141 réponses à ce sujet

[Chewin]

Why not Medieval 2 and Assassin's Creed 1 or 2?
 
Note: Assassin's Creed 1 Assassins are Shia! Now that makes things interesting.

Never bothered much with Medieval 2 and while I do like the rest of the AC games, I had the most fun with the third entry (mostly in concerns to gameplay). Also, didn't want to have all 4 games to dominate the list.

And yes, a heavily fictionalized version of them at least.

[mybudgee]

Interesting how many part 2's there are on here...

[CrazyRah]

Persona 4: Golden

Zelda: Ocarina of time

GTA: San Andreas

Persona 3

The Walking Dead Season 1

Rome: Total War

Starcraft: Brood War

 

They are the ones that I'd give the most accomplished score

[bmwcrazy]

It's hard to think of a game that's flawless.

The closest is probably Half Life 2.

[Sion1138]

KotOR and Oblivion.

[Nole]

FF IV

FFVI

DAO

Wacraft III

[Ridwan]

Clearly opinion based thread. What in your opinion is the very definition of a 10/10 game.

 

VTMB(With patches)

 

A game that meets the following conditions is a 10/10 game.

 

Reasonable length, replay value, good mechanics, great gameplay, amazing sound, artful graphics (whether 2D or 3D), interesting lore/story (depending on the genre, no one plays Quake, to name an example, for the story.

[Seraphim24]

All this 10/10 discussion is all like

 

 

10/10 is just you know, wow, that game was a lot of fun. Hey, if someone was looking for a game to play, then play this one because I enjoyed it a lot more than a bunch of these other games.

[cronshaw]

Last of Us was probably the best game I've ever played

Portal 2 was superb as well

Mass Effect 1 was right up there

and Fallout 2

[Tacoshark12]

I'm always reluctant to give anything a perfect score but of the games I have played these are the ones I would rate highest.

 

Portal 2

Guild Wars 2

Last Of Us

Uncharted Series

Skyrim

Batman: Arkham City

Minecraft

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

What is a 10/10 game? Everyone should describe that before putting their answers. Because I doubt that a 10/10 game means a game with no flaws. So there needs to be description, parameters.
 

 

Flawless Masterpiece.

 

But there is still this moronic rating tendency: would rate what they like 10/10 and what they dislike 0/10. Fortunately not in this thread.

[Kaiser Arian XVII]

Not cool. I'm out of likes for the 3rd time. Unreal Tournament 2004 is the best multiplayer ever and has awesome singleplayer.

[SomberXIII]

All time favorites.

1. Uncharted 2: Among Thieves
2. Mass Effect 2
3. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
4. Saints Row IV

The four below are almost close to 10.

1. Dead Rising 3
2. Just Cause 2
3. Final Fantasy XIII
4. Tomb Raider

[themikefest]

Uncharted series

ME trilogy

DAO

DAI

Skyrim

Pong

Saints row 2/3/4

Just Cause 2

Tomb Raider

[Seraphim24]

However as games gain in complexity over the years, I now find Doom and it's ilk a bit too simplistic, because Ive become considioned into accepting narrative, or story-driven games as the norm. Games such as Mass Effec and Dragon Age are now kind of the standard for me, and anyting that doesn't immerse me in a similar way now feels stale. Admittedly thought Doom is still pretty fun for a quick stress-relieving blast.

 

Huh, the circles I've been in usually feel the opposite. The purist games of yesteryear often had significantly deeper gameplay and narratives of now usually just means "cinematic" and flourishy without necessarily having any real character or story depth either.

 

I guess what I would say there is an increasing desire to see motivations and interactions beyond "X is a mean ex ranger with a mean streak" as your entire story concept, but so far "story" has basically meant injecting Hollywood style plots and cinema which isn't the solution IMO, first because many Hollywood style plots, despite having extensive dialogue and scenes, I find very vapid and frankly the random programmer who was taping blurbs to the instruction manual is just as qualified to create stories as far as I'm concerned. Second, it's reduced the gameplay incentive. Doom was positively labyrinthine compared to what came after it.

 

I feel like there's also serious bloat in many sequels where it's like, oh we need to give them the Vacuum weapon or the water pistol because that was in the previous games... there's more 'stuff' but it's not always fun.. makes things feel sort of like a chore sometimes I guess.

 

Much of the "complexity" of modern games I just find irritating, to be honest I guess. I'm pretty much just running through setpieces a lot of the time pressing the punch/shoot button... However, it all depends and I've played some that were pretty fun.

 

Lufia II

 

Also can't believe I missed someone posting this one... sunk so many hours into that game once upon a time. So nice.. I don't know if I could give it a 10/10 but it's something.

[Il Divo]

Warcraft III: Reign of Chaos and The Frozen Throne

The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time

Dark Souls

Portal 2

Mass Effect 2