Firstly, there is no "right" or "wrong" answer, since we all know there are no Thedas shaking consequences, either way.
However, the First Blight says hello. What's so special about the First Blight? There were no Wardens, at all. While the Anderfels are still a wasteland, purportedly, they're still there, and people still manage to live there. In the Fifth Blight, how many Wardens were at the archdemon fight? As many as what, 2? With only 3 going in to the Battle of Denerim. The Inquisitor that banishes the Wardens isn't dooming Thedas any more than the Inquisitor that keeps them. The only difference being where the Wardens are. If people that held the remaining archdemons up as some kind of proof that banishing them is bad, there would be no Thedas, because the first archdemon would have destroyed it. It lasted over a century, and there truly were no Wardens to stop him, until the very end. In order for banishing to mean the doom of the "known" world, or at least Orlais and/or Ferelden, it would have to mean that somehow Thedas lost the ability to hold the darkspawn until the Wardens could return. Nothing presented in the time of the choice, or afterwards, supports this.
Aside from the Inquisition, who actually has the manpower to successfully repel the darkspawn should they rise again? Ferelden took a beating during the previous Blight, and Orlais has been involved in a civil war. Top that off with the Elder One's forces hammering them every chance they got; the Freemen using hit and run tactics; Red Templars taking people for their 'mining operations'...well, its going to curtail any serious efforts to raise a large standing force to stand against a darkspawn hoard.
Can we guarantee that there are no long term issues with exile? Simply because Bioware hasn't announced one doesn't mean that they can't figure out how to change it up for the next in the series. We don't know. Rule of thumb is to be prepared. Having more options available to you in any setting is preferable to not. Some people thought that killing Wrex in Mass Effect wasn't big deal. Or that screwing over the Krogan on the Geonophage cure wasn't going to bite them. Now we have left either a Warden or the Champion in the Fade, and someone drank from the Well. Rather than assume that they will amount to nothing, I choose to go with pragmatism and believe they will. Besides, Thedas has just gone through THREE major events. The Fifth Blight, the Mage/Templar War, and the war between the Elder One and the Inquisition. Not to mention the other events going on, like the Orlesian Civil War. If another Archdemon arose during or right after that conflict, EXACTLY how would that go? Aside from the Inquisition, who would be able to hold them off? If you have no Wardens, you will have to wait UNTIL they arrive, THEN lop off its head. I don't know if Morrigan is up for sharing her knowledge OR popping out another kid...so, yeah. When all is said and done? A seriously battered Inquisition, weakened Orlais and Ferelden? Do you REALLY think Tevinter or the Qunari is JUST going to sit there and do nothing? REALLY? A chance to pick off an old enemy and expand your territory? History has shown that it would be the PERFECT time to steamroll your enemy. An army of mages descending upon weakened forces? Yeah, looks bad, and TOTALLY within the realm of possibility. Having Wardens would potentially, but not guarantee that you could reduce the potential losses enough to maintain at least the appearance of a powerful force that would be enough to deter even an expeditionary force from exploratory incursions into your holdings.
Remember that this IS speculation on my part. My opinion. Whilst in the way of saying OVERALL that there is no right decision, according to an individual, and based upon their personal experiences, thoughts, morals and the like, yes there CAN be a 'right' decision. At least personally and I'd rather be over prepared than not.





Retour en haut





