97 réponses à ce sujet

[Notshauna]

For my Qunari no, she's lost too much to either bring herself to do that, it'd absolutely KILL her if Sera did that. As for my Elf, maybe, it depends on how  Josephine betrayed her and the Inquisition but, I super double doubt it'll happen, but if she has to she will. For my Human, yes, absolutely, you don't betray the person who trusts you most, she'd see Cullen as dead to her and try and rectify his continued existence.

[Mrs_Stick]

 Yes. I wouldn't give it a second thought.

You and your violent ways...I love it...

[Giant ambush beetle]

Yes real betrayal, not a hey this sucks I'm leaving. No I mean some sort of act or action that cause great harm towards you and the entire Inquisition as a whole.

That basically makes that somebody an enemy, worse even. I don't know how anyone could spare such scum, not only would it put the whole organization at risk because it makes you look like you take betrayal lightly, it would also show that you, the leader, are heavily compromised by emotions and selfishness.
Anything other than public execution should result in an immediate loss of your troops trust and ultimately your leadership.

I'm not a big fan of torture and messy vengeance though, it would look like all your decisions are clouded by emotions and as a leader you cannot afford such weakness. You have to keep a cool head, think purely logically, far ahead and your decisions have to benefit the greater good.

[kalasaurus]

No.

 

If there was an option to kick his ass and take him to task for betraying my character, yes.  If he is genuinely contrite for it would my Inquisitor forgive him, yes.  Would he have to kiss ass to get back into my quizzie's good graces, definitely.

 

There is a similar situation in one of the SWToR storylines, where a companion you romance betrays you.  Since he's the healer, killing him (and there was an option to kill him in Beta) is kind of like shooting yourself in the foot.  They adjusted it to you can 1) forgive him and make him go back to earning your trust or 2) bring him back, but sever the relationship.

 

I'd be content with that arrangement.

 

Spoiler

My Sith was in a romance with him and first force choked him before forgiving him.  He was still surprised at her mercy .

 

That was more in line with her character, though, since I went all dark side XD.

 

I guess it depends on how I roleplay my character and how I'd have her react.  I couldn't bring myself to kill a romanced Anders (in fact, I've only killed him on one playthrough to finish the Sebastian romance).  I just don't like killing companions if I can avoid it.

[ZerioctheTank]

:'( this is after my emotional breakdown right? Because both my Inquisitor & me IRL will be sobbing into our respective beds for at least a week. It would depend on what they did honestly. Not every betrayal needs to be paid in blood.

Don't get me started on Anders......he.....sorry it is different.

[RobRam10]

[Yermogi]

I... don't know. Maybe? Depends on the character I'm playing.

 

Actually, I'm going to say yes, just because I, as a player, would really want to see things tied up as far as a relationship goes.

[robertmarilyn]

I'd need all the details I could get before I could decide what I'd do. Without more to go on than I have now, I'd say that I wouldn't execute a loved one who betrayed me. 

[Hazegurl]

They tried with Morrigan and Anders. With Morrigan I never got the whole "You deceived me" bs. She was very open and honest and the Warden could have turned her down. With Anders, i felt that perhaps they should made Anders confess what he would do to a Friend Hawke and then let them decide if they wanted to help or not.

 

For this game, it would depend on how it is handled and whether I agree with it or not. If they flat out undermined what I am doing then they will die without question.

[Finnuval]

It would depend a little on wether the betrayel you speak of would be aimed against the Inquisition (kinda like Ander's betrayel is aimed against the chantry but possibly harms me) or if it is truly personal, let's say... I've played you from the beginning, romancing you just to get close to you but it was always my plan to harm or assassinate you...

 

In the first situation I would track him (or her) down, get answers and then give him a clean and mercifull death.

In the second situation I would hunt him (or her) to the ends of the earth and tear him limb from limb and feed him to a Mabari.

 

ofcourse in any playthrough after that I would choose completely different 'cause I want to see all possibilities play out eventually

[veeia]

For me personally, no. I'm not about killing people, or spending my time on vengeance. I mean, if there was time and the act was horrible enough, I'd be down for chasing them down to figure out why they did it/find some justice.

 

But it depends on the character. I can see some characters not being able to see past hurt pride and literally stopping in the middle of the final battle to go hunt down their LI.  

 

...reaaaallly hope there's not some big, not foreshadowed, unforgivable and unavoidable betrayal though. 

[themugen]

Simple answer : yea.  I'd feel conflicted killing Sera, but then again there's always Josie to offer comfort.   

[Doll]

Manual save -> STAB STAB -> load -> try and salvage the achievement

 

In all honestly though it really would depend on my Inquisitor and their attitude. The reason I didn't get the trophy for the romance the first time in DA2 was because my Hawke romanced Anders, from the way I had her character in my head I imagined she felt betrayed that Anders tricked her into helping him and got revenge. She was a bitter one...

[Hair Serious Business]

Well they did said they took romances to "next level" and made them more "realistic" not just classical Shepard's reference "We will bang...ok?"

And honestly I do wish something like this happened.This would be realistic if you are in love-hate relationship with someone or as they said some of your choices will greatly affect both story and some of your companions later on...perhaps you will do "wrong call" for some of them and they will decided that betraying you...idk?

Still would be interesting thing if it happened it is "realistic" thing to happen afterall...not everyone is your loyal dog no matter what and not everyone will just walk away if you p*ss them off and it would make things even more interesting and dramatic as well if someone you love stabbed you with knife in back.

 

(And I think we both know what story had something like this...)

 

[NoForgiveness]

Depends on the betrayal, if she(Sera or cass) stabs me and runs off... no won't bother. If she steals info and sells it to the enemy, which leads to a village or even inquisition forces being massacred or something... then ya, and I'd probably attempt to kill her myself(or my character's self).

[Commander Rpg]

It depends on the situation. I forgave Isabela for what she did, not knowing if she'd ever come back, because she was nice to have around, smart and bla bla bla.

If it would happen in a point where the safety of my party is endangered, and the person being a sleek calculating bastard, I'd do a whole execution on public square, exposing her to public ridicule before death.

[Apostate.]

It depends on the situation. I forgave Isabela for what she did, not knowing if she'd ever come back, because she was nice to have around, smart and bla bla bla.

If it would happen in a point where the safety of my party is endangered, and the person being a sleek calculating bastard, I'd do a whole execution on public square, exposing her to public ridicule before death.

The message would be received I imagine.

[TheLastArchivist]

****. If I love the person and he loves me, and my beloved has been through the worst of the Inquisition beside me, then his betrayal must have a VERY good reason behind it.

 

First, I'd go after him to get some explanations. Then, I'd demand to know what the hell happened to make him change his mind so abruptly. I mean, he could've done this for a million reasons. He could've been coerced. What if by betraying me, he managed to ransom a relative kidnapped by the servants of the Elder One? Or avoided his home village being razed to the ground by an enemy's army? I don't know. 

 

For a person to stand beside you in something so black and white as an inquisition, where your loyalties are clearly defined, people simply won't wake up one morning and think: This is it. I've had enough of ths crap. I'm switching sides! This is war. It's not like picking a fight with a friend because he likes to use plastic instead of paper bags in the supermarket. Or drink Pepsi instead of Coke. This is some serious ****.

 

You can be court-martialled for this. You can be sent to prison and rot in there for the rest of your (now) miserable life. You can be hanged. You can be beheaded. You can be forced to commit suicide.There are some motherfreaking consequences for treason during wartimes. So I seriously doubt someone would take the initiative to become involved with the Inquisitor unless he knew firsthand full well where he stood in the war.

 

The alternative would be for him to be a spy or double agent hellbent on working against you. Then it would be the brig or death penalty if the chance for him to escape were considerable. But in this last case, there were no true love for starters, so screw him and his backstabbing. 

 

 

So yes, I'd go after him. But not to kill him. Because for such a drastic change to take place, I'd believe until the last minute, 'till the last second, that he was backed so badly into a wall that he was left with simply no other choice. And then, if I managed to learn the truth somehow, then I'd kill the son of a b.... that put him in this whole mess in the first place. 

[WarriorOfLight999]

It all depends.

 

If it's strictly limited to personal boundaries, then no.

 

If the betrayal extends to jeopardizing lives or empowering the Elder One? Yes, I would. My personal life or feelings mean little in the face of saving existence.

[Coverage]

The mission of the Inquisition is way too important for my character to place love or personal emotions above the well being of the organization and charges under his command. So yes, if the love interest actively betrayed the Inquisition in a way that either harms or is likely to bring harm to the group then they would likely have to die.

 

If it is more of a personal betrayal that doesn't actively involve the Inquisition then that's a different matter entirely, and the outcome would depend on the specific situation.

[LightningPoodle]

Yes. Betrayal... there can be no return...

[Apostate.]

Yes. Betrayal... there can be no return...

...There will be blood?

[LightningPoodle]

...There will be blood?

 

Sure, why not. Add a little spice into life.

[Reznore57]

I've spared Anders and he wasn't my LI...

I wanted to punch him in the face though.

 

I think I would lose my cool if my LI would kill another companion I really like , depending on the circumstance I could go murder knife.

But the situation would really need to push all my buttons.