MMO - Guilds War 2
RPG - Heavily modded BG 2
Open World - TES Morrowind (>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Skyrim)
FPS - Serious Sam 2 (I make no apologies for this) // Halo
RTS - Starcraft, all of it.
Sports - Winning Eleven
Notable mention - DAI, for somehow mixing three of my fave genres (MMO, RPG & Open World) and almost pulling it off flawlessly.
Fallout New Vegas
Mass Effect (the entire series, there are certain elements that I love in all three games)
Star Control II (one of spiritual predecessors for Mass Effect)
Cobra Mission (an old hentai JRPG with a cliched plot which I like playing and replaying nevertheless)
Sensible World of Soccer (yes, I'm a bit of old-timer, right 
)
I'd only give a 10 to a game with zero game breaking bugs or flaws that othewise mar the game's quality. I mean, this is an absolutely perfect score, so it can't be given to even spectacular games if they suffer from bugs (sorry Bethesda)... so my list is pretty short (edit: or it would have been had I not kept coming back to add things...)...
Grand Theft Auto: Vice City
Street Fighter Alpha 3
Marvel vs. Capcom 2
Deus Ex
Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
Tactics Ogre
Tekken 3
Halo
Halo 2
Since I just made a big deal about glitches, I'll just say that I never saw any in those games...
Guest_mikeucrazy_*
GTA:III
HALO1-3
WoW
DA:O
ME1-3
AC1,3,Rev and 4
Dark Souls
Alan Wake
Skate
and of Course The Elder Scroll Series
Mario World 3
Super Mario World
Ocarina of Time
The Original Starcraft
Baldur's Gate
Legend of Dragoon
Legaia 2
Ninja Gaiden
Kotor 1&2
WoW
Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance
God of War
Call of Duty 4
Mass Effect
DA:O
Dark Souls
Cook Serve Delicious
Telltales:The Walking Dead
XCOM
I'm sure there are plenty more but those are the stand-outs from five generations of consoles and PC.
10/10 is hard to come by b/c that's literally perfection. I'm an English teacher and rarely give 100s because that means the person wrote a perfect essay, above and beyond the call of duty. That hardly ever happens. So in games...
...I could only give that to Portal. Which isn't to say that's the only game I've truly loved. But that game was perfect. I don't know how it could have been improved. Nothing additional needed.
Not because it my favourite game.. But it deserve it imo. Still love to listen to the soundtrack.
10/10 is hard to come by b/c that's literally perfection. I'm an English teacher and rarely give 100s because that means the person wrote a perfect essay, above and beyond the call of duty. That hardly ever happens. So in games...
...I could only give that to Portal. Which isn't to say that's the only game I've truly loved. But that game was perfect. I don't know how it could have been improved. Nothing additional needed.
You... I really disliked teachers like you. LOL
In principle, you are absolutely right. However in practice, only the tiniest majority of teachers grade this way, so it results in (slightly) unbalanced equivalences. If you'd give most good papers an A, the impact is minimal. But if you truly believe half the class should get a C based on the bell curve... that's a problem (but it sounds like you don't do that, so I'll stop my rant here).
I said 100s, not A's 
-Championship Manager/Football Manager Series. Out of self protection, I have not upgraded since FM2012. FM2015 is looking so tasty though... first version I played was Championship Manager Italia, which was the 1993-1994 season, I think...
-Civilization III, IV & V
-Baldur's Gate 'Trilogy'
-Mass Effect Trilogy
-Megaman 2
-Crono Trigger
-Dragon Age: Inquisition. Excluding the Civ en CM/FM games, it's been well over a decade since I've played a game that so easily made me lose track of time.
-NBA2K15. Best RPG ever.
-Super Mario World
-Super Mario 64
-Super Metroid
-Metroid Prime (I think)
-Little Big Planet.
And I'm probably forgetting a tonne. I've been playing games for 25 years.
Pff.
10/10 would literally mean a perfect game, and given how lengthy games tend to be, most of them are going to have something that's annoying or doesn't quite work somewhere along the line.
Fallout 3 might be my personal favorite game, just because it was the first one that really drew me into its world and kept me captivated after I started trying some of the more complex PC games about four years ago. But I'm certainly not going to claim that it doesn't have problems - the over-the-top exploding heads, bad companion AI, and NPCs who just repeat the same few sentences over and over again, for starters. Mass Effect has clunky combat and a "Race Against Time" that isn't a race against time. Dragon Age: Origins has combat sequences that drag on and on when what I wanted to was to get on with the story. Almost any game with dialogue choices has a few scenes where there isn't an option to express what I'd like to have my character express.
Mega Drive's Scooby Doo Mistery (considering when it was released)
Dragon Age: Origins
Final Fantasy XI
Lost Odyssey
Crusader Kings 2
Fallout: New Vegas
The Sims (Original)
Onimusha 2
The Witcher 2
Donkey Kong Country 2
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
Portal 2
999 & VLR
Zelda: Majoras Mask
Baldurs Gate 2
Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons
Hell yeah! I need to play VLR. Terrible anime guru sama told I should wait for the third game to play VLR but it's probably never coming out now.
Guest_TrillClinton_*
Hell yeah! I need to play VLR. Terrible anime guru sama told I should wait for the third game to play VLR but it's probably never coming out now.
lmao who is Terrible animu guru sama?
Guest_Catch This Fade_*
lmao who is Terrible animu guru sama?
Some dude that used to be a Geth. I forgot the name he goes by now. So he's terrible anime guru sama.
Some dude that used to be a Geth. I forgot the name he goes by now. So he's terrible anime guru sama.
Hmmm...
Guest_TheDarkKnightReturns_*
Morrowind is the only game to date with others coming damn close.
- Persona 4 Golden.
- Rome Total War.
- Crusader Kings 2.
- XCOM: Enemy Unknown.
- Metal Gear Solid: Snake Eater.
There are no 10/10 games for me. Perfection is not something you ever reach, it's something you constantly strive for.
When it comes to my favourite games, then my list would be quite long... but many of them are clearly not perfect.
Retour en haut
