Weird he didn't shoot me? Not sure what's going on there. He's buggy at times though once he attacked me when I killed Triss and then on my next game I got a "MacCready hated that" but he didn't start firing like a madman. So *shrug* Oh I like Danse but he's...ugh. If I could call him on it I'd tolerate it more as it is eh. MacCready has been plenty loyal to my PC though. You don't have to be rude to be socially awkward however. Danse is just rude because he is.
"I have something different for you." I've started running away when he tried to give me quests at this point. Oi Vey. Especially egregious when it's a quest that's done in Sanctuary Hills then I'm just "Why can't you do it? Why can't you do this quest?"
I think there is a tolerance threshold. Deacon usually attacks me right away after killing an innocent NPC, but he starts attacks me once it goes down around 3 hates or something. I know people have MacCready and Hancock attack them after Triss killing.
As I said, different taste. I use them both plenty of time, so at this point, I know which I like better. I like Danse's loyalty and his crude way of talking to people. MacCready is just too selfish to bring him around when doing quests since money is not really an issue for me, so I just usually help people for the sake of it. It's just up to how you approach the game. Danse's rudeness is mostly the people you hang out with which are filled with mercenary, synths, ghouls, mutants, etc. He wasn't rude to Cait, Garvey, or Dogmeat. As I bring him along, I understand him a lot more. He doesn't hate all ghouls. He would approve and like for you to help the ghoul kid reunite with his ghoul parent instead of leaving him to die despite knowing that it's pretty dangerous tactically, he also dislikes it if you tell him his parents are dead just to skip over the issue. All MacCready cares about is if he gets paid and like with Cait, he dislikes it if you decide to help the kid. He dislikes cowardly actions and hates bribing as well. I like when he chimes in when I said I would use violence to free the girl by any mean necessary, he also said by any mean necessary. I tell a guy to man up in a bar fight and he likes it while saying I hold my own in barfight makes him loves it.Yeah, he's basically the choice if you want to have someone upright and no shady activity. Who revolves violence through righteous and straight forward means instead of cowardice or shady. No one can change each other's mind on these two either ways, we just have different playstyle. I just find Danse to be a jerk with a heart of gold. He may say rude things, but he doesn't stand for bad behaviors.