Aller au contenu

Photo

Heterosexuality non-existent in Orlesian noble court?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
308 réponses à ce sujet

#101
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

One think I found "funny" was that, in the Dorian personal quest, you could not say "Hey dude, your father did the right thing". In a RPG which is all about choice, you have NO CHOICE at all on this matter.

In this game you can pretty much decide if you want to KILL PEOPLE or not - but Maker forbid, making comments against homosexuality is strictly forbidden. It seems it's ways worse than killing tons of people.

That line of thought doesn't exist in Thedas outside Tevinter nobility.


  • Roamingmachine et Bayonet Hipshot aiment ceci

#102
Nathair Nimheil

Nathair Nimheil
  • Members
  • 689 messages

Homosexuality is NOT the common thing.

It would be problematic for the survival of the species, tbh.

No it wouldn't, to be scientific. Non-reproductive sexual behaviour (including long term or permanent same-sex pair bonding) is commonly observed in hundreds of species including ours. (And, as you have probably gathered, we are all still here.)


  • daveliam, Teddie Sage, WildOrchid et 3 autres aiment ceci

#103
Nathair Nimheil

Nathair Nimheil
  • Members
  • 689 messages
At any rate, I find hilarious how feminists tend to be rather intollerant towards ANYONE not sharing their views.

Talk about being coherent.

People should be tolerant of intolerance in the name of unthinking consistency? Nonsense. Non-sense.


  • Eloka aime ceci

#104
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

People should be tolerant of intolerance in the name of unthinking consistency? Nonsense. Non-sense.

*coughSera'santielvenattitudescough*


  • Primula Nightfall, Roamingmachine, Charoleia et 2 autres aiment ceci

#105
Primula Nightfall

Primula Nightfall
  • Members
  • 80 messages

That line of thought doesn't exist in Thedas outside Tevinter nobility.

 

What.

I can't understand if you are sarcastic or not, here. It's irrelevant whether it's not typical outside Tevinter - in a game about choices, not having that choice is completely out of place, and clearly was not included to avoid making homosexuals angry and noisy.

 

No it wouldn't, to be scientific. Non-reproductive sexual behaviour (including long term or permanent same-sex pair bonding) is commonly observed in hundreds of species including ours. (And, as you have probably gathered, we are all still here.)

 

Right. Still it's not, in terms of numbers, the MOST COMMON status - and yes, this is the reason "we are still here". Try to procreate with exclusively homosexuals relations, let me know if it works for you. 

 

Please remember that the ultimate instict of every living being is to procreate. Survival instincts above all.

 

*coughSera'santielvenattitudescough*

 

Nah, she's gay, so she can pretty much allow herself to be intolerant. It's accepted.



#106
naddaya

naddaya
  • Members
  • 991 messages

No it wouldn't, to be scientific. Non-reproductive sexual behaviour (including long term or permanent same-sex pair bonding) is commonly observed in hundreds of species including ours. (And, as you have probably gathered, we are all still here.)

 

Besides, there are too many humans already.


  • Neeve aime ceci

#107
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

What.

I can't understand if you are sarcastic or not, here. It's irrelevant whether it's not typical outside Tevinter - in a game about choices, not having that choice is completely out of place, and clearly was not included to avoid making homosexuals angry and noisy.

Not sarcastic. Actual opposition to homosexuality doesn't exist anywhere else in Thedas (except probably in qunari territory). And you don't have a choice to do that in any other DA game either, so.


  • Bayonet Hipshot aime ceci

#108
Primula Nightfall

Primula Nightfall
  • Members
  • 80 messages

Not sarcastic. Actual opposition to homosexuality doesn't exist anywhere else in Thedas (except probably in qunari territory). And you don't have a choice to do that in any other DA game either, so.

 

Wait.

 

How is THAT not a clear indication of an "agenda"? I don't even



#109
Xilizhra

Xilizhra
  • Members
  • 30 873 messages

Wait.

 

How is THAT not a clear indication of an "agenda"? I don't even

Because religious intolerance of homosexuality isn't an inevitability? Because there's no real reason to hew to it when designing one's own religion for a fantasy world?


  • Nathair Nimheil et Jewel17 aiment ceci

#110
mikeymoonshine

mikeymoonshine
  • Members
  • 3 493 messages

What.

I can't understand if you are sarcastic or not, here. It's irrelevant whether it's not typical outside Tevinter - in a game about choices, not having that choice is completely out of place, and clearly was not included to avoid making homosexuals angry and noisy.

 

 

There are many choices bioware do not allow you to make for many reasons, for example you can't play as a nug.  :blink: It being "a game about choice" is not an argument for the inclusion of a specific choice. 

 

 

Right. Still it's not, in terms of numbers, the MOST COMMON status - and yes, this is the reason "we are still here". Try to procreate with exclusively homosexuals relations, let me know if it works for you. 

 

Please remember that the ultimate instict of every living being is to procreate. Survival instincts above all.

 

I don't see your point, yes everyone here is aware of the fact that you cannot procreate with the same sex.  <_<



#111
l7986

l7986
  • Members
  • 1 837 messages

Honestly with the Orlesian nobles at the ball I kind of expect it since rich people just kind of do whatever anyways and they'll have anyone that disagrees with them killed. More surprised there wasn't a noble walking around with a sheep or a horse or something and introducing them as their spouse.



#112
Primula Nightfall

Primula Nightfall
  • Members
  • 80 messages

Because religious intolerance of homosexuality isn't an inevitability? Because there's no real reason to hew to it when designing one's own religion for a fantasy world?

 

And how is religion relevant, now? I never spoken about "religious intolerance". Why do you think the two things are necessarily connected?

 

 

There are many choices bioware do not allow you to make for many reasons, for example you can't play as a nug.  :blink: It being "a game about choice" is not an argument for the inclusion of a specific choice. 

 

 

I don't see your point, yes everyone here is aware of the fact that you cannot procreate with the same sex.  <_<

 

 

Right, because playing as a nug is the same as saying "I don't agree with you". Are you serious? 

 

And my point was to state it clearly that the "default status" of every species with defined sexes is that of heterosexuality, if we consider the survival of a species the primary objective. Now, while it's not a problem being homosexual by itself, having homosexuality spammed everywhere like if it was the "typical" state of things is rather preposterous and clearly indicates a deliberate choice by BW to just make the noisy minority happy. 



#113
Yinello

Yinello
  • Members
  • 1 370 messages

 

There are many choices bioware do not allow you to make for many reasons, for example you can't play as a nug.  :blink: It being "a game about choice" is not an argument for the inclusion of a specific choice. 

 

 

It's the anti-Nug agenda, I tell you!  :bandit:


  • daveliam, mikeymoonshine, godModeAlpha et 1 autre aiment ceci

#114
PashaPlays

PashaPlays
  • Members
  • 16 messages

Because Bioware is pathetically trying to get on the good side of the SJWs of Tumblr and NeoGAF, an impossible task if you know anything about them.


  • Primula Nightfall aime ceci

#115
Sigma Tauri

Sigma Tauri
  • Members
  • 2 675 messages

 

And my point was to state it clearly that the "default status" of every species with defined sexes is that of heterosexuality, if we consider the survival of a species the primary objective.

 

Default status. Would you like a factory reset, sir?



#116
Primula Nightfall

Primula Nightfall
  • Members
  • 80 messages

Default status. Would you like a factory reset, sir?

 

Oh, please. You know what I mean. Let's try not to nitpick on terminology, it's never useful.



#117
Sigma Tauri

Sigma Tauri
  • Members
  • 2 675 messages

Oh, please. You know what I mean. Let's try not to nitpick on terminology, it's never useful.

 

I'm not picking your nits. There's shampoo for that.


  • Roamingmachine aime ceci

#118
schall_und_rauch

schall_und_rauch
  • Members
  • 483 messages

Next time, we will attend a Tevinter Ball. People's attitude towards gay people on such a social event should satisfy some people here.

 

BTW, I loved the fact that you could be really shocked that the empress had an elven mistress. Because racism is the norm in Thedas. The writers know exactly how to balance their progressivism.



#119
Paul E Dangerously

Paul E Dangerously
  • Members
  • 1 883 messages

Nothing wrong with that, whatever it is Bioware is trying to do. Sometimes, though, they may be trying too hard.

 

That's my feelings on it. Bioware's well intentioned, but they handle things with all the subtlety of a hand grenade.


  • Primula Nightfall, Charoleia et Tatar Foras aiment ceci

#120
Yinello

Yinello
  • Members
  • 1 370 messages

Conjuring fireballs and lightning storms out of nothing, using telekinesis to build bridges, time travel magic and demons pouring from sky holes are perfectly okay but acceptance of homosexuality? THAT'S GOING TOO FAR IN A FANTASY WORLD!


  • schall_und_rauch, Xilizhra, Joy Sauce et 2 autres aiment ceci

#121
Nathair Nimheil

Nathair Nimheil
  • Members
  • 689 messages

Right. Still it's not, in terms of numbers, the MOST COMMON status - and yes, this is the reason "we are still here". Try to procreate with exclusively homosexuals relations, let me know if it works for you.

I don't see your point here. Gender and relationship diversity is well documented to be pro-fitness across a broad range of situations. Why is it so important to you to qualify "common and perfectly normal" with "but still less than 51% statistically!" Who cares?

And as far as reproduction and child care it turns out that adults without their own direct offspring involve themselves in caring for community offspring in varying degrees right up to full fledged adoption of "surplus" or orphaned young in lots of different species. If you don't think that's pro-survival then my son would like to have a word with you.
 

Please remember that the ultimate instict of every living being is to procreate. Survival instincts above all.

Yeah, so we thought back in the 1950s. Then along came George C. Williams and the idea of gene-centred evolution.

But, regardless of that, while "reproduction" is clearly the simplistic "goal" of any living thing, the mechanisms of that reproduction are not always simple. Mechanisms and behaviours are direct, not goal oriented. Animals want to "do reproductive stuff", not necessarily reproduce. Even mechanisms and behaviours that evolved to improve direct reproductive success are open to "subversion". When you evolve permanent pair-bonds you can easily end up with some members of the species forming non-reproductive permanent bonds. Or dogs humping the furniture.

You've also got to remember that "survival instincts" are much, much more complex than you suggest, especially in humans. People die trying to save the children of strangers. Soldiers die for their country. People die for their religion, or ideology or bungie jumping....
  • Sigma Tauri, mikeymoonshine et IamTheXena aiment ceci

#122
mikeymoonshine

mikeymoonshine
  • Members
  • 3 493 messages

Right, because playing as a nug is the same as saying "I don't agree with you". Are you serious? 

 

Yes ofc, focus on the silly example and ignore that actual point.  <_<

 

It is a choice that bioware does not allow you to make, in that sense it is the same. There are many of these and many reasons as to why. 

 

 

 

And my point was to state it clearly that the "default status" of every species with defined sexes is that of heterosexuality, if we consider the survival of a species the primary objective. Now, while it's not a problem being homosexual by itself, having homosexuality spammed everywhere like if it was the "typical" state of things is rather preposterous and clearly indicates a deliberate choice by BW to just make the noisy minority happy. 

 

The "Default State" (odd way of putting it) is a lot of things, last time I checked mages weren't all that common either.  ;)

 

I feel like you are trying to make some kind of evolutionary argument, i'm not sure why you keep banging on about survival being the objective. We are talking about video games here. 

 

I'm sorry that you feel a few gay characters equates to homosexuality being spammed everywhere and I don't see what is wrong with making minorities happy. All of this is sort of irrelevant to the discussion about why we can't be anti gay in DA:I though. 



#123
Primula Nightfall

Primula Nightfall
  • Members
  • 80 messages

Conjuring fireballs and lightning storms out of nothing, using telekinesis to build bridges, time travel magic and demons pouring from sky holes are perfectly okay but intolerance of homosexuality? THAT'S GOING TOO FAR IN A FANTASY WORLD!

 

Fixed it for you



#124
Yinello

Yinello
  • Members
  • 1 370 messages

Fixed it for you

 

Intolerance of homosexuality already exists in some fantasy worlds so your fix is wrong. The fact that you're fighting to change one of the very few worlds that openly accepts homosexuality... Embarassing, man.



#125
daveliam

daveliam
  • Members
  • 8 436 messages

Ugh.  I wake up and check the BSN to see another thread about how 'manly and gross' Cassandra is and then come in here to see pages of 'OH NOES! TEH AGENDA!!!!" posts. 

 

I think I need to take a day off from BSN.

 

Catch y'all on the flip.  I just can't with this place this weekend. 


  • SwobyJ et Yinello aiment ceci