Aller au contenu

Photo

Insightful criticism of the storytelling...


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
4 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Spectre Impersonator

Spectre Impersonator
  • Members
  • 2 146 messages

http://johnswritersb...ge-inquisition/



#2
New Kid

New Kid
  • Members
  • 950 messages

I don't get why people would be concerned about the choices directly affecting the ending, why would they? Why do they need to? How is the mages/templars going to affect the battle with Corypheus? Or whether the Wardens were recruited?

I also disagree with what he says about choices not having an impact.


  • AshesEleven aime ceci

#3
Frybread76

Frybread76
  • Members
  • 816 messages

Here's the deal:  Either we get a game in which our choices matter and create multiple and widely divergent endings (but with those choices being retconned or resolved in external media because it would be too much work for one game) or we get a game in which our choices don't really matter or only result in a few mildly different endings that can be carried over to the next installment without too much of a headache for the writers/developers.


  • Nyaore et New Kid aiment ceci

#4
King Dragonlord

King Dragonlord
  • Members
  • 513 messages
Those choices do affect the ending because you can keep playing after the ending and they affect your world state

#5
Nyaore

Nyaore
  • Members
  • 2 651 messages

Here's the deal:  Either we get a game in which our choices matter and create multiple and widely divergent endings (but with those choices being retconned or resolved in external media because it would be too much work for one game) or we get a game in which our choices don't really matter or only result in a few mildly different endings that can be carried over to the next installment without too much of a headache for the writers/developers.

Pretty much. If this was a stand alone series, as I think Origins was meant to be, the choices could be as varied and as numerous as the writers could allow themselves to get away with. In a continuing series however, the more choices there are for the player ironically the more restricted the writing team becomes. You can't make each choice impact the word in a unique and earth shattering way without devoting far too much time and resources, and the more and more impactful choices you add eventually you end up with no two world states looking even remotely the same. At that point the writers are backed into a corner, and no one wants that. So they make choices that have flavorful impacts, but at the end of the day won't cause too many headaches down the line.


  • Bob Walker aime ceci