To be fair it's a little difficult to come up with such plans when your being attacked by Templars.
Which, while somewhat understandable, does little to encourage me to see your side as the best way into the future.
What I'm aiming for is the temporary suffering of a minority for a greater good that's better for everyone. We also haven't seen the revolution at all beyond its very beginnings.
Ultimately, after having thought about it, this isn't about me starting a rebellion; if I was in that situation myself, I'd have looked for other solutions before massive bloodshed ideally (having Lambert and his supporters assassinated might be an acceptable start). What it's about is why I have to support the rebellion now that it's here.
We have seen the revolution. It's right there in Hinterlands, among the stabbed, sliced, charred and frozen corpses of refugees.
As for who we're supporting from now on... well, like I said before, my dwarf has no emotional attachment to the debacle. He'll listen to the guys with the best plans for the future.
She's in another country. Expecting her to personally stop this is like expecting FDR to personally bring the hammer down on war criminals in the Pacific, except even more difficult due to the lack of a decent communications network.
It is one of the examples of "not realizing that actions have consequences" we've talked about in the Vivienne thread though.