1428 réponses à ce sujet

[General TSAR]

Yep.

 

I support all loyalist brothers and sisters who carry the sword of mercy, Red Templars need to get their sh.t together and stop being dicks.

[Asari_Party]

The very premise of the Templars is built on rotten foundations, and the order is simply not worth saving imo. I'd like to see the Circles actually become what they should have been: schools, and not prisons.

[Uccio]

FREEEEEDOOOOOOOOOM!!!!!

 

 

Mages obviously. Templars need to burn in the just fire of the mages.

 

Templars are made by men, they can be unmade.

[raging_monkey]

FREEEEEDOOOOOOOOOM!!!!!
 
 
Mages obviously. Templars need to burn in the just fire of the mages.
 
Templars are made by men, they can be unmade.

then remade into something fair and just

[Inquisitor Archaeon]

I would be indifferent to the conflict, most likely. Unless I was a mage myself, I suppose. 

 

I'd just want the conflict to be over so we can focus on the true threat: the Breach and the demons.

[Catche Jagger]

This conflict is one I am rather... conflicted about. All human organizations are bound to decay and grow corrupt down the line, this holds true for both the templars as well as the mages. The templar order, or any order designed to police a specific group, is inevitably bound to grow more and more zealous as years pass. However, without the Templars to police them, it seems unlikely that all of the mages will just sit around and let the mundies keep doing what they're doing, and even more importantly, it's unlikely that they'll just refrain from communing with demons as an act of goodwill. Allowing the mages free reign of themselves is as absurd as trying to put the exact same system back in place. Neither will work in the long run. There needs to be some sort of compromise made, a way to give the mages some more freedom while maintaining the necessary oversight.

[Sir DeLoria]

Those darned mages can pry my holy sword from my cold dead hands!!

[Sir DeLoria]

Templars are made by men, they can be unmade.

So are mages.

In fact most of these nerdy wimps can be unmade far more easily.

[lordsaren101]

Dumat loves templars, their bones work great as toothpicks for him.

[FromMyths]

I stand where the good guys are, whether they're a Templar or a Mage.

Both Templars and Mages show so many bad points, that the few good people in their groups end up getting caught in the chaos. So I stand with those guys; it'd take more years than my Inquisitor most likely can live before either of those hard-headed fractions can reach a compromise.

[The Elder King]

Dumat loves templars, their bones work as great toothpicks for him.

I'm neutral, but this made me laugh .

[RobRam10]

Mages

[KainD]

Hope that the templars would eradicate every single blood mage they see. No excuses. Even your post confirms how fall they are with a selfish ambitions to rule. Good thing there orders like the templars and seekers.

 

Not for long, and not against the truly worthy.

[HiroVoid]

Magars.  Templars with magic.

[KainD]

then remade into something fair and just

 

Like slaves to the mages. 

[KainD]

Magars.  Templars with magic.

 

Templars ARE with magic, that's what lyrium does, makes them able to do some magic. Regular templars go for the spirit/anti-magic skill tree to fight mages. Red templars are not so picky, they can throw fireballs as well now. 

[Inprea]

On a pile of templar corpses.

 

Just kidding that would stink to high heaven after a short while and make for poor footing. I'm more pro mage then I'm anti-templar though when I think of a templar taking a child from a mother just because she's a mage I just want to behead every templar that laid a hand upon that child, gave an order or stood by and did nothing.

 

Due to my view on rights of the individual and children I see the entire templar order as guilty of crimes against humanity.

[KingTony]

On a pile of templar corpses.

Just kidding that would stink to high heaven after a short while and make for poor footing. I'm more pro mage then I'm anti-templar though when I think of a templar taking a child from a mother just because she's a mage I just want to behead every templar that laid a hand upon that child, gave an order or stood by and did nothing.

Due to my view on rights of the individual and children I see the entire templar order as guilty of crimes against humanity.

It would be better if the mother was allowed to keep the child for a few more years until it succumbed to posession and destroyed the whole village, wouldn't it?

[Grimmdead]

Choosing the Templar's for the most part

[GodBrandon]

100% templar. Mages should be locked up in the tower forever.

[raging_monkey]

Seriously for a MT thread theres little passionate arguments, insult, even pass-aggro remarks... im kinda bummed and glad XD

[Grimmdead]

Seriously for a MT thread theres little passionate arguments, insult, even pass-aggro remarks... im kinda bummed and glad XD

 

Well most of it is probably pulling from the fact there are not many DA forum visitors logged in at this time, because most people are running through their games looking for something that might spark a genius level thread topic on *spoiler* like possibilities 

 

And in the long run we don't have enough lore to dive deep into the origins of the circles and why we feel locking mages up from everyone else is a necessary evil, rather then a way of policing and keeping untrained mages from accidentally harming others. 

 

Personally I believe that the census is that Templars are necessary for the safety of both the mages and for the non mages of thedas. I sort of view them as i would a Militia group, military based as needed, with the backing of religious values and teachings. its hard to say yes or no in the long scheme of things because there are mages that most mages are good, but there are bad apples in the mixture... and there are templars who are just far too blind to see the good.

[StrangeStrategy]

Pro-Circle. Its the only way I can see everyone being happy.

Side with the mages 100%, and you get Tevinter 2.0. You know, the land of "lets sacrifice our elven slave so we can entertain our guests!" and "Ohh that guy looked at me funny. Lets kill him with magic."

 

Side with the Templars and you get poor Mages being mistreated, even when they've done nothing wrong. That eventually leads to bitterness and rebellion.

 

Pro-Circle is a compromise.

[lordsaren101]

Mages are the master race. I say all mundanes should be caged, or at best be used as slaves.

[raging_monkey]

Its been stated that tevinter isnt a pancea for magi and that tevinter's culture is magic centric so the southern states are unlikely to go that route