Aller au contenu

Photo

Rate the Companions from Top to Bottom [No Spoilers]


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
246 réponses à ce sujet

#201
MajorStupidity

MajorStupidity
  • Members
  • 1 923 messages

There is no companion I outright dislike I am completely willing to use them all. I won't rate combat effectiveness because that really depends on your party composition.

 

1. Varric - I will give him first spot just because he was the only really great companion in DA2 and he is still great in DAI even if he is a bit more subdued.

2. Iron Bull - I just like how he feels much more open minded about my decisions (I have to actively go out of my way to get disapproval from him)

3. Dorian - I really like his character he is well written and incredibly likeable.

4. Cassandra - I don't always agree with her, but I find her pragmatism and passion endearing.

5. Solas - I enjoy hearing his views and philosophy and even when I am disagreeing with him I can usually understand where he is coming from.

6. Blackwall - A little boring, but he is generally a likeable guy

7.Vivienne - Yes she is a ******, but she is a well written ******. I just really enjoy her interactions with other characters (Sera and her are pretty damn funny)

8. Sera - She can sometimes be irritating because of how immature she is, but at the same time I still do find her antics occasionally entertaining, and her interactions with other characters is usually pretty funny.

9. Cole - He just grates on me sometimes I enjoy some aspects of his character and I like his companion quest, but I just don't find myself wanting to take him in my party as much as other companions.



#202
Dreambender

Dreambender
  • Members
  • 3 messages

1. Cassandra. Passionate and driven, Cassandra is wonderful. She truly cares about people and wants to do the right thing. 

2. Sera. She's really grown on me and she's adorable and funny.

3. Cole. Cole's a sweetie, like a sad little puppy.

4. Dorian. Charming, funny, and kind underneath the snark. 

5. Varric. Varric's caring underneath all of the jokes and chesthair. His treatment of Cole really made me think highly of him. 

6. Iron Bull. This was a tough one, I really do like The Iron Bull. Possibly more than Varric, possibly less, depends on my mood.

7. Vivienne. I respect her, but we have fundamentally different views about certain things.

8. Solas. My opinion of Solas fluctuates but he's definitely not one my favorites.

9. Blackwall. His story is interesting but I was never interested or connected to him as a character. I found him the most forgettable.



#203
Addai

Addai
  • Members
  • 25 848 messages
Solas
Cole
Cassandra
Dorian
Varric
Blackwall
Iron Bull
Sera
Vivienne

The advisors are all kind of just there.

#204
Ryzaki

Ryzaki
  • Members
  • 34 400 messages

Are we doing combat performance or story because those are very different lists.

 

But anyway for my preferences in story.

 

1. Cole

2. Iron Bull

3. Solas

4. Cassandra

5. Varric

6. Vivienne

7. Blackwall

8. Dorian

9. Sera

 

In terms of combat

 

1. Sera

2. Blackwall

3. Vivienne

4. Cassandra

5. Varric

6. Solas

7. Dorian

8. Bull

9. Cole

 

(I love the last two but the AI is godawful at their specs. And Dorian's buggy as hell).



#205
Karai9

Karai9
  • Members
  • 251 messages

1. Varric- he will always be my #1 bro no matter what, even if he is more serious and worn out in this game.

2. Iron Bull- I like him so much more than I thought I would. He wears the 'macho' mask well, but the moments where he lets it slip are touching and often quite profound.

3. Cassandra- stoic lady that has done a lot of growth since DA2. I really appreciate that she isn't afraid to admit when she's wrong or point out when something just isn't working (Chantry/Circle/Templars).

4. Cole- I love taking Cole with me places just to hear what will come out of his mouth next, and often times I just want to give him a hug. It's refreshing to have such a genuinely good and selfless character in the group.

5. Dorian- fabulously snarky and genuine. His personal quest chokes me up every time *all the feels*

6. Solas- super fascinating character who offers some really challenging (in a good way) opinions about things in the DA universe that we've only really experienced from one perspective before.

7. Vivienne- the lady is a b**ch but she knows it and owns it. I definitely don't always agree with her but she's so well written and acted that I can't not enjoy her character.

8. Blackwall- I have to say that I forget about him quite often, but his desire to be better is very admirable. Still, I'm looking forward to the playthrough where I romance him so I can see more of his character.

 

9. Sera- as much as I keep trying, I just can't like her character. She's way too immature and intolerant for my taste.

 

Advisors:

 

Cullen- very surprised that I like him as much as I do since I found him incredibly irritating in the last two games, but this ex-templar has come a long way. (It probably helps that his romance is so sweet - Alistair Vers. 2.0).

Josephine- cute and sweet but sometimes a bit bland.

Leliana- . . . what the heck happened girl? Looks like someone turned into Marjolaine after all. . .


  • DaryAlexV aime ceci

#206
SirGladiator

SirGladiator
  • Members
  • 1 143 messages

Sera and Leliana at the top

Josephine

Cassandra

Varric

Cole (I didn't expect to like Cole, but he admitted that killing all those mages was wrong and he wouldn't do it again, so I forgave him)

Solas

 

The rest I didn't much care for, or didn't like at all, I'll only mention Vivienne because I expected to like her, but I really didn't.



#207
VahnXIII

VahnXIII
  • Members
  • 109 messages

Dorian - phenomenally written and perhaps my favorite side character since Balthier in Final Fantasy 12

Varric - ever since his introduction in the tutorial, I loved having him around. The only thing is...i'm also a rogue and I only need 1... but great character nonetheless

Cassandra - very strong character all around and a good leader for my group

Solas - his out-of-the-box philosophies regarding the fade and demons makes for great dialogue and a unique perspective

Iron Bull - wish I had more room in my party for him to join as his dialogue is fun and it's always a pleasure to learn more about his experience the qun

Blackwall - who doesn't like the old experienced warrior? He's to the point and offers a lot of wisdom. Good to have around!

Cole - I can't help but think of Ronald Weasly every time I see him or when he talks. They look very similar.

Sera - don't really like at all. I find her annoying, but hey, thanks for the book that allowed me to become a DW tempest.....

Vivienne - no. Just, no.

 

Josephine - I liked her character because it isn't over the top. She's not a super spy or an ex-templar. She's a sophisticated politician that hails from a long line of merchants. Plain and simple, which I like....

Lelianna - ...on the other hand spy masters are awesome and I'm glad she's on my side.

Cullen - good character, but I've seen him in plenty of other games. Ex-templar turned inquisition supporter. Raise army army and march forward.



#208
Nayana_Jaz

Nayana_Jaz
  • Members
  • 107 messages

1 - Dorian

2 - Cassandra

3 - Cole

4 - Varric/Solas/Iron Bull

5 - Blackwall/Sera

6 - Vivienne



#209
First Warden

First Warden
  • Members
  • 9 messages

1 Blackwall, closest thing to a grey warden I got in this game :( great character though.

2 Varric, good to see him again even if I was the bland inquisitor instead of Hawke

3 Dorian, really cool guy hope to see him again in next DA

4 Iron Bull, Freddie did  a really good job voice acting him, awesome companion

5 Cassandra, she's alright I guess

6 Cole, meh, nothing to really say about him

7 Solas, couldn't really agree much with him when it came to grey wardens, Cole, and so on

8 Sera, pretty annoying

9 Vivienne UGH Vivienne...

 

Cullen-really good character, like how he develops over the games

Josephine-she's alright.

Leliana-wish I could've romanced her or something, it's way too easy to harden her in the beginning.. and hardened Leliana is a B imo



#210
DaryAlexV

DaryAlexV
  • Members
  • 199 messages

1. Top of the tops and forever in my heart: rogue, storyteller, and occasionally unwelcome tagalong - mr. Tethras. (btw Varric is never unwelcome)

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

2. Chuckles

3. Iron Bull and Cole

4. Cassandra

5. Dorian

6. Blackwall

>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>

7. Sera and Vivienne 



#211
Ogillardetta

Ogillardetta
  • Members
  • 966 messages

1.Sera
2.Dorian
3.Cassandra
4.Ironbull
5.Varric
6.Cole
7.Solas
8.Blackwall




9.Vivianne.



#212
Kulyok

Kulyok
  • Members
  • 749 messages

I tend to take Solas, Cassandra and Varric with me all the time anyway, but -

 

1. Solas

2. Cassandra

3. Varric

4. Iron Bull

5. Dorian

6. Cole

7. Blackwall

8. Sera

9. Vivienne

 

Aaand Vivienne really doesn't seem to be wining many popularity polls, does she? Poor dear.



#213
Riladel

Riladel
  • Members
  • 71 messages

1 - Dorian

 

2 - Solas

3 - Cole

 

4 - Varric

5 - Iron Bull

 

6 - Sera

7 - Cassandra

8 - Blackwall

 

 

9 - Vivienne



#214
kkleven

kkleven
  • Members
  • 9 messages

1. Varric

2. Sera

3. Cassandra

4. Dorian

5. Iron Bull

6. Blackwall

7. Solas

8. Vivienne

9. Cole

 

I mainly use Vivienne as co-mage when hard battles other than that - she stays in the tent. Sera is well written and her english voice do fit her character. She is not eduacated and seems a little bit silly, but she cannot ble blamed. The persons I wish be present in next chapter: Sera, Cassandra, Varric, Iron Bull and Dorian. Others; Nope. josie, Cullen and Lelianna no need to be present either.

 

Cheers,

-Klevs 



#215
Phoe77

Phoe77
  • Members
  • 628 messages

I have a really hard time ranking them because the ones that get on my nerves the most still have redeeming qualities and my favorites still have annoying foibles that make me want to smack them.  I think that's a testament to the quality of their writing.  That said, I'll try to rate them even though I haven't actually finished the game yet.

 

Dorian - I like him a lot and he has probably the least irksome flaws to me.  He can be disrespectful and somewhat insulting to people, but it seems that he usually gets that way when the other party starts it rather than defaulting to being a jerk.  

Blackwall - His archetype is pretty simple, but I really like it.  I think his desire to redeem himself in his own eyes is very admirable, and I like that he can be so committed to that goal and still be ready to joke around with people and enjoy himself.  Plus, he's a hottie.  I do dislike the broad brush he paints all nobles with, especially since he doesn't seem to mind praising the Inquisitor despite his or her potential noble heritage.  

Cassandra - I'm glad they made a religious type that is practical and not shackled by dogma.  She's got faith and conviction, but she also shows moments of spiritual vulnerability.  She's in favor of the Chantry because of the good that's at its heart rather than because of some blind faith.  I like her character far more than I thought I would.

Varric - I like the growth that his character has gotten.  For the most part he's easy going and accepting of other characters, he's still funny, but his regret over the events of DA2 make it seem like he's there for a better reason that "because fans liked him".  He can occasionally be mean spirited though, but then he has been through a lot.  

Vivienne - I don't see eye to eye with her on very many issues and I think that she goes out of her way to antagonize certain people, but she has decent support for several of her arguments, even if she's a bit too quick to assume that her own experiences are standard for every mage.  Its really neat to see a character who's not only poised and powerful on the field of battle, but also among nobles.  

Iron Bull - I haven't used him as much as I would like to have, but he's interesting.  I like that he's neither blatantly pro-Qun or anti-Qun and instead sees benefits to both ways of life.  He's a big brute with hidden depths, and that's neat to see.  He's the first qunari that I've actually liked.  

Cole - Again, I haven't used him very much.  I like how devoted he is to helping people and I think his way of viewing the world and people in it are very interesting.  I can't wait to use him more.  

Solas - Solas is very smart and provides a very unique view of the world, but he can be snooty and dismissive of other people or groups when they don't have the benefit of his experience or knowledge.  That said, I like him and I'm pleased that he's usually at least civil with everyone else, even when they're trying to antagonize him.

Sera - She's entertaining and wild.  She's also rude, small minded, and stubborn.  She refuses to see the merits of any mindset that's even slightly different from her own and that is one of my absolute greatest pet peeves.  She irritates me in every one of our conversations, but even she has redeeming qualities.  

 

I like all of the companions though.  They're well written and there are at least a couple of things I like about each character.



#216
PearsAndCherries

PearsAndCherries
  • Members
  • 99 messages

1. Solas :wub:

2. Cullen

3. Black Wall

4. Dorian

5.Varric

6. Iron Bull

7. Sera

8. Cassandra

9. Vivienne

 

Don't care that much about Cole tbh.



#217
Poledo

Poledo
  • Members
  • 548 messages

Dorian - Well written and well voice acted. His personal story in Redcliffe was superb.

Solas - I'm probably in the minority here - I think overly serious characters are few and far between in games these days. Anyone who takes themselves this seriously is usually made fun of. I just love this character to death.

Blackwall - I was saddened by his story twist but I still love it.

Iron Bull - just a fun character that takes a while to get involved or have chat options with or else I would have him higher.

 

The rest can go in any order really - they were just there. Sera was a bit overdone but I still like her. Cass was the opposite of Sera, I liked how she developed eventually though, seeing a softer side. Varric is amusing, but he could go or stay and I don't think the story would have suffered one bit for his absence. It made sense for him to be there due to how DA2 was told from his persepective to Cassandra, it tied in nicely. Don't get me wrong I like him, but he doesn't stand out for me.

 

I loved Josephine, her innocence despite her life choices amuses me. Cullen and Leliana returning yet again with a more pronounced role was great.



#218
Lady Sif

Lady Sif
  • Members
  • 2 219 messages
Companions:
1. Solas
2. Dorian
3. Cole
4. Cassandra
5. Sera
6. Varric
7. Blackwall
8. Iron Bull
9. Vivienne

Advisors:
1. Cullen
2. Leliana
3. Josephine

#219
Qunquistador

Qunquistador
  • Members
  • 234 messages

1)Josephine

2)Cullen

3)Leliana

 

1)Cole  

2)Solas

3)Vivienne

4)Cassandra

5)Sera 

6)Dorian

7)Varric

8)Iron Bull

9)Blackwall



#220
Helmetto

Helmetto
  • Members
  • 264 messages

Eh, I like them all.

 

Except Solas.

 

but if I had to rate them:

 

1. Cassandra

2. Sera

3. Vivienne

4. Dorian

5. Cole-Varric-Blackwall (These three simply did not leave that much of an impression with me)

8. The Iron Bull (For Personal Quest reasons.)

9. Solas. While similar to Sera in a lot of ways, this ass is very pretentious about things and carries the "I'm Right" vibe a bit more up there. Still interesting though.

 

Advisors:

1. Leliana.

2. Josephine.

3. Cullen.



#221
DementedSheep

DementedSheep
  • Members
  • 188 messages

Hmm I'm not good ranking favourites so more or less

 

Cole 

Cassandra

Solas (I like his character though probably wouldn't be friends with him)

Varric

Dorian 

Iron-bull

Blackwall (didn't leave much on impression one way or another TBH)

Vivienne 

Sera



#222
sim-ran

sim-ran
  • Members
  • 265 messages
1. Casandra - expected to hate her but she's so well written and voice acted. She's also decent, honest and reasonable even when she disagrees with you, and touchingly vulnerable.

2. Solas - has the most fascinating knowledge and insights. Would have been top but his personality and backstory seem to be very bland, and his "I know best" judgey attitude grates at times.

3 - Varric/Dorian/Sera/Cole
I can't really rank these guys, I like them all a lot, but not as much as the top 2. Varric's solid and fun but doesn't offer anything fresh. The other 3 all are fresh (Tevinter, common people and just plain unique perspectives in turn) but lack elsewhere. Dorian's arrogance gets in the way of his charm for me sometimes. I always have to bring up subtitles with Sera to work out what she's saying. Cole just doesn't say enough beyond the cryptic nothings (I do like those, buy I want MORE! )

4. Vivienne / Blackwall
Both useful for combat. Blackwall is inoffensive but boring as hell. Thought I'd really dig Vivienne but she doesn't seek to have anything to say to me. Ever! This may be because she's disagreed with all my decisions so fast.

5. Iron Bull - dislike everything about him. I find him useless in combat, and his backstory is completely at odds with his mannerisms and personality. The fact that the VO and writing makes him as Vega as possible infuriates me. I like Vega IN MASS EFFECT - evoking him in DA makes no sense and kills my suspension of disbelief.

#223
drake2511

drake2511
  • Members
  • 905 messages

1. Solas: he's one of the most interesting character in all DA. He has so many layers, he's fuel for so many discussions and theories. Lore oriented romance. Ma sa'lath.

2. Cole: my adorable little spirit, the angel of the Inquisition. I take him everywhere, he has fantastic comments on everything.

3. Dorian/Iron Bull:
Dorian: snarky best friend and an interesting Tevinter PoV.
Bull: he grew on me. On my first run I didn't care much about him, then I took him out with Cole and Solas. They have amazing banters, and he's much more open minded and smarter than he looks. I like him. A lot!

4. Cassandra/Sera:
Cass: kicking ass female warrior, loyal friend. Yes please.
Sera: great character, one of my quizzy's best friends, despite everything. I like the relationship she has with Solas, many believe they hate each other, but that's far from the truth imho. They behave like they're family.

5. Blackwall: I like him, even after his personal quest (maybe more?). He has a good sense of humor and he's a complex and interesting character.

6. Varric: I think he already had his time to shine in DA2, he feels out of place sometimes. I guess that's the point of including him, to get him out of his comfort zone (Kirkwall). Still love the wicked grace scene though.

7. Vivienne: I don't dislike her, I just don't like her as much as the others. She's like the lovely snobby aunt of the Inquisition.


There isn't anyone I don't like or hate. That's a first in a Bioware game!



#224
Biotic Flash Kick

Biotic Flash Kick
  • Members
  • 1 561 messages

Honestly?

I'm only going to mention Cass and Blackwall because they are my favorites.

I love my tanky tanks :33

 

Everyone was great though.

Sera rubs me the wrong way but she's basically a kid. 

Her and Cole fight like brother and sister 



#225
Exalus

Exalus
  • Members
  • 347 messages
1 - Cassandra - I think she exemplifies passion and determination and she really warms up to you as the story progresses
2 - Dorian - clever and sometimes bashful
3 - Varric - your bro and drinking buddy
4 - Solas - "I love spirits!"
5 - Sera
6 - Blackwall
7 - Iron Bull 
8 - Cole
9 - Vivienne
 
Oddly enough I ended up liking the original party the most. They were also conveniently well balanced in terms of class.