Aller au contenu

Photo

Rate the Companions from Top to Bottom [No Spoilers]


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
246 réponses à ce sujet

#126
Jaderail

Jaderail
  • Members
  • 150 messages

Something, something something, Solas.

 

1. Solas - so far the most interesting, haven't learned a lot about him personally but he seems to agree with me a lot, he's always in my party and there's something intriguing about his wise sagey-elf thing.

2. Cassandra - Appears harsh but I love her personality when she starts to open up more

3. Varric - good comic relief, well-written character, though he came off as a little "bitchy" until a bit later into the game

4. Iron Bull - Nice to have in party, great party banter!

5. Dorian - funny and witty, I like talking with him, but he can be a bit pompous

6. Blackwall - a bit dull, but honorable and good to have around

7. Cole - Mysterious, but still pretty interesting if not incomprehensible at times.

8. Sera - she's alright, I don't agree with most of what she does and she is always disagreeing with my decisions

9. Vivienne - preachy and annoying. Avoid her at all costs.

 

Advisors

 

1. Cullen - <3

2. Josie - Cute and nice to talk with

3. Leliana - can't relate with her very much this time around



#127
SomeUsername

SomeUsername
  • Members
  • 193 messages

Its not easy to rate them because I generally like all of them but here it goes for me.

Companions:

1. Solas, even though we disagree on many things, he still "deeply respects" my Inquisitor and that's enough for me to put my wise wizard at the top.

2. Cassandra because I don't mind her religious views and I like her character and personality (when she opens up to you anyways)

3. I will say Blackwall, he is a bit boring and not much to say to him it seems for me, but I really like his personal story/quest and I find it very interesting.

4. Varric. I like his character and all but I don't have any interest in his merchant surface dwarf story thing that he often mentions.

5. Vivienne, I agree with most of her ideas as far as I know about her. I don't understand all the dislikes, maybe I am missing something as of now, but she seems like an intelligent Wynne replacer in a way.

6. Dorian since I just like the way he talks.

7. Cole. I liked him at first but he just starts getting too weird. Not to say I dislike him, but he is lower on the list because he doesn't seem to have much personality imo.

8. Iron Bull. He can be funny sure, but I only like him because he treats me like a boss (mostly just by saying "boss"). He is your typical "humorous mercenary".

9. Sera last because she is kinda annoying and I don't know much about her character since I never bothered to because she didn't make her appearance interesting.

For advisers:

1. Cullen. I like the way he acts like a tired important leader that has worked for many years and is loyal to the Inquisitor only.

2. Leliana because she knows my Warden and that's a good enough reason for me.

3. Josephine I don't like that much because everything about her is boring for me.

If you consider Morrigan an adviser even though she really isn't, I would put her at the top.  :)



#128
Samahl na Revas

Samahl na Revas
  • Members
  • 363 messages

1. Solas, as a mage I grew to respect him despite deferring of opinion on certain ideas.

 

etc: One of the best written characters I came across. Who ever wrote him needs to write more DA characters. Voice actor, perfect who ever sat down for the voice actor reading chose the right person to voice Solas. The way his lines are written perfect. Who wrote Solas? Let them write more characters.

 

2. Cassandra, I thought she was brash at first, but I grew to understand why she acts the way she does, I found it necessary. She was my romance.

 

3. Dorian, he always looks like he is crying but he makes it look so good. He made for good conversation and the bits about himself were quite good actually.

 

4. Cole, a mystery to unravel at first but my guess: which I made very early on was right 300%. 

 

5. Iron Bull, not what I expected and he has too few information about himself and his future.

 

6 Vivienne, not really memorable but I love the voice acting. Or maybe I like how she calls me darling :) . No it's her voice acting I like,  just not her background which for me will make her a forgettable character. The Banter is good too otherwise she might be lower on my list.

 

7 Sera, annoying hard to understand at first but eventually I understand and get where she is coming from. She's like Varric in a childish simplistic kind of way.

 

8. Blackwall, like bull after a while he says very little and I only learn one major bit about his past. 


 

9. Varric, Not the Varric I met in DA2. If someone sees Snow White let her know I found one of her Dwarf and will exchange him for Varric. 



#129
Kappa Neko

Kappa Neko
  • Members
  • 2 328 messages

etc: One of the best written characters I came across. Who ever wrote him needs to write more DA characters. Voice actor, perfect who ever sat down for the voice actor reading chose the right person to voice Solas. The way his lines are written perfect. Who wrote Solas? Let them write more characters.

Oh god, yes! That voice is a perfect fit. Together with his polite but intense personality, he's far sexier than he has any right to be with that ugly head of his! ;P

Cassandra, Solas and Dorian are my top 3 as well so far. Haven't done any personal quests yet though. Might change.
Still worried Solas will go Anders at the end... I'm drawn to misguided idealists (didn't romance Anders though).

#130
Annarl

Annarl
  • Members
  • 1 266 messages

Advisors: I love Cullen and Josephine but Leliana is a little odd so a little drop off in this game.

 

As for the companions: 1.Varric

                                      2.Iron Bull

                                      3.Blackwall

                                      4.Dorian

                                      5.Cole

                                      6.Solas

                                      7.Cassandra

                                      8.Sera

                                      9. Vivienne

 

To be fair the bottom four are more or less tied.



#131
Kittn

Kittn
  • Members
  • 293 messages

1. Solas, as a mage I grew to respect him despite deferring of opinion on certain ideas.

 

etc: One of the best written characters I came across. Who ever wrote him needs to write more DA characters. Voice actor, perfect who ever sat down for the voice actor reading chose the right person to voice Solas. The way his lines are written perfect. Who wrote Solas? Let them write more characters.

 

Hear, hear! I just finished a quest involving Cole that made me admire Solas even more. He's so incredibly fascinating that I have had to stop myself from just up and starting over (90 hours into first playthrough now with no end in sight as of yet) just to make an elf for him every time he speaks. Do we know who was responsible for him?

 

I didn't post my opinions of the advisers with my list, but since all the cool kids are doing that now here's how they stack up for me:

1. Cullen: He's been through too much not to appreciate his presence above the other two. And he has great hair. Which is a bonafide miracle in Thedas nowadays if you ask me. Maybe he's the real sign that the inquisition is chosen by the Maker, considering that. I am also not completely biased because I have him on the romance path, honest!

2. Leliana: I did not like her at all in DA:O. I tried to, but she felt sorta fake to me. Now she seems to have found some nerve and her angry eyebrows, and that's given her just the amount of personality she needed to be believable. I enjoy interacting with her now and hearing what she has to say.

3. Josephine: Only last because someone had to be. Her accent is fantastic and I get the feeling she could convince just about anyone to ally with us. She doesn't bring the history to the table that the other two do, but I like her just fine.



#132
Lughsan35

Lughsan35
  • Members
  • 491 messages

I love them all.  I wish I could bring them all along all the time


  • Aolbain et Lebanese Dude aiment ceci

#133
Aolbain

Aolbain
  • Members
  • 1 206 messages
I like them all, but if I had to choose...

1. Cassandra. She manages to combine brash violence with surpising self-insight. Also, fangirl Cassandra is adorable.
2. Sera. I would HATE her in real-life but man is she awesome.
3. Dorian. Completely missjudged him in the marketing, much deeper then expected.
4. Vivienne. Everyones Iron ****** Mom.
5. Iron Bull. If nothing else because how intresting he makes the north sound like.
6. Solas. Kinda ...boring when not talking about magic/the fade.
7. Blackwall. Sounds so passive-agressive every time we talk.
8. Varric. Turned bitter and crule. Understandable, but still.
9. Cole. Meh.

1. Cullen. Followed his natural character progression, and it's interesting to watch.
2. It's nice to see some one not having murder as the first and best answer to all lifes questions.
3. Sorta the same as with Varric.

#134
CronoDragoon

CronoDragoon
  • Members
  • 10 408 messages

Hear, hear! I just finished a quest involving Cole that made me admire Solas even more. He's so incredibly fascinating that I have had to stop myself from just up and starting over (90 hours into first playthrough now with no end in sight as of yet) just to make an elf for him every time he speaks. Do we know who was responsible for him?

 

Solas is written by Patrick Weekes, who also wrote Cole, Iron Bull, and Masked Empire. Previously he wrote Mordin, Tali, and ME3's Rannoch arc.

 

Let's just say I was pretty confident going in that Solas would be well-written.


  • Kittn aime ceci

#135
RamonNZ

RamonNZ
  • Members
  • 115 messages

 

Advisers. (first name)

 

 

That's a spoiler

 

Advisors:

 

 

2) (this name

 

 

That's a spoiler.

 

Advisors

2. This name
 

 

That's a spoiler

 

As for the advisors..

 

1 - This person

 

 

That's a spoiler.

 

This thread ruined some of my fun since I haven't gotten that far. This is no spoiler territory. Try and be careful.



#136
Teddie Sage

Teddie Sage
  • Members
  • 6 754 messages

That's a spoiler

 

 

That's a spoiler.

 

 

That's a spoiler

 

 

That's a spoiler.

 

This thread ruined some of my fun since I haven't gotten that far. This is no spoiler territory. Try and be careful.

Sorry... Maybe I should request a mod to move this thread to the Spoilers section? :wacko:



#137
WashclothRepairMan

WashclothRepairMan
  • Members
  • 142 messages

1. Blackwall

2. Iron Bull

3. Dorian

4. Varric

5. Solas

6. Sera

7. Cassandra

8. Cole (I cannot forgive that stupid hat and emo haircut)

9.  Vivienne

 

I like 1-4. Rather inifferent on 5-7, I sort of like them but not thrilled. Cole and Viv suck. Cole got a little better as I talked to him, but as I said, that hair and hat is a big no-no.

 

Hoping for Scout Harding to be a companion and romance option in DLC or Expansion.



#138
MrGDL87

MrGDL87
  • Members
  • 1 002 messages

Only halfway through but here are my impressions so far:

 

1) Vivienne - Confident, witty and interesting. I also agree with her stance on the Mage/Templar war. Also she is fabulous darling ;)

2) Iron Bull - Likeable as a character and interesting. Also liking the interaction with the Bull Chargers.

3) Cassandra - I like her because of her religious views and her quirkiness. I also like the accent.

4) Cole - I like the way that he comments on more or less everything when travelling. Also interesting.

5) Varric - I like him as a character just for DA2 nostalgia reasons.

6) Dorian - I am indifferent to Dorian but does provide interesting information about Tevinter.

7) Solas - ATM, he appears to be moody most of the time but has the useful combat abilities.

8) Sera - Extremely annoying and confusing (I thought I was going to like her from the previews but no)

9) Blackwall - A bit boring and don't really use him at all.

 

Advisors - Leliana, Cullen then Josephine

 

*I might change my mind as the story progresses*



#139
WashclothRepairMan

WashclothRepairMan
  • Members
  • 142 messages

1. Dorian he's witty and charming

2. Varric/Seras/Cas/Blackwall/Solas - Can't really choose between these, like them all

3.Iron Bull - He's a dork tbh but it's kind of endeering

4.Vivienne - She's interesting but abit of an upperclass twit

5.Cole - I just find not as interesting, he's also got some kind of anime character wibe that Fenris had that makes me instantly disslike him

There's a typo in your description of Vivienne. :rolleyes:


  • ronniecross2 aime ceci

#140
WashclothRepairMan

WashclothRepairMan
  • Members
  • 142 messages

There definitely seems to be a general consensus that there is an A league and B league. A being (in no order) Dorian, Blackwall, Solas, Cassandra, Varric, and Iron Bull, while Sera, Cole and Viviene are the B league. Glad to see that I'm not crazy in my dislike for Vivene, indifference towrds cole, and irritation with Sera.



#141
snackrat

snackrat
  • Members
  • 2 577 messages

Dorian

Cole

Solas

Varric

Cassandra

Vivienne

Iron Bull

Blackwall

Sera

 

I liked all of them except Sera. I'd've liked for more to be done with Blackwall.



#142
Chernaya

Chernaya
  • Members
  • 5 136 messages

Iron Bull

Varric

Dorian

Solas

Cole

Sera

Cassandra

Vivienne

Blackwall

 

Despite my ordering, I liked 'em all. Blackwall to me was a bit boring and then suddenly upsetting... but he was still well written, which is what's important.



#143
T.G

T.G
  • Members
  • 14 messages

I've only read the first page or so of this thread because I felt that, inevitably, bits and bobs of spoilers started to creep in as people described their relationships with the companions.

 

I've unlocked them all, and have had a good chat with them all - literally all that I can at the stage I'm at - but I haven't played far enough to give my list yet... might come back here later and do so.

 

One thing that struck me really strongly while reading through everyone's lists was that, even from only a page of posts, the variety of people's preferences was amazing, and pretty much covered the whole cast of characters in all kinds of spots from love to hate; the whole spectrum. I think that's a pretty impressive achievement in itself for this game, and I'm really looking forward to getting to know all the companions better.

 

But I did want to mention one very specific moment for me in the game so far (not remotely a spoiler).

 

It was almost a throw away moment really, quite banal in a way, but it really struck me at the time, and made me think "Wow, I hardly know any of these people yet, and already, in just a throw away comment, this game has got me emotionally involved with these guys; empathising with them and caring about them." ...

 

It happened the first time I discovered a remnant of the Grey Wardens in the Hinterlands. I was like, "Yay, found one."

 

And then there was a moment of silence, the wind was blowing, and then Varric (I'm pretty sure it was Varric) said quietly something like, "I bet Blackwall would have liked to have been here for this."

 

It was a nothing really, just a bit of coded 'banter', probably designed to remind me that this quest-line was linked to Blackwall, that he wasn't here, and that it might be more beneficial to have him along for this quest-line. But I only thought about that gamey, mechanic side of things later.

 

At the time I caught my breath and just stopped everything, and my heart actually sank. I thought about Blackwall stood alone on the edge of our encampment at Haven, wondering about the fate of his brethren, and that he wasn't here with us at the moment we discovered something really important to him. And I felt really bad for him.

 

'Out-of-game' I looked at my monitor, down the list of companions I had with me, at their little icons and such, but really my head was in-game and felt like I was meeting their eyes, one by one, and noone said anything but really they were all saying, "Yep. He ain't here. That was your decision (boss)." And it felt like any one of them would have given up their spot for him at that moment... if I'd said so.

 

Weird, eh? Like I say, just a nothing moment, that suddenly became a something moment. I decided right then and there to abandon my expedition in the Hinterlands, return directly to Haven, and 'make my report' to Blackwall; to bring him the good news. Of course, we did have a little dialogue moment when I found him, but it didn't resemble that in any way, except in my own head; no way the game could have predicted my feelings at the time and offered anything scripted that matched my mood. But it was a genuine mood I felt. I was subdued. I felt kinda guilty.

 

And the search for the Black Wardens will continue at a later date, when I can dedicate the time to conducting a proper search; just myself and Blackwall; that was the promise I made to myself out of regard for him.

 

Strange role-play moment, completely unforced and uncontrived by either myself or the game, and coming directly out of in-game character interaction and random dialogue. Felt kinda odd, in a good way.

 

And my interaction with certain other characters is already taking on greater significance and meaning, at least in my own mind, and that speaks quite highly for this game in my view.

 

Good job.

 

~TG


  • Akkos aime ceci

#144
Minimooo

Minimooo
  • Members
  • 312 messages

Love all the advisors equally, so I can't rate them  :wub:

 

As for companions...

  1. Sera - I adore her. Her circular ramblings remind me of the way some people speak here in England, and she's just great craic all round. Especially love her when you romance her, because you get to see her more vulnerable side.
  2. Cassandra - Strong lady with an inner soppy romantic. What's not to love?
  3. Iron Bull - Love his banter with Sera. And his addiction to dragon murdering.
  4. Dorian - Smooth af, with a glorious moustache. Plus, I love his sassiness. And on a more serious note, his personal quest is A+
  5. Varric - Varric's varric, who doesn't love him? He's only lower down because I use Sera as my archer rougue, so rarely have him in my party
  6. Cole - Kinda weirded me out when I first met him.. didn't know what to make of him. But he grew on me, and I like his character arc.
  7. Blackwall - Found Blackwall a bit meh. Nothing really extraordinary stood out about him for me.
  8. Solas - I liked him at the beginning, but he started to grind my gears as the game went on. He comes across as a bit high and mighty..
  9. Vivienne - Really hoped I'd love Vivienne, but she appears very conniving to me. I don't trust her intentions in joining the Inquisition.

 

But no matter what number the characters appear in my list, I think they're all written really well. In fact, my dislike for Vivienne actually makes me applaud her writing because, for me, she's a confronting individual, and I'm still trying to work her out.



#145
Obiwanshinobi

Obiwanshinobi
  • Members
  • 1 messages

1. Dorian: By far my favourite companion. Dialogue, voice acting, character design and back story are all exceptional. Some genuine laugh out loud moments with some of his lines.

2. Sera: She's a twist on the 'little sister' archetype, with enough quirks for at least ten companions. Her inane ramblings also provide some of the best banter from other companions - Varric, Dorian and Blackwall come to mind.

3. Varric: The same swaggering and entertaining rogue I remember from DA2.

4: Solas: There was the odd moment his obstinance grated on me, but for the most part he was a fascinating companion to have around. The way he handles Iron Bull during party banter deserves particular praise.

5. Cassandra: Won me over with certain aspects of character development - particularly when romancing her.

6. Blackwall: His character grew on me. Bored me to tears to begin with, but by act 3 I was pleasantly surprised.

7. Iron Bull: Amusing enough, but somewhat overhyped. In many ways he reminded me of a more entertaining version of James Vega.

8. Cole: Well written and a relatively unique concept, but he was just too damn depressing/emo for my liking.

 

 

 

9. Vivienne: Insufferable. The one companion I could have lost along the way and not a single s*** would have been given. Having said that, she's still well-written.



#146
Lebanese Dude

Lebanese Dude
  • Members
  • 5 545 messages

I liked them all but some more than others.There's a lot to say but I'll keep it short.

 

1) Cassandra: I loved her. I really did. Probably my favorite Dragon Age character after Alistair. Perfectly written and perfectly voiced. Her scenes were always great and she felt the most human out of all the companions.

2) Dorian: Charming, dashing, and cunning. Sassy, classy, and brassy. Despite his confidence, he's also fully capable of admitting that he has more to learn. Love his character and loved his romance arc even more. 

3) Vivienne: Strong, capable, and witty with glorious interactions. Despite her arrogance and appearing like a beyotch, she really cares about others.

4) Solas: Intelligent, astute, and always willing to impart knowledge. He also surprised me with his vicious and headstrong nature. Not used to that with elves in DA.

5) Sera:

Spoiler
That's all it took for me to love her. A bit of a hypocrite but that made her all the more real.

6) Cole: Very well written character. Always had something interesting to say. Has the best companion plot among the characters.

7) Iron Bull: Crazy, buff, masculine guy with a heart of gold. What's not to like? I loved getting drunk with the guy.

8) Varric: Instantly approachable and charming as hell. Liked him in DA2 and loved him in DAI. Brian Bloom is the perfect male VA.

9) Blackwall: Least favorite companion. His character arc was really interesting though. I loved his protective nature and he was the only character to really shock me. Well done BioWare.

 

I liked all the advisors equally. Cullen and Leliana had great (potential) character development and you could feel the pain from their past. Josephine was cute as fk.



#147
AshesEleven

AshesEleven
  • Members
  • 1 575 messages

Solas.

 

Then everyone else.



#148
Vader20

Vader20
  • Members
  • 431 messages

 love them all except for one: Iron Bull.... So for me, he is the most boring, uninteresting of all... Where is Sten ?? or someone like him. Damn.. I loved that guy so much. He was a Qunari, but he was so well written. Those debates were memorable. Bull ? I don't know what he is all about..



#149
Susss

Susss
  • Members
  • 28 messages
1. COLE: So pure and unique, love his banter
2. CASSANDRA: She's really comes across as the force behind the inquisition in the beginning, she's so driven, while still keeps an awkward and hilarious side
3. VARRIC: He's changed a bit, as it should be, but still definitely old Varric, good character development between DA2 and DAI
4. DORIAN: Witty, funny, my femquisitor can't stop flirting with him
5. SOLAS: A bit boring sometimes, but also different from anyone else and very interesting in his own way, I wish he had long hair :/
6. SERA: Funny at times, way too silly/childish other times... I feel her character lacks development throughout the game
7. IRON BULL: I don't get the fuss with him tbh, will romance him in my next playthrough and see, but to me, he doesn't make sense as a qunari or spy
8. VIVIENNE: I get the concept and all, I just really hate having her around
9. BLACKWALL: As boring as they get, only redeeming quality is his personal quest being the best of them all
 
I love the three advisors, I guess Cullen a bit more, cause... yeah, Cullen.


#150
Guest_Faerunner_*

Guest_Faerunner_*
  • Guests

1. Cole

2. Solas (would be first except Cole is just such a sweetie-pie! <3)

3. Varric

4. Dorian

5. Iron Bull

6. Cassandra

7. Blackwall

8. Vivienne

9. Sera