One thing for certain, she's neither overly feminized and always in control all the time (since much of this depends on morality)
For me, BroShep is an archetypal greek hero and a representation of Odysseus. Like BroShep, Odysseus also have his share of insta-attraction with the ladies and he was a warrior who was always thwarted by fate whenever he tried to return home. Odysseus was beloved by his people and an excellent warrior. He have his ships and his loyal army. He is adventurous, clever with his tongue and he has his wits. Basically, BroShep is the reincarnation of the classical ideal hero who is filled with confidence, honor and courage. Even Ashley/Liara is technically Penelope... the one who waited for the Hero to return. Even your ME2 lovers are loosely based on the archetypes for the women Odysseus met in his long journey home, the treacherous witch-goddess of magic; Circe, the beautiful enchantress nymph; Calypso and Nausicaa; the virginal princess of Phaeacia. And like Odysseus, BroShep can be ruthless and brutal and he revel in blood and glory and in the end, he can never do wrong as the goddess is with him.
The best way I could think for FemShep, she's not a definite archetypal hero like BroShep but more a representation of the warrior women. She's Athena, Mulan, Joan of Arc, Boudicca, Hippolyta, Fantaghiro, Ratna Kemala, Freyja, Brunhild, Valkyrie or a shieldmaiden who join men in war and the one who decide who live and die in battle. She inspire hope and peace or vengeance in the time of war. She's not sexualized but is a sexual creature. She's not over-feminized but is a feminine woman. And she doesn't inspire great lusts simply by being in a room. Although like BroShep, her story does align with The Odyssey but she's not a complete appropriation of Odysseus. Kaidan, Garrus, Thane and Jacob isn't a greek love archetype of anything as they're all warriors in their own right. FemShep is a mythology of Mass Effect which is uniquely her own which made her unpredictable. That is what made her character attractive to me.
and sorry, for Greek mytho dump but hey, I can't keep on saying the same thing all the time..
Edited to add more.
I can see a bit of what you're saying, but I disagree with the assumption that Femshep's, well, femininity makes her any different than Broshep. For example, doesn't Broshep "inspire hope and peace or vengeance in a time of war?" Isn't he "not sexualized, but a sexual creature?" And if you look at her and Jacob, she certainly does "inspire great lusts just by being in the same room."
Shep's gender does not change their actions or their personality, thus any comparisons between the two based on things they do or how they're perceived are invalid; such things are not gender-dependent.
And do you honestly think there's no mythology involving love between two great warriors?
The LIs are about the only thing that change between the two genders. Let's examine them one by one, shall we?
ME1:
Liara: Ignored, due to being a LI for both genders.
Ashley and Kaiden: Both powerful warriors haunted by past actions (either theirs or their family's). Both act as Persephone, waiting for Shepard.
ME2:
Jack, Garrus, Thane, Miranda: Powerful warriors in their own right, but they all hide emotional trauma that Shepard needs to help them deal with.
Jacob: No data available. (Never actually payed attention to him.)
Tali: The only real "damsel in distress" I found. Needs saving in 2/3 games. Perhaps the most archetypical, even stereotypical female; heavy themes of virginity and purity. At the same time, she's a competent warrior and mechanic, and is capable of performing actions no other character could hope to achieve. See: Saren Recording in ME1.
ME3:
Steve Cortez: Deep-seated emotional issues that Shepard must help him overcome.
Traynor: Not actually attempted yet.
Kaiden (Mshep only): A warrior who, after dealing with his conflicting urges (friend vs soldier), has come to trust his commander on a deeper level than ever.
Mshep does a surprising amount of emotional analysis, something often reserved for feminine characters. He's by no means the stereotypical greek hero, any more than Fshep is.
Modifié par Batarian Master Race, 02 juin 2015 - 02:46 .