This is a reply to the 'Mass Effect was more consistent' talk that's been bandied about on this thread. I'm aware that this is basically unrelated to the topic at hand, and I have no intention of going round and round on this. So I'm just to say my piece and leave it at that. Because whilst I have no love for Inquisition, I do take issue with this idea that the Dragon Age series is inherently flawed or not as good as Mass Effect and that this game (awful as it IMO is), somehow proves that.
So yes, I just want to say I cannot disagree more with the sentiment that Mass Effect was a consistent series. The latter 2 games maybe, but the change from Hard Sci-fi to more pulpy sci-fi between ME1 and its sequels was jarring beyond belief. ME1 felt believable, and it focused on the realities and awkward compromises that come with entry into new political systems and communities. The focus on how tense the situation between Humanity and everyone else was absorbing and the game did a great game of showing how normally quite reasonable people like Charles Pressly and most of the Turians in the game, lost their cool when the other race was mentioned. Because it was so soon after the war, and Humanity's belligerence and impatient style is so jarring to the Status Quo 'You have to wait your turn like everyone else'.
I felt like all this was abadoned in ME2, despite it only being 2 years (which is the blink of an eye to many aliens). All the nuance and sober realism was thrown out in favour of a pulpy ripping yarn mixed with Film Noir. Which was great on its own terms, but the fact that it was so different in tone, and there was now so much Magic Science in evidence (Shepard coming back from the dead as a bionic superhero commando, EDI in general but particularly her hokey acquiring a fembot body, and her cyberwarfare abilities which seem far more advanced than anything the Geth and Reapers ever use). Along with the Lex Luthor inspired character of TIM, it felt like the series had taken a hard shift into much more overly anime, comic book, superhero style territory.
The lack of consistency between ME1 and ME's 2 and 3 is the very reason I lost interest in the series. I still think its a good series, but the first game was the only one that truly *mattered* to me, When they changed what the series was and how it was being presented, the kinds of stories it was telling and of course the whole 'Cult of The Absolutely Awesome and Amazingly Amazing Commander Shepard' thing that became so unbearable in and out of game, it turned ME from a series that I truly cared about, to one that I could only accept if I seperated the games mentally as being basically standalones, carrying my characater over but very much taking each game for its own individual merits and not dwelling too much on the idea that it was supposed to be one big, continuous story.
And frankly, given how they completely and utterly (IMO anyway) mishandled the Reaper invasion to the point that I just didn't care about it at all, that is much easiet to do than you would think. So I don't accept for one second that the series has been consistent in any way, ME1 is by far the strongest in terms of narrative, ME 2 is probably the most well made and polished of the 3, delivering an experience that whilst it bears no realtion at all to the world of ME1, is on its own merits a fantastic experience. As for ME3, it tried to move back into more serious territory but was now set in a world that was completely unsuitable for that kind of tone. They had allowed individual characters and factions (like EDI, TIM, Shepard, Cerberus etc) to be so ludicrously overpowered and proficient at anything and everything, that the situation never felt as dire as they were saying. Because you were expecting some wave of the magic wand plan, and for these people to always be able to do basically anything they wanted and achieve any outcome just because they were so incredible.
The Hard Sci-fi, Cold war realpolitik of ME1 seemed very, very far away by the end of ME3. Nothing felt like it mattered anymore, because it could all be solved quickly and easily in exceedingly and increasingly unlikely and silly ways.
There, all done. As you were...