6 réponses à ce sujet

[Stronglav]

Where the nazis portraid as "good guys"

The poor soldiers who just followed orders.

 

Such as:Generation War.

 

https://www.youtube....h?v=ShaVle8SiO8

 

It is discussting.

 

So spill your opinions here.

[mybudgee]

* Disgusting

[Giant ambush beetle]

You do know that most soldiers were indeed following orders and weren't blind followers of that tyrannic regime, right? They had little choice, back then refusing conscription or simply badmouthing the Führer meant being shot in the head or being put into a concentration camp.

I've read books about the war written from German soldiers at the eastern front and I can tell you that many didn't feel very enthusiastic about that war at all.

[Fidite Nemini]

You seem to have a loose definition of "latest". That linked TV series is from March 2013. And I from what I've read just now, it most certainly didn't paint Nazis as good guys. The controversy that particular series spawned was because it depictured a clear distinction between Nazis and the "normal" Germans which is historically incorrect.

[Aimi]

The controversy that particular series spawned was because it depictured a clear distinction between Nazis and the "normal" Germans which is historically incorrect.

I agree. The distinction isn't historically incorrect; nobody except Daniel Goldhagen thinks that. What was incorrect about Unsere Mütter, unsere Väter was, like you said, just how stark that distinction was portrayed as having been. They turned what seemed like every young German in the miniseries into a White Rose member.

There was also the whole thing about the portrayal of the Polish Home Army as antisemitic, which I thought spawned a far more serious wave of criticism.

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Don't know about latest German war movies, but 'Downfall' and 'Stalingrad' are great.

[Lotion Soronarr]

My reaction?

 

"It's about time."