Aller au contenu

Photo

A Request for Demisexuality in Bioware Games


1942 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

*
MESSAGE POPULAIRE !

Hello Bioware, 
 
I am writing this thread to offer a suggestion I would like to see for future Bioware games. Bioware has been very representative of the various sexualities that exist in the world. From introducing homosexual women characters with Juhani in Knights of the Old Republic, to introducing bisexual characters with Silk Fox and Sky in Jade Empire, to introducing homosexual male characters with Steve Cortez in Mass Effect 3, to introducing pansexual characters with The Iron Bull, and even thinking of possibly introducing an asexual character in a future title. With such an impressive resume for representation, I would like to humbly suggest that in the future Bioware also adds demisexual characters as well. 
 
For those reading this and do not know what demisexuality is, I will post the explanations below: 
 
A demisexual is a person who does not experience sexual attraction unless they form a strong emotional connection with someone. It's more commonly seen in but by no means confined to romantic relationships. The term demisexual comes from the orientation being "halfway between" sexual and asexual. Nevertheless, this term does not mean that demisexuals have an incomplete or half-sexuality, nor does it mean that sexual attraction without emotional connection is required for a complete sexuality. In general, demisexuals are not sexually attracted to anyone of any gender; however, when a demisexual is emotionally connected to someone else (whether the feelings are romantic love or deep friendship), the demisexual experiences sexual attraction and desire, but only towards the specific partner or partners.
 
When describing demisexuality as an orientation to sexuals, sexuals often mistake it as an admirable choice rather than an innate orientation. Demisexuals are not choosing to abstain; they simply lack sexual attraction until a close relationship is formed.
 
According to one hypothetical model, a person who identifies as a demisexual does not experience primary sexual attraction but does experience secondary sexual attraction. In this model, primary sexual attraction is based on outward qualities such as a person's looks, clothes, or personality while secondary sexual attraction is attraction stemming from a connection, usually romantic, or from status or how closely the person is in relationship to the other.
 
Though factors such as looks and personality do not affect primary sexual attraction for demisexuals (since demisexuals do not experience primary sexual attraction), such factors may affect romantic attraction, as with any other orientation.
 
Primary vs Secondary Sexual Attraction Model
Spoiler
 
"Demisexual" is sometimes out under the gray-A umbrella. Demisexuality differs from gray-asexuality in that demisexuality is a specific sexual orientation in between "sexual" and "asexual", whereas "gray-A" is a highly unspecific catch-all used for anything between sexual and asexual that does not fit.
 
Demisexuality may make forming romantic or sexual relationships more difficult for some people. Demisexuals often make first impressions with sexuals of being "just friends", which may make them sexually value the relationship less.
 
Demis may also append a gender orientation to the label, as in "Demi-heterosexual".
 
If you still do not understand, here are explanations of what demisexuality is and how to tell if a person(or character in this case) is one. Due to length, I will have these in spoilers:

 

What is Demisexuality?
Spoiler

 

Telling if you/someone is demisexual:
Spoiler
 
To Bioware and whoever else is reading this, I appreciate the time you took to do so. Please feel free to add any input you wish. Thank you. 

  • Remmirath, In Exile, Shazzie et 49 autres aiment ceci

#2
LonewandererD

LonewandererD
  • Members
  • 480 messages

I doubt they'll put this in. Too large of a consumer base to account for what is one of the more of the obscure sexualities. If you want to RP a demisexual individual, or romance one, just headcanon it. Also, I think Vivienne might count as our asexual choice as she seems to have to no interest in such things, they just get in the way of the important stuff.

 

-D-


  • Rolenka, Lightpanda, HK-90210 et 9 autres aiment ceci

#3
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages
My biggest question is how would you portray this in a game? Could you write a sample conversation or an overview of the romance arc to give more detail? I'll be honest, I had never heard of this until you brought it up in the other thread, so I really have a hard time defining this as a separate sexuality as opposed to...something else. I don't have the vocabulary to accurately reflect what I'm trying to express.
  • Heimdall, Lightpanda, Aimi et 13 autres aiment ceci

#4
Asdrubael Vect

Asdrubael Vect
  • Members
  • 1 507 messages

if demi-sexuality Li means that character will romance and sleep only with someone who is somethink like that character(commons beliefs, race, mage/non-mage, respect what they do)

 

 

i am all ok with that as with race and faction(some chantry templar girl will not romance rebellion mage male) restricted romances



#5
JadePrince

JadePrince
  • Members
  • 851 messages

As much as you and I may disagree on certain topics, I think Bioware would be doing a good thing by including demisexuality in their games. I remember we even proposed some dialogue for it a while back. If you can find it, you should definitely post it. I liked it a lot and thought it could be a potentially really lovely/romantic/sweet romantic path.


  • RevilFox, Hanako Ikezawa, werqhorse et 4 autres aiment ceci

#6
karushna5

karushna5
  • Members
  • 1 620 messages

Wow. I never knew you were a demisexual Kallen.

 

It can be weird because at some point you go "nope never going to be attracted to anybody" and then somehow someone walks into your life and it gets confusing. Like some people count the people they have dated, and I have always counted the people I have been sexually attracted to. (2) I honestly thought girls were just like that and my friends were pretending as the idea of sexual attraction was just so bizzare to me.

 

Like the idea of sex seems so terrible that for men it seems worse than death itself, and for a woman I am not with something absolutely horrible. And even in a relationship, sex is something on an inward timer in my head. Been three days, it is time for sex because sexuals really need that stuff. It helps being with someone that never pressures you and always allows you to make the first move, but the number of times it feels like you both are into it is pretty rare.

 

I mean I feel like there are the long terms most people don't understand. Homoromantic Demisexual, and somethings seem to have more effect on my life (****** in homoromantic pretty much has defined where I am at now in life of no choice of my own so I usually associate with lesbian) but I never heard someone but it so well. The different feelings involved.

 

The hard part with characters is they never can use terms (even gay and straight characters just imply) so it might be hard to implement. How would you suggest how a character like this could be shown without actually using the terminology?


  • RevilFox, Hanako Ikezawa, BraveVesperia et 2 autres aiment ceci

#7
veeia

veeia
  • Members
  • 4 986 messages
Merrill could easily be read as biromantic demisexual, IMO. In fact I think Kallen did until Gaider called her bisexual, right? I wonder if its possible he just isn't that informed on the concept of demisexuality. Quite possible he'd agree that she is.
  • jellobell, Zveroferma, Hanako Ikezawa et 7 autres aiment ceci

#8
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

Merrill could easily be read as biromantic demisexual, IMO. In fact I think Kallen did until Gaider called her bisexual, right? I wonder if its possible he just isn't that informed on the concept of demisexuality. Quite possible he'd agree that she is.

 

Merrill technically is that, or demi-bisexual as I read it when I looked it up


  • Zveroferma, DeathScepter et EmperorKarino aiment ceci

#9
karushna5

karushna5
  • Members
  • 1 620 messages

Aveline may be one as well, she never seems to comment on anyone else than her husbands and seems very very awkward at wooing.


  • Zveroferma, DeathScepter, Chari et 2 autres aiment ceci

#10
veeia

veeia
  • Members
  • 4 986 messages

Im on my phone and sausage finger smashed that post to publish before I was done :lol: 

 

So to add, I just wanted to say I support this wholeheartedly. :)

 

And my only advice to the writers would be to do your research and be very careful with how you write it if it's with a LI, because there is a possibility that such a narrative could imply that the LI was asexual but the player "fixed" that or is a special exception because of their playerness...which is pretty hurtful to asexual folk. Maybe a way to avoid this is to have the player not be the first person they've fallen for. 


  • werqhorse aime ceci

#11
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

Aveline may be one as well, she never seems to comment on anyone else than her husbands and seems very very awkward at wooing.

 

Aveline is Aveline :P


  • DeathScepter et EmperorKarino aiment ceci

#12
veeia

veeia
  • Members
  • 4 986 messages

Awkwardness isn't inherently demisexual. Aveline's discomfort around flirtation probably has a lot to do with her insecurity about her perceived lack of femininity (as revealed through her conversations with Isabela), as well as the way she compartmentalizes personal/private. She could be, but I find it more uncomfortable to cite her awkwardness there, as opposed to Merrill's, because it does seemed linked to her gender identity expression...which is separate from sexuality.

 

I wouldn't argue with anyone who wanted to headcanon it, that is, but just my two cents. :) 


  • Zveroferma, RevilFox, werqhorse et 4 autres aiment ceci

#13
RevilFox

RevilFox
  • Members
  • 507 messages

Merrill technically is that, or demi-bisexual as I read it when I looked it up

Merrill does nothing in game to exclude herself from being demi, but Word of God states she's bi.


  • DeathScepter aime ceci

#14
karushna5

karushna5
  • Members
  • 1 620 messages

Awkwardness isn't inherently demisexual. Aveline's discomfort around flirtation probably has a lot to do with her insecurity about her perceived lack of femininity (as revealed through her conversations with Isabela), as well as the way she compartmentalizes personal/private. She could be, but I find it more uncomfortable to cite her awkwardness there, as opposed to Merrill's, because it does seemed linked to her gender identity expression...which is separate from sexuality.

 

I wouldn't argue with anyone who wanted to headcanon it, that is, but just my two cents. :)

 

For this reason I am usually more into headcanons as trying to implement it without inserting the idea that people's sexuality can be "fixed" is hard to do without being explicit. I would love to see it but I am Demisexual and have no idea how it would work in a video game.



#15
veeia

veeia
  • Members
  • 4 986 messages

Merrill does nothing in game to exclude herself from being demi, but Word of God states she's bi.

 

Yeah, in this case I have no problem throwing Word of God aside, because it honestly sounds like he was using the best words he knew to describe her and his vocabulary might be limited. These are fairly new concepts (I mean to have concrete words for, obviously demisexuals have always existed), especially to people who are over 30. (...which I'm assuming he is). A lot of people are going to view demisexuality as a liminal thing---halfway between asexual & sexual, and open to any of the romantic inclinations, and not quite know how to use it as its own concept. Which I am sure is very frusrating, but keep educating and  I think people will learn. I'm sure this thread has already educated a lot of people. :)

 

I could be wrong, he could be like "eff you Merrill is bisexual and no demi about it", but....honestly, with whats in the text? It's a perfectly valid reading, so, eff you, hypothetical jerkface Gaider. :P


  • RevilFox, Hanako Ikezawa, werqhorse et 5 autres aiment ceci

#16
Bipster

Bipster
  • Members
  • 118 messages

As I've said in the KISA thread, I am always 100% up for diversity in romances. I think a demisexual romance/LI could make for a very interesting kind of love story, one that we haven't yet seen in a Bioware game before. 

 

I feel like to do it convincingly though, Bioware would have to change up their romance formula a little bit, and do some research in order to create a faithful portrayal. 

 



#17
Gothfather

Gothfather
  • Members
  • 1 415 messages

 

Hello Bioware, 
 
I am writing this thread to offer a suggestion I would like to see for future Bioware games. Bioware has been very representative of the various sexualities that exist in the world. From introducing homosexual women characters with Juhani in Knights of the Old Republic, to introducing bisexual characters with Silk Fox and Sky in Jade Empire, to introducing homosexual male characters with Steve Cortez in Mass Effect 3, to introducing pansexual characters with The Iron Bull, and even thinking of possibly introducing an asexual character in a future title. With such an impressive resume for representation, I would like to humbly suggest that in the future Bioware also adds demisexual characters as well. 
 
/snip

 

How could they write this into a story so that it would be truly representational and not just a situation where people precieve it as a hetero or gay or Bi character that just needs to "warm" up to you first before things progressed?

 

I am not equating demisexuals to the above, I am asking how could they be representated as unique in their own right in a story without either going into a monologue of their sexual orientation or without people thinking oh that character is just a [blank]sexual who takes things slow and wants to get to know someone first before taking the plunge relationship wise.

 

Since the cues we get about OTHER peoples sexuality are external because we can't read peoples minds, how do you present demisexuality in a story? With [blank]sexualities like gay or pan you can have the character make comments about their attraction to so and so. And this can give some major clues to their orientation. With Demisexuals how would you do that? I mean it would be odd  to have them say 'I don't find so and so attractive' just randomly. I mean i don't comment on how i am not attracted to the majority of the world i am not attracted to.

 

This is not an attack I just honestly don't know how you could do this in a game without it feeling forced or clunky or token-esque. Whats better its absence or it done poorly? Yes admitting that Done well is the best option but given the choice which is better?


  • Annos Basin, Lady Nuggins et MonsterSobStory aiment ceci

#18
Hanako Ikezawa

Hanako Ikezawa
  • Members
  • 29 692 messages

As much as you and I may disagree on certain topics, I think Bioware would be doing a good thing by including demisexuality in their games. I remember we even proposed some dialogue for it a while back. If you can find it, you should definitely post it. I liked it a lot and thought it could be a potentially really lovely/romantic/sweet romantic path.

You mean these?

 


Probably there would be some awkward flirting, most from the Player Character--maybe entirely from the player character. This kind of ambiguous sexuality / demisexuality makes me think it would take longer to develop and be more heavily based on their approval rating of the PC. This would be adifficult LI to get with, I think. Eventually, the PC would have to confront or ask the SA / demisexual.

 

PC: Look, I think I've made it pretty clear that I'm into you. Do you... feel the same way?

LI: I... I don't know!

PC: You... don't know.

LI: It isn't that easy! I've never... I've never felt like this. For anyone. So I don't know.

PC: Okay, it's okay. I'm not trying to... push you into anything. I promise.

LI: I know, I know, I just... I need time.

PC: Well, if you figure it out, let me know? I'll be waiting.

 

And then once either the approval rating gets high enough, the romance flag gets flicked and it's all ahead full. The character could be available to both genders and still have an ambiguous sexuality / be demisexual in their own mind, which is the important part.


This sounds like an awesome example of dialogue! I'd love to see a character like that!  :) Plus it lets the player feel extra special because they really get to be that person's "The One". 

 

I'd add: 

PC: Is it because I'm a woman/man?

LI: No, no! I mean, it's not that, I swear. I don't... I don't think that matters to me. It's just...

PC: It's okay, you don't have to explain. Just... tell me if I'm making you uncomfortable or if you want me to leave you alone?

LI: *blushing a little* No, it's okay... you don't have to stop, just... give me some time to figure things out?

 

I feel like it's important to get some dialogue in there that confirms that they aren't just confused heterosexuals. 

 

Again, what matters most to me is that homophobic straight players can't sh*t on me for thinking the LI is non-straight, you know? I get enough of that in the rest of the media I consume. :/


  • Nerys, karushna5, Karach_Blade et 5 autres aiment ceci

#19
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages

You mean these?

 

If I didn't know what the background of what those conversations was about, and it popped up in the game, I would honestly think they were confused [insert]sexual here. Not saying that that's what a demisexual is, just how an outsider might view that dialogue. Maybe, change the "I've never felt this way before" to one that describes a past relationship a bit more, just so we can get a better grasp on where this character is coming from. 


  • tesla21 aime ceci

#20
Gothfather

Gothfather
  • Members
  • 1 415 messages

You mean these?

 

See I read those and Demisexual does not at all spring to mind. I don't know if you can have representation when most people don't even realise its being represented.

 

Just to be clear I support representation of people's sexuality, but I think its important to do it well. I think its better not to have representation then to have poor representation, but other people might disagree. And frankly I don't know what the right answer is.


  • olgaroni et MonsterSobStory aiment ceci

#21
Uprising

Uprising
  • Members
  • 39 messages
I'd like to know how a demisex character would be. From what I understand a bisexual LI do the job.

EDIT: dont mind, didnt see previous posts on my phone.

#22
RevilFox

RevilFox
  • Members
  • 507 messages

Yeah, in this case I have no problem throwing Word of God aside, because it honestly sounds like he was using the best words he knew to describe her and his vocabulary might be limited. These are fairly new concepts (I mean to have concrete words for, obviously demisexuals have always existed), especially to people who are over 30. (...which I'm assuming he is). A lot of people are going to view demisexuality as a liminal thing---halfway between asexual & sexual, and open to any of the romantic inclinations, and not quite know how to use it as its own concept. Which I am sure is very frusrating, but keep educating and  I think people will learn. I'm sure this thread has already educated a lot of people. :)

 

I could be wrong, he could be like "eff you Merrill is bisexual and no demi about it", but....honestly, with whats in the text? It's a perfectly valid reading, so, eff you, hypothetical jerkface Gaider. :P

I actually agree with you, for the most part, but I know Kallen doesn't.

 

There's a visual novel for iOS devices called...uh..Roomates, I think. One of the characters is Bi and another Pan, and that game does pretty much the best job I've ever seen describing the difference between the two.



#23
JadePrince

JadePrince
  • Members
  • 851 messages

See I read those and Demisexual does not at all spring to mind. I don't know if you can have representation when most people don't even realise its being represented.

 

Just to be clear I support representation of people's sexuality, but I think its important to do it well. I think its better not to have representation then to have poor representation, but other people might disagree. And frankly I don't know what the right answer is.

 

Yeah, it's difficult because that dialogue might resonate with some people but completely go over the heads of others. The challenge is to present demi-sexuality in such a way that it 'counts' as representation to the people who care about it, but without having to use the word "demisexual" in game (since it would be just as out of place as one of the characters in DA calling themselves 'heterosexual' or 'gay'-- correct me if I'm wrong but those words are never actually spoken in the games, right? Because those are modern terms that don't really fit the language of Thedas?). 


  • drummerchick et veeia aiment ceci

#24
Gothfather

Gothfather
  • Members
  • 1 415 messages

Yeah, it's difficult because that dialogue might resonate with some people but completely go over the heads of others. The challenge is to present demi-sexuality in such a way that it 'counts' as representation to the people who care about it, but without having to use the word "demisexual" in game (since it would be just as out of place as one of the characters in DA calling themselves 'heterosexual' or 'gay'-- correct me if I'm wrong but those words are never actually spoken in the games, right? Because those are modern terms that don't really fit the language of Thedas?). 

 

I can't recall anyone using those terms. Hell in DA2 i can't recall anyone actually using terminology that suggested they were even bi with the exception of Isabela. If you are male Anders mentions he fancies men but its not implicit that he also fancies women. And if you are a woman I don't recall he mentions he likes men. This is how I remember things. Only Isabela as I recall mentions past lovers some are men and some are women so you can't play the game without realising she fancies both men and women. In DA:O it was different I think Zevran brings this up as a matter of course and Leliana does as you explore deeper into her past as a bard. But in DA2 it was different I never even knew Fenris was a Romance option let alone his orientation till after my first playthrough and then only because I read he was an option.

 

I never presued any of the romances in DA2 like i did in DA:O so once the romances started maybe there was dialogue that contradicts my experiences.

 

That dialogue could also resonate with someone who is has a type of woman/man they like and now someone not their type has got them confussed because they are attracted to this person. It could be read as someone who identified themself as hertro experiencing their first same sex attraction and being confussed or vis versa. It could be someone who is just likes to take things slow and is confused at what they should do. Do they let the romance progress quickly or wait? And if they wait will they lose the person they are attracted to? If they go quickly will they be respected? Being confussed about a relationship is such a common situation that spans the gambit of orientations that it simply doesn't convey, oh that person is Demisexual, at all. People who are confused often use impercise words to express themselves as well so the exact wording can't be used as an obvious marker.



#25
veeia

veeia
  • Members
  • 4 986 messages

That's why I think it would be best if the LI knew what they were about, instead of the PC being their first and the one who made them feel this way. Can't be confused with orientation confusion if the LI isn't confused. It also wouldn't feed into the stereotype of the demisexual as "just a normal person who wants a special snowflake romance"


  • Natureguy85, eyezonlyii et JadePrince aiment ceci