What is up with people dissing quality games out of some misplaced fanboy loyalty? First it was Tales of Xillia, then Persona, and now Divinity Original Sin. Divinity Original Sin is a modernized game with the soul of the good 'ol retro RPGs. It's in my opinion a completely amazing game that is worth every second spent playing it and is also highly rated. DA: I is a triple A title backed by big bucks (EA) and, as per usual, characterized by its flashy graphics though it seems this time the gameplay actually matches the effort spent into movie-izing everything.
I make no apologies for being an enthusiastic fan of Bioware games, so no, it is not misplaced as I chose it for myself, not someone else. But I believe you are equally enthusiast about Divinity otherwise my comment wouldn't have bothered you. I am much the Larian Studios fan myself, but believe the game worthy of criticism may that future games improve.
I have 250 hours in the game and never said it was a bad game (I believe it should be nominated for RPG of the year but hope DAI takes it). It has several faults, some more agreed upon than others including serious technical ones.
I still haven't played the ending because of the lackluster story (even fans don't usually praise the story - months of forum time tells me this as do reviews) and boring companions. But even though that is a personal opinion: Divinity is and always will be a niche game, with a much smaller niche than DA:I has because of its old-school base, for one, and its off-the-wall (some would say elementary) humor, second. Just as DA:I has a smaller base than action games.
And they just can't compete with the music (as awesome as Kirill is), graphics and so on with AAA, whether or not that matters to you or me, it is important to the broader audience. Larian has been more about fun and creativity but not emotionally-engaging stories and robust companions -- the heart of old-school RPGs, besides hack-n-slash. The combat and environment are excellent, but in the end, considering all --it still seems to pale in comparison to DA:I and some other games.
I will chalk this up to a misunderstanding of what I said rather than this being an issue of the pot calling the kettle black. 