Aller au contenu

Photo

Is it just me or does "the Dawn will come" sound like it was ripped straight from the Lord of the Rings (movies)?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
22 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

Sounds like a mix between the Edge of Night and Misty Mountains Cold, I will let you be the judge

 

 

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AgYxMVRtJr4

 

 

 

Regardless of how you feel about Bioware's blatant plagiarism I am sure we are all waiting for the Cullen version of Fabulous Secret Powers

 

 



#2
Kantr

Kantr
  • Members
  • 8 657 messages

It wasnt plagarism as the director behind it explains.



#3
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

It wasnt plagarism as the director behind it explains.

 

So what did he call it? Accidental reproduction?



#4
Teddie Sage

Teddie Sage
  • Members
  • 6 754 messages

Most bard songs sound the same in every game or media, it's nothing new. Deal with it.


  • Charcoal15 et Elisaveta aiment ceci

#5
Cecilia L

Cecilia L
  • Members
  • 688 messages

It absolutely does, and that's what makes it so awesome and epic!



#6
Brovikk Rasputin

Brovikk Rasputin
  • Members
  • 3 825 messages
Maybe if you're tone deaf it sounds the same.

#7
Shelidon

Shelidon
  • Members
  • 339 messages
It's certainly very very very very (very) close. If it's an explicit homage, I'll have great respect for that. Can anyone link or quote what the director said.

#8
ZipZap2000

ZipZap2000
  • Members
  • 5 262 messages

It sounds like every song from every similar setting with a song, presented better I might add.


  • Toastbrot et Tevinter Soldier aiment ceci

#9
Bhaal

Bhaal
  • Members
  • 415 messages

Most bard songs sound the same in every game or media, it's nothing new. Deal with it.



#10
Eudaemonium

Eudaemonium
  • Members
  • 3 548 messages

My gf, who was in another room when I got to that scene, sent me a text saying 'your game is playing the song from the hobbit movie'.

 

I couldn't disagree.



#11
Kantr

Kantr
  • Members
  • 8 657 messages

http://www.reddit.co...artfelt/cmce4ud



#12
Guest_Challenge Everything_*

Guest_Challenge Everything_*
  • Guests

Now I'm picturing my Inquisitor talking to Corypheus, and instead of using the catapult to cause an avalanche, she just holds her staff, gets into a defensive position, and says, "YOU SHALL NOT PASS!!!" XD



#13
Nibbin

Nibbin
  • Members
  • 105 messages

Maybe if you're tone deaf it sounds the same.

Bit of an overstatement, the similarity/influence is definitely evident to anyone musical or not, and that's ok.
Are YOU tone deaf? 



#14
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

Bit of an overstatement, the similarity/influence is definitely evident to anyone musical or not, and that's ok.
Are YOU tone deaf? 

 

No people I think it is his passion for Bioware that causes him to lash out unduely, I forgive and absolve him of all his sins and welcome him back to the discussion if he is willing to be a productive contributer to the discussion.


  • Kerrija aime ceci

#15
Kerrija

Kerrija
  • Members
  • 17 messages
bla

 

How good to see you graced these forums with your presence again after being banned. 

You know what would be grand though? If you at least tried to post something that wasn't inflammatory or just plain stupid in the forums of a game that you hate oh so much.



#16
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

How good to see you graced these forums with your presence again after being banned. 

You know what would be grand though? If you at least tried to post something that wasn't inflammatory or just plain stupid in the forums of a game that you hate oh so much.

 

I have no idea what you are talking about hon, I was merely remarking on the similarities between Dragon Age and Lord of the Rings choice in music.



#17
Kerrija

Kerrija
  • Members
  • 17 messages

I have no idea what you are talking about hon, I was merely remarking on the similarities between Dragon Age and Lord of the Rings choice in music.

 

Look, "blatant plagiarism", taking jabs at "defensive Bioware fans" at the bloody Bioware forum are not really the best way to foster a mature discussion.

You just might find that people being defensive and/or rude in regards to your post might just in fact be related to your way of presenting your arguments.



#18
LinksOcarina

LinksOcarina
  • Members
  • 6 525 messages

It's just a Bard Song, like all the rest.

 

https://www.youtube....h?v=u_tORtmKIjE



#19
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

taking jabs at "defensive Bioware fans" at the bloody Bioware forum are not really the best way to foster a mature discussion.

 

You are right, even though he started it stooping to his level is not the way to foster mature discussion, I have edited my post to make it more to your liking.



#20
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

It's just a Bard Song, like all the rest.

 

https://www.youtube....h?v=u_tORtmKIjE

 

That sounded nothing like the songs in question, or did some jape just go over my head?



#21
LinksOcarina

LinksOcarina
  • Members
  • 6 525 messages

The point on how the song doesn't matter, it's in the tradition of "bard songs" like this. 



#22
Fabulous Warden

Fabulous Warden
  • Banned
  • 28 messages

The point on how the song doesn't matter, it's in the tradition of "bard songs" like this. 

 

Still don't see your point, but on a different note having listened to your clip I would love to see more medieval fantasy games borrow more from that musical style, throw in a slight classic rock vibe and the wail of an electric guitar and you will have the beginnings of a kick arse soundtrack. Personally I have always felt it was a bit of a missed opportunity that the Dark Souls games did not have more of a classic rock inspired soundtrack, a shame.



#23
Kerrija

Kerrija
  • Members
  • 17 messages

You are right, even though he started it stooping to his level is not the way to foster mature discussion, I have edited my post to make it more to your liking.

 

Got a laugh out of your edit, well played.