I would like to know what is the code of the Chevaliers concerning allegiance? I couldn't quite understand in the book how fomenting a coup against you liege was not against their "honor" code. Anyway the Chevalier code means nothing to me, considering one of their final test is to go killing elves randomly in an alienage to prove what "tough" soldiers they are. Right.
I also don't understand what are his credentials for being a good leader. I think I've said that before in another thread, but being a good soldier or general is not a guarantee that you'll be a good ruler (I'm looking at you Loghain, and I do love you). We know Celene at least ruled for 20 years. He saying "I can do better" does not mean he actually can.
He killed an ally just because the guy did not follow his moral standards. That's not anymore cruel that what Celene would do, but that's certainly stupid and this does not speak well of him as an ally. So the minute my Inquisitor does something he does not approve, he gets the Remache treatment? I don't think so.
I despise both Gaspard and Celene, if there is any way to screw them over, the Inquisitors that are closer to my mindset will.