386 réponses à ce sujet

[RobRam10]

I want to hug Fiona.

[Ryzaki]

Can't we just get rid of the leaders and force a truce 

 

If only.

 

Authors pet is more fitting. Too stupid to be a legitimate Sue anymore.

 

Nah there's some ****** mary sues. *looks at Bella Swan*

 

Can we at least take her to task for this stupidity if we side with the mages? If we can't I don't see myself ever siding with them. I don't feel stupidity like this should be rewarded.

[Dark Helmet]

Ya it the whole Quarian vs Geth all over again....

 

One side say kill them all while the other side ends up backed into a cornor and forced to join a Evil being.

 

Again the main difference being the leader of the side backed into the corner WANTED the war.

 

Something the Geth for all their stupidity are not guilty of.

[thesuperdarkone2]

Ya it the whole Quarian vs Geth all over again....

 

One side say you must be Controlled or die while the other side ends up backed into a cornor and forced to join a Evil being.

Pretty much. I wonder how much hate the mages would get if say it was someone like Rhys who did this and not Fiona.

[Bugsie]

I don't see Fiona as much of Sue, more a poorly written overtly contrived character obviously meant to link stories. Shame they did it that way.

Gives me 'bad writing vibes' something fierce. Like when C3P0 and r2d2 showed up in the new Star Wars films, supposedly to help tie the original trilogy to the new one...

[Morroian]

After becoming Danarius' apprentice. She was still enslaved for quite some time before hand. So again, mages can be slaves in Tevinter.

 

Had her talent manifested itself at that point? According to the wiki those who manifest magic talent if they were of the lowest caste move up to becoming liberati.

[Dark Helmet]

 

Can we at least take her to task for this stupidity if we side with the mages? If we can't I don't see myself ever siding with them. I don't feel stupidity like this should be rewarded.

 

I doubt it, at least not in any meaningful way. She's too much of a pet for anything other than direct opposition to stick.

[thesuperdarkone2]

 

Can we at least take her to task for this stupidity if we side with the mages? If we can't I don't see myself ever siding with them. I don't feel stupidity like this should be rewarded.

Look at the pictures I posted at pg. 7. Those occur if you side with the mages

[Wissenschaft 2.0]

Authors pet is more fitting. Too stupid to be a legitimate Sue anymore.

 

Shes not really the authors pet either. She play a major part in one book and then came back for a supporting role in another book. Sure she had a major impact on the story but she wasn't shown that much in Asunder. She hasn't been feature enough to be called an Authors pet.

[herkles]

Look at the pictures I posted at pg. 7. Those occur if you side with the mages

I didn't see any pictures

[Morroian]

I don't see Fiona as much of Sue, more a poorly written overtly contrived character obviously meant to link stories. Shame they did it that way.
 

 

Well put, this is exactly what she is.

[thesuperdarkone2]

Alistair makes his mom cry

Spoiler

 

Spoiler

 

Spoiler

This occurs if you side with the mages. Fiona gets punished regardless of who you side with apparently.

[thesuperdarkone2]

I didn't see any pictures

Sorry, just posted them right now.

[Dark Helmet]

This occurs if you side with the mages. Fiona gets punished regardless of who you side with apparently.

 

Not enough though.

[Shahadem]

I am hoping for a happy reunion for the two of them. 

 

Or Wynne. 

 

Apparently if you have magic in your line it does great things for your age. 

 

Wynne looked pretty old and withered. But that may have been from a mod.

[EdwinLi]

Well that certainly must a serious stab in the heart to have her own son banish her out of Ferelden 

 

Also Wynne is dead. Remember she died back in Asunder.

[Hellion Rex]

I want to hug Fiona.

Hug her till she stops breathing, you mean.

[Ryzaki]

This occurs if you side with the mages. Fiona gets punished regardless of who you side with apparently.

 

Good.

 

Alright now I feel she's not a sue. Just a poorly implemented plot device that should be nuked from orbit.

[Ryzaki]

Sorry, just posted them right now.

 

I still don't see them. Link?

[Morroian]

Not enough though.

 

what is her punishment?

[Shahadem]

I don't see Fiona as much of Sue, more a poorly written overtly contrived character obviously meant to link stories. Shame they did it that way.

Gives me 'bad writing vibes' something fierce. Like when C3P0 and r2d2 showed up in the new Star Wars films, supposedly to help tie the original trilogy to the new one...

 

C3P0 had to show up in the 2nd and 3rd movies because the 4th episode starts off referencing how C3P0 used to be ObiWan's droid during the Clone Wars.

[Dark Helmet]

Good.

 

Alright now I feel she's not a sue. Just a poorly implemented plot device that should be nuked from orbit.

 

For the good of Thedas, for the good of anyone who had ever been pro-mage before DA2 and the like!

[EdwinLi]

what is her punishment?

Spoiler

Banishment from Ferelden by her own son Alistair if you made him King.

[Dark Helmet]

what is her punishment?

 

Death is suitable.

[RobRam10]

Hug her till she stops breathing, you mean.

You must have missed my signature.