said it was selfish to not think about how others outside the circle felt, to oppose an investigation into an assassination attempt on the devine and for the leadership to put all mages at risk by rebelling in that way at that time. 

 

 

 

the line about reminding people why their scared of magi, well nobody was crying about the horrible confined conditions of mages themselves, it was "i'm scared of them lock them up" it matters not how they justify locking them up, to the Magi the only reason they are locked up is because the mudanes fear them.....end of story.

 

That argument is not about justification it is about practicality. Whether you agree with her or not on the issue of mage freedom you have to accept that the mages were not ready for war because they really obviously weren't ready for that. 

 

 

 those unwilling to accept confinement no longer care about those outside it and why should they? to the rebel's their confinement is as much the fault of the average person of thedas as it is the templars themselves. and for those mage that supported the towers the greatest contempt would be reserved.

 

You are ignoring practicality to talk about what is fair and how people are entitled to feel, it doesn't matter. Rebelling when everyone fears and hate you means little in the way of support and allies. Even if they won what is to stop angry mobs killing many of these newly freed mages? How can they survive in an environment like that with no experience in the real world? 

 

 

It is in fact lucky that Bioware have chosen not to go as dark as real life, If you look at the atrocities committed in the name of liberty against those who sided with their keepers even their fellow citizens its horrific, Vivienne likely wouldn't be in Inquisition but a ditch somewhere along the imperial highway. 

 

From arson to beatings, to rape, torture and of course murder, lots and lots of murder. some of the punishments carried out by revolutionaries against their own people for supporting the other side are some of the most despicable crimes around and yet for the most part today these self serving blind rebels that only cared about themselves are celebrated by those countries that succeeded in their rebellion.

 

Yes and those who supported a losing rebellion got much the same treatment. What is your point? 

 

 

the fact is to the Rebel's Vivienne is the one who is blind and detriment to her own people, a traitor in fact. the problem is we have a habit of looking at things from a 21st century point of view, one where people accept less rights and freedoms in favour of security because of the comforts it affords us. But the less rights people have the more militant they are about them. history is riddled with rebellions that today are considered nuts.

 

hell the us war of independence started over the rate of taxes to pay for a war they demanded. removing yourself from the situation makes the whole thing sound stupid. but the reason was because they had no say in paying those taxes it was a right denied to them.

 

Again, these are arguments for why it happened. They are not arguments for why it was a good idea or for why Vivienne is wrong. 



#197
Sifr

Sifr
  • Members
  • 6 788 messages

This just about sums it up nicely. She was granted privileges that very few have, and acts dismissive because those below her wanted an better life. She reminds me of an corrupt politician. She will probally be thrown out of the airlock once I get the knight enchanter specialization.

 

Exactly, her attitude is;

 

"How dare those ingrates complain just because they've not been allowed outside the tower in over a decade! Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go rub elbows with the Empress, the Orlesian nobility and the Divine..."


  • SeekerOfLight, ianvillan, Darkly Tranquil et 7 autres aiment ceci

#198
Gtdef

Gtdef
  • Members
  • 1 330 messages

There is nothing wrong about Vivienne's opinion. She spoke the truth. Only thing mages did was to paint a huge target in their back.


  • HiroVoid et AshenEndymion aiment ceci

#199
Medhia_Nox

Medhia_Nox
  • Members
  • 3 530 messages

So, now she's guilty of having worked for the freedoms other mages just want to kill for.  

 

Fascinating.


  • AshenEndymion, efd731 et Swaggerjking aiment ceci

#200
leaguer of one

leaguer of one
  • Members
  • 9 995 messages

Exactly, her attitude is;

 

"How dare those ingrates complain just because they've not been allowed outside the tower in over a decade! Now if you'll excuse me, I have to go rub elbows with the Empress, the Orlesian nobility and the Divine..."

Well in contrast, the mage could be as dirt poor as most of the people in thedus. You don't like the circle, try living in an alienage or dust town.