hence why people need to take them with a grain of salt and need to know your own preferences. I also disliked dark souls despite what the reviews said (and I like a challenge) but I know myself and the kinds of games I like. I never bought it and only played it when I got it for free and glad I never payed money for it.
I think there's something to be said about following the game coverage and making an informed decision on what you see; alongside the whole knowing your preferences.
First time I ever preordered something it was with ME3. I did so because I've always enjoyed Bioware games, and assumed that the conclusion to one of my favorite trilogies (in any medium) would be no different. I only really started paying attention to information regarding the game shortly before release, and I remember having an uneasy feeling by a lot of what I had heard/seen. It was revealed that Udina was always going to be the Counselor, because of something that happened in the books; the game was supposed to open with Shepard on trial for what he did in Awakening (which was an entirely optional quest); gameplay footage showed an abundance of auto-dialogue; and the child-in-the-vent scene seemed to always end the same, from what they showed during twitch streams.
I'm not saying this to start a discussion about ME3 - my point is that I had uneasy feelings with things that I saw prior to the game's release; yet I kept my preorder, and ended up feeling disappointed by the game.
Because of this, I originally didn't intend to preorder Inquisition. It was only because I had been following all of the information about the game for months now, and I *don't* have any worries about it; that I ended up preordering. (well, that and I want that darn Bog Unicorn. XD)
I know already (through gameplay footage, and released information) that Inquisition already has everything that I was hoping for (multiple races, minimal autodialogue, the ability to establish where your character stands with regards to the Chantry, tactical gameplay mode, and a number of other things) in the game. Maybe I'm just easy to please, but all of that was enough to warrant a preorder from me.
I understand not everyone will feel the same. And if you do have worries about the game, then you really shouldn't preorder it. For me, though, I don't really see any reason not to.