Aller au contenu

Photo

Story-wise, who's the best Warrior/Mage/Rogue in the party? (Possible Spoilers)


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
83 réponses à ce sujet

#76
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*

Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
  • Guests

Best noun "that which is the most excellent, outstanding, or desirable."

Here's the problem, everyone has different criteria of what would be best. For some it is the function of the assigned role of the character, for some it is the social interaction and banter.

So with this in mind, I will rank each first by role, and then by desired social interactions.

Tank:
Low level -Cassandra
High level -Blackwall

Melee DPS
toss up - Cole (higher DPS), Iron Bull(Survivability)

Ranged DPS
1. Varric
2. Sera

Caster DPS
1. Dorian
2. Solas
3. Vivienne (she is higher after you make her Heavy Armor with silverite, otherwise she spends most combat dead.)

Caster Utility
1. Solas
2. Dorian
3. Vivienne

Social - completely subjective (based on banter)
1. Varric
2. Solas
3. Cole
4. Cassandra
5. Iron Bull
6. Sera
7. Blackwall
8. Vivienne

 

We're talking how powerful they are from an in-universe/lore perspective completely discounting game play mechanics and roles.



#77
ArvinDulku

ArvinDulku
  • Members
  • 306 messages
 

We're talking how powerful they are from an in-universe/lore perspective completely discounting game play mechanics and roles.

 
Warrior - Cass
Rogue - Cole
Mage - Vivi

Based on your stipulation, those would would my choices I guess.

#78
gothicshark

gothicshark
  • Members
  • 169 messages

We're talking how powerful they are from an in-universe/lore perspective completely discounting game play mechanics and roles.


here's the thing, each and everyone in your party has proven they are equally talented and powerful. the Lore on each has balanced them all.

Examples why any could be considered strongest.
- Varric: Author, rogue with the ultimate Crossbow ever made. Lorewise he's running around with a Bow-powered Machinegun.
- Solas: a weak (Spoiler) who is trying to gain power because he's just(spoiler) and it takes time for a (spoiler) to regain power.
- Cole: A spirit of compassion, who has become human. He's nearly godlike powerful as an assassin.
- Cassandra: A Seeker, ie the most powerful Anti-Mages on the planet.
- Vivienne: First enchanter of Orlais
- Dorian: Understands Time Magic, an impossible type of magic.

#79
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

here's the thing, each and everyone in your party has proven they are equally talented and powerful. the Lore on each has balanced them all.

No they haven't and no it doesn't. 

 

 

- Varric: Author, rogue with the ultimate Crossbow ever made. Lorewise he's running around with a Bow-powered Machinegun.

Not really. He just has a really good crossbow. Bianca, by his own admission, is a better shot. And she's seen for five minutes. 

 

 

- Solas: a weak (Spoiler) who is trying to gain power because he's just(spoiler) and it takes time for a (spoiler) to regain power

 Not a showing of power. Controlling the Anchor, however, is. No one has done anything comparable. 

- Cole: A spirit of compassion, who has become human. He's nearly godlike powerful as an assassin.
Cole didn't become human and never truly can. That aside, how does this balance him out? 

 

 

- Cassandra: A Seeker, ie the most powerful Anti-Mages on the planet.

Not seeing balance.

 

 

- Vivienne: First enchanter of Orlais

Not a showing of power. By your logic, Fiona should be the most powerful mage in Thedas. She isn't. 

 

 

- Dorian: Understands Time Magic, an impossible type of magic.

Again, not an actual showing of abilities. It was a theory, something he can never replicate once the Breach is closed. 


  • Dermain aime ceci

#80
Hornless Qunari/Human DPS

Hornless Qunari/Human DPS
  • Members
  • 189 messages

Iron Bull  - Tank (Badass Mofo)

Viv - Mage (K-E With Barrier is a killer Combo)

Sera - Rogue (Total Destroyer of mobs)



#81
Jackums

Jackums
  • Members
  • 1 479 messages

Cassandra

Cole

Solas



#82
Akkos

Akkos
  • Members
  • 522 messages

Story wise if Cassandra were to be the protagonist of DAI. If the Inquisitor didn't survive the blast or in the fade maybe...

 

Vivienne, Blackwall, Varric and Cole would be in the party, while the rest will be quite irrelevant in the Inquisition.

 

Because no one has the mark, Solas will not join the Inquisition because no one has the Anchor.



#83
New Kid

New Kid
  • Members
  • 950 messages
Depends what you mean by best. I would say Cass and Solas for warrior and mage, but rogue is tough. Varric uses a crossbow, a weapon that requires less skill than daggers or bows. I would say Sera because she earned her skills.

#84
Todrazok

Todrazok
  • Members
  • 551 messages
Storywise in the game eh?

The banter seems to indicate Cassandra being the best warrior.

As for the rogues, Cole seems the best bet, being a ghost.

Mages is the tough one here, but since there was a banter where Vivienne mocks Solas for putting his clothes on fire, Im giving this one to Vivienne. That being said, by the time the campaign ends it's obviously Solas. :)