15 réponses à ce sujet

[godModeAlpha]

In the Leliana mission: Under her skin in the shrine of dumat, we meet Erasthenes who we can kill or capture. Now I'm just curious, which option has what consequence in the long run?

When it comes to Leliana I'm quite carefull, I'd rather have her by my side happy.

[godModeAlpha]

Bump

[rybob]

Not sure if it's related to my world state but Leliana killed her no matter what I said. 

[Jaron Oberyn]

If you told her to kill the traitor back in haven, she will kill this woman no matter what. If you told her to spare the traitor in haven, you can direct her to kill this woman (hardening Leilani) or spare her (softening). If she becomes divine, based on if she's hardened or not she will either be ruthless or peaceful in her approach.

[Chewy]

Bumping this.... Cuz I'm not sure myself.

Erasthenes is a magister captured by the elder one, he was owner of Calpenia who is leading vents and mages if you sided with Templars.

Soooo does anyone know consequences for killing him or keeping him in that barrier alive.

[Bladenite1481]

Bumping this.... Cuz I'm not sure myself.

Erasthenes is a magister captured by the elder one, he was owner of Calpenia who is leading vents and mages if you sided with Templars.

Soooo does anyone know consequences for killing him or keeping him in that barrier alive.

If you kill him, you have to fight Calpernia. If you keep him alive he gives you the spell of binding that keeps him in pain and you can show it to Calpernia and make her turn against Cory. 

[Chewy]

I'm glad I saved and didn't progress much....

I kept him alive but I don't remember him giving me "spell of binding" -_____-

[Estelindis]

If you kill him, you have to fight Calpernia. If you keep him alive he gives you the spell of binding that keeps him in pain and you can show it to Calpernia and make her turn against Cory. 

This isn't true.  I killed Erasthenes and I managed to talk Calpernia down.  With her appreciation for treating slaves better, I thought she might do some good in Tevinter if she lived.  However, perhaps this is only possible if you complete all the missions re. the surveillance crystal.

 

I admit that I flipflopped on the Erasthenes decision a bit.  At first, I offered to have him made tranquil, which he seemed fine with, as he just wanted his suffering to be over, and at least this let him still live...  But then I got a war table mission about mages being outraged that I had punished someone with tranquility and that I was going too far!  Ah, here...  It wasn't a punishment: it was to help him!  Stupid mages...  (Note: my inquisitor was a mage!)  So I reloaded and went with keeping him alive... but what he said to me when I refused to kill him really stabbed me in the conscience, so I reloaded again, killed him, and kept that.

[Kantr]

I assume the Master of Calpernia is tempalr sided quest.

[Estelindis]

I assume the Master of Calpernia is tempalr sided quest.

Correct.

[Chewy]

Aweeeee maaaaaaan! I don't know what to do hahaha

I'll keep him alive and next playthrough I'll kill him.... To see difference... After all i went weird way and end up joining in with Templars but closed their order lol

[xikorra]

i remember i kept him as a tranquil or something of that sort and everyone was quite happy with it, at least, no dire consequences became known and i got approvals. i think there was a war table mission afterwards about mages getting mad i made him tranquil but one simple completion of that and they were pacified (my inquis was a mage so they were like "ok well at least one of our own did it" so -shrug-)

 

as for calpurnia i had the option to spare her but i ended up killing her anyways 

[Bladenite1481]

This isn't true.  I killed Erasthenes and I managed to talk Calpernia down.  With her appreciation for treating slaves better, I thought she might do some good in Tevinter if she lived.  However, perhaps this is only possible if you complete all the missions re. the surveillance crystal.

 

I admit that I flipflopped on the Erasthenes decision a bit.  At first, I offered to have him made tranquil, which he seemed fine with, as he just wanted his suffering to be over, and at least this let him still live...  But then I got a war table mission about mages being outraged that I had punished someone with tranquility and that I was going too far!  Ah, here...  It wasn't a punishment: it was to help him!  Stupid mages...  (Note: my inquisitor was a mage!)  So I reloaded and went with keeping him alive... but what he said to me when I refused to kill him really stabbed me in the conscience, so I reloaded again, killed him, and kept that.

It may not be true that you have to fight Calpernia, but it is true he gives you the spell of binding. Because that's exactly what happened in my playthrough. I made him tranquil, he wrote the spell and gave it to Leli who gave it to me. At the end I gave to to Calpernia and she turned against Cory. If you can do it with knowledge of her being enslaved..then its just another choice in the game that is quite moot lol. 

[Arl Raylen]

This isn't true.  I killed Erasthenes and I managed to talk Calpernia down.  With her appreciation for treating slaves better, I thought she might do some good in Tevinter if she lived.  However, perhaps this is only possible if you complete all the missions re. the surveillance crystal.

 

I admit that I flipflopped on the Erasthenes decision a bit.  At first, I offered to have him made tranquil, which he seemed fine with, as he just wanted his suffering to be over, and at least this let him still live...  But then I got a war table mission about mages being outraged that I had punished someone with tranquility and that I was going too far!  Ah, here...  It wasn't a punishment: it was to help him!  Stupid mages...  (Note: my inquisitor was a mage!)  So I reloaded and went with keeping him alive... but what he said to me when I refused to kill him really stabbed me in the conscience, so I reloaded again, killed him, and kept that.

 

Dang this game is so full of non-choice choices. If you make the Corypheus' minion at Adamant tranquil the war table mission doesn't show up when you do it to Erasthenes, in fact I didn't notice anything except for some companions disapproving of my actions.

[Bladenite1481]

Yep, filler choices. You will be a lime green lamp post and we will worship you whether you like it or not! So says the people of Thedas, as they worship Theda-Jesus despite  his or her pleas for them to believe in themselves and not some silly god. 

[Remorce]

If you choose to let him live cole gets angry as you let a man continue to suffer. Mages and iron bull slightly approve if they are in your party. If you kill the reverse happens. Coles approval is affected either way.