The forest was dense and wild; underbrush thick with thorns and treacherous vines prevented any thought of straying from the path. And there was a path—narrow and crooked and muddy, like a game trail. The idea made Uth'shiral nervous—following a game trail was a fantastic way to meet predators. It was, however, the only way forward, and as long as the birds continued to sing from the branches, she supposed it was safe enough. What she'd do if the birds fell silent, she wasn't sure. She didn't think she'd be able to fight her way through the thorny brush more quickly than a native predator could.
She paused for a moment, leaning against a tree trunk and trying to remember where she was going. It was odd, being somewhere like this without her companions, and not knowing how she got there or where she was heading. It was something important; she remembered that much. She thought that this must be the Arbor Wilds; the birds and vegetation seemed similar. She'd promised not to return there, though. Was she breaking that promise? Maybe she'd strayed too far off the main path. Where were Cassandra and Varric?
The Inquisitor glanced behind her, half expecting someone to be jogging toward her, catching up to her lead. But instead, the game trail wound through the woods and vanished.
It must be important, whatever it was. She'd promised Abelas that she would never return to the Arbor Wilds, but with luck a Sentinel would see her and guide her to the exit, rather than attacking her on sight. It was a genuine mistake, after all—Abelas would understand. He wouldn't be happy, but he'd understand.
Wait... Abelas. Wasn't she here looking for him? Lavellan frowned to herself and stepped away from the tree, continuing her hike. They'd parted ways before she had ever returned to Skyhold. He hadn't welcomed her intrusion before, and later...
Later, despite seeming to view her as little more than a burden and a means to an end, he had thrown away whatever goals he had, declared her his friend, and... stayed, at least for a while. Abelas had returned to the Arbor Wilds to grieve for what could not be restored.
“Are you sure it wasn't your fault?” a voice asked from her right.
Uth'shiral glanced sharply, but nothing was there.
“If you'd been a better friend, maybe he would have stayed. Maybe he could have moved on,” the voice continued from behind her. She spun, but saw nothing as her heart began to race. The voice was deep and calm, with a faint hiss behind it.
“Or,” the voice continued, above her this time, “maybe he would have been better off if you'd never intruded here at all. He might have succeeded in fending off Corypheus without your help. Or he might be dead. Is dead not better than suffering?”
The Inquisitor looked up, but frowned as she saw nothing yet again. Had she taken too much lyrium, or was there a demon somewhere near?
“An excellent question. I could be a demon. Demon or not, I could be inside you even now,” the voice mused, from in front of her this time. “Maybe I was in you all along, as you agonized over each decision you made. Maybe I am the reason for your successes. Maybe I am the reason for your failures. Could you even achieve greatness on your own? It was always the Anchor. His Anchor. Solas raised you up to be a hero despite your wishes, and he didn't stay. Weren't you good enough? Hadn't you been successful? Now you stand on a pillar, and no one's waiting below to catch you if you fall. How long do you think you can stay there?”
There was nothing in front of Uth'shiral—nothing she could see. She backed away slowly, turning back toward the game path. “Abelas?” she asked, picking up her pace. If she could find him, he'd help her against this demon.
“Are you certain of that? He called you 'friend,' but he meant to use you to find Solas. Every bit of aid and effort to keep you alive for just a while longer, was for that goal. Maybe it wasn't ever kindness. Maybe it was cold practicality. Just like all the others—he wants you to help him, but he won't thank you for it in the end. How quickly friendship is forgotten in the face of a new goal.” The voice sounded pitying. It galled Uth'shiral that this... thing, whatever it was, wherever it was, had the nerve to pity her.
“And what of Solas? Kind, gentle Solas, who laughed as he trapped his kin in torment for all time. Solas, the Dread Wolf, the betrayer, the author of the elves' downfall.”
Uth'shiral forced herself to ignore the voice as it continued onward, giving voice to every angle of every concern she had. If she listened for too long, she might break. She might simply stop and curl up and cry in defeat and self-pity. She could not do that; she had work to do. She had people to help, rifts to close, and a world to explore.
“Abelas!” Lavellan shouted. She worried that the voice of the—spirit? Demon?--drowned out her voice, but she had to try. She ran onward, shaky, her legs sinking and slipping in the mud of the game trail—mud that persisted despite the brilliant sunlight and clear sky overhead.
“Are you certain he is a friend...?” the voice whispered into her ear.
“Go away!” she snapped. “Abelas!” she called again, and lost her footing to the mud. She crashed facefirst into the slippery mess, struggling to return to her feet. It was too hard—the mud was slippery and she couldn't get a purchase. She groaned and slumped in defeat.
“Inquisitor! Why are you--”
“Invading your most private sanctuary, even as she invaded the Temple of Mythal. This place is not for her,” the voice thundered. “Does she understand you? Does she respect you? How could she? Shemlen act blindly, with no understanding of the world. You tangle with such small fears. Isn't she the real threat?”
“Tangle with--” The telltale sounds of metal and magic reached her, but it was far away. She had to get there. Her friend was in trouble. She had to help. Although she was exhausted from battling with the mud, she mustered some of her magic. Enough heat, and the mud should dry. Then she could--
The ground crackled beneath her, scaly flakes of dried mud forming on top of the slippery mess. It wasn't much, and it wasn't perfect, but it was enough. She regained her footing, casting the same fire spell along the ground ahead of her as she charged toward the sounds of battle. The more confident she was of the results, the sturdier the ground became as she ran.
“Abelas, I'm on my way!” Lavellan shouted, as the shrieks and howls of demons came ever closer.
“Do you think he needs your help? Did he ever need your help?” the voice goaded.
“If you intend to be of use, then hurry!” Abelas called back.
“How could a shemlen be of use to you? If you can't make yourself wake, how could she manage it? Maybe you should have gone with Solas. You could have helped yourself. You could have helped the others. You still could. You haven't really decided anything, even now. I know.”
“Haven't I?” Abelas roared back, over the shriek of a fear demon.
“Wake? This is a dream?” Uth'shiral mumbled under her breath. Well, everything made more sense, then. She was still on that rickety fishing boat, trying to wake Abelas. Abelas, who was fighting demons and needed help right now, according to Cole.
She pushed herself harder. Knowing it was a dream meant she also knew she wasn't going to run out of energy or lose her breath.
She almost ran into Abelas's sword as he spun to face what he expected to be another attacker. They were in the courtyard of the Temple of Mythal, and it was far more ruined than it had been in person. In fact, she could swear it was crumbling before her very eyes, as fear demons leapt from the ground, shrieking in fury as they attacked.
Abelas was fast, and sturdy, but he was one man against at least ten fear demons. Uth'shiral hastily threw a barrier over them both as she struggled to think. Cole's existence had taught her that even demons might be spirits; Solas had taught her that it was mostly a matter of perception. Not knowing what Abelas was afraid of, she had no idea how he saw the demons. Still... even with two of them, they were going to have trouble fighting so many. They thrashed at her barrier, shrieking their rage and frustration. The Inquisitor struggled to remain calm. They were fear demons; fear would feed them.
The easiest way to defeat them would be to look at them as something other than fear. If wisdom could become pride, if purpose could become desire, what had the fear demons once been before they became dangerous? Fear was so primal that it was difficult to imagine it being anything else. She'd heard of spirits of valor; maybe such a spirit could turn against its courageous nature and become a bullying fear demon.
“Where is the honor in attacking people weaker than you are?” Uth'shiral demanded of a demon—no, she must think of them as spirits—as it swiped at her barrier. She cast the spell again, strengthening the protection as Abelas continued fighting.
“What are you doing? How is that going to help?” Abelas demanded.
“Did you expect better from a shemlen?” the omnipresent voice asked, its condescending tone making Uth'shiral long to punch it – if only she knew where it was. So instead, she forced herself to focus on the spirit she was addressing.
“You greatly outnumber us. This is not an honorable battle. And in the end, you gain nothing from it. No honor, no commendation for your bravery. And no emotion to strengthen you. We will simply be dead and gone.”
Was it her imagination, or did the spirit hesitate? But it was only one, and the others continued to attack.
“Why are you trying to reason with them?” Abelas snapped. “Focus and cast your spells!” He slashed at a demon that appeared from the ground far too close, then kicked away one that reached for Uth'shiral as she cast yet another barrier over them.
“You could make the fight more fair. You could help us instead. I'd make sure your efforts are mentioned. It would be one of the bravest things you've ever done,” Uth'shiral continued.
The spirit abruptly changed; so quickly she did not even see the change. Rather than a bony thing with many teeth, it had become an elven woman in heavy armor, a golden glow surrounding it. “Yes. There is no honor in this. Let us be allies, if only for now.”
“It could still be fear,” the voice cautioned. “Perhaps you are deceived.”
“It's Valor and it's helping!” Lavellan snapped.
“Reasoning with it was a risky plan,” Abelas said, “but I am thankful you succeeded. “We must fight harder. With three of us fighting, we may stand a chance.”
“Or we could even the numbers further,” Lavellan responded. She settled a fresh barrier over Abelas and Valor. “What else could become fear? Valor does not appeal to the others.”
“You were fortunate to turn even one of them,” the Voice said. “Is it worth risking your allies' lives to keep trying? They know what they are!”
“SILENCE!” Abelas snapped at the Voice, as he stabbed at yet another fear demon. “All you do is speak of worry!” He circled around to Uth'shiral's back, shoving away a demon she had not even known was there. “Fear is primal,” he said. “Many other emotions turn to fear. We do not have time to go through every single one of them, not if you plan to survive. Pay attention! Three of us can do this.”
Valor jumped back as a fear spirit began to rise beneath it, and swung its sword hard. The fear spirit roared, barely injured by a blow that would have cleaved Uth'shiral in two.
“They're strong...” Uth'shiral observed. Her impulse was to strengthen their barriers, but she had strengthened them as much as she could. She had to either fight, or speak, and she'd gotten an idea. She had no idea if it would work; it could even backfire. Still, she had to try.
The Inquisitor took a deep breath, and then she addressed the Voice. “Are you sure you know what they are? They don't seem to be doing much thinking about anything.”
“Do you even know why you are attacking?” the Voice asked the fear spirits. “Or do you attack and attempt to inspire fear because you are the ones who are afraid?”
“Did it just...?” Abelas swung his pommel at a spirit that was edging too close to Valor. Valor slashed at another spirit that was trying to reach Uth'shiral. And Uth'shiral cast a paralysis glyph on the ground near one that was walking toward Abelas.
“I'm not sure,” Uth'shiral answered honestly. It seemed to be working, but could she trust the Voice? What if it couldn't change anything anyway?
“What would happen if you stopped fighting? Would they stop, too? Would they pursue you if you fled? If you continue to fight, they might destroy you. There are many of you, but even now they stand against you. What will happen when one of you is destroyed?”
Some of the fear spirits hesitated.
“If you hadn't attacked Sorrow, would he have fought you? Is it too late to stop? Was it wise to attack this prey? Even your own kin turn against you. What happens when you lose another?” the Voice persisted.
The fear spirits had ceased to attack. They milled uncertainly for a moment. One abruptly broke away and fled; another followed. The remainder began to look hazy and uncertain. Abelas and Valor remained defensive, and Uth'shiral maintained her barriers. The spirits, however, gave up the attack. Whatever doubt they had that had caused them to cease, they now seemed resolved that it was wiser not to attack. Uth'shiral wasn't sure if they were still Fear, or Caution, or something else entirely, but one by one, the remainder milled away—likely confused and questioning the nature of their existence. Tomorrow they might be fear spirits again, but today they had a chance to be something else. And not a single one of them had to die for it—a seemingly impossible positive outcome, especially given how much of a fight they'd given the fear spirits. She almost couldn't believe that her hasty plan had succeeded.
“Thank you. A better row hasn't been had in centuries,” Valor stated, breaking Lavellan's reverie. “Who would have thought that they were all such cowards? Ah, but a win is a win.”
“Yes,” Abelas replied, seeming more than a little confused himself. “A win is a win...”
“Unless it isn't. You're still here, sleeping,” the Voice pointed out.
“Thank you for reminding me, Doubt. I had hardly noticed,” Abelas responded sourly.
“I'm here to help,” the Inquisitor said. “Cole was sure I could wake you. The fear spirits are gone, so there's nothing holding you here anymore.”
“I am severed from the waking world, Inquisitor. It is not a simple matter. Without Mythal's geas to call me to service, I cannot wake. If I had known, I would not have slept so deeply.”
“You said you woke every time there were intruders at the Temple. Surely there's some way to drag yourself out of the Fade.”
“Is there? And does he want to? He said he would like to find a place free of shemlen, to enter the blissful sleep of eternity. Perhaps he has,” Doubt said solemnly.
“That is no longer what I want. It would be easier to sleep, but I wish to be awake for what is to come,” Abelas said firmly.
“Ah, but if you wake, who do you help?” Doubt replied. “What you wanted is within reach, and yet...”
“And yet.” For some reason, Abelas turned away from Uth'shiral, as if it were painful to see her.
“Be brave,” Valor said. “Your spirit is strong. Even if you choose unwisely, you have the strength to choose, and the strength to continue even if the decision was the wrong one. You will endure.”
“Will he? I wonder,” Doubt replied.
“Don't listen to Doubt for now,” the Inquisitor said. “You came here, so you know there must be a way out. We just have to find it.” She glanced around, but the temple was in ruins and surrounded by jungle. Except...
“The paths! The only reason you didn't attack us on sight was because we walked them,” Uth'shiral said. “We should try that now. You know the paths from years of watching people come to petition Mythal, so that part's easy. If it doesn't open a way for you to wake, then maybe Mythal will come and poke you awake or something. It might be wishful thinking, but isn't it better than doing nothing? Valor, what do you think?”
Valor shrugged. “Puzzles are not my expertise. If you intend to walk those silly puzzles, this is where we part ways. I shall be off finding an honorable opponent. I would not do well to fall to my fear again.”
“I am not a petitioner, I am--” Abelas objected.
“Someone who needs help,” Lavellan cut him off. “It doesn't matter who you are, or were. Do you know another way?”
“I have tried,” he admitted. “The forest only leads back to here, whichever way I try. Perhaps it is the influence Doubt has gained over this place.” He made a displeased sound in the back of his throat, then strode toward the first path. “With the state this place is in, the paths may require both of us to reach the inner sanctum.”
“The paths may only lead you back to here,” Doubt said. “Perhaps there isn't an exit at all.”
“Don't listen to it.,” Uth'shiral warned. “What we need right now is certainty. If we don't focus on our goal...”
“I know,” Abelas snapped even as he stepped onto the golden path with quick, sure strides that made Uth'shiral feel suddenly envious. He might have hundreds, even thousands, of years of experience from watching others walk these paths, but he made it look simple. She remembered how she had agonized over every slow step, almost hopping from tile to tile. The Temple of Mythal had been built for taller elves—elves like Abelas. “It is likely I know more about certainty than you do. Doubt seems to feel a particular kinship with you, but these paths hold no room for it. Watch my steps and if the path does not stay lit, follow them exactly.”
“I'm not the one who's trapped in her own dreams,” the Inquisitor grumbled, but she did pay close attention. The paths were not in as good of condition as she thought. The structure had crumbled around them, blocking some areas. Abelas, after walking two of them with no help from her, finally hesitated. “I do not recognize this path,” he noted. “The rest I have walked from memory. This one is... new.” His eyes narrowed as he examined the arrangement of the tiles. “Perhaps if I walk it, I can leave. But the debris...” He hesitated. “It may be better to remain here, and try to repair the damage. This place should be... more. If--”
“No. You said there is no room for doubt. You've seen others walk these paths. I'm sure you walked them once, too. Look, if I walk over this side...” She hopped onto the tiles without thinking, golden light shining beneath her feet. “Ah. I shouldn't have done that, should I?”
“Probably not,” Abelas answered with a wry smile, “But you are correct. If you walk that side, and I step here...” He stepped lightly onto a tile on the opposite side.
The tile began to crumble beneath her feet. She stumbled, then jumped to the next as the tile she had stood on plummeted into endless darkness. “Well... that doesn't look good. We've got to be quick!”
“There is no room for doubt here,” Abelas agreed, hopping quickly to the next tile. Behind him, his own previous tile crumbled and fell. “We must be quick. Do not fall!”
“This is very complicated to do quickly,” Doubt mused. “I don't know if you can do it.”
“Neither do I, but I'm trying anyway!” Uth'shiral hurriedly jumped to another tile, and another, trying to always keep the path ahead clear. If she didn't leave a path... those tiles weren't magically reappearing. It could be an illusion; this was the Fade. But she didn't want to risk it.
On the other side, separated by crumbled statuary and weedy plants, Abelas's steps were a more graceful and measured mirror of her own. He managed to look completely composed despite the danger—but then, she'd seen how well he could jump when he had called up steps to the Well of Sorrows. He might be fine. Unless, of course, her hunch were correct and this was the way out. In that case, if they failed, he'd be stuck here, and his body would be thrown overboard. It would cause no end of trouble for the remnants of Clan Lavellan.
She forced herself to focus; this part of the path was simple. Two tiles right, one tile up, two tiles left, forward again, all the way right, all the way left, up and right and down and loop around the broken Fen'harel... She was now ahead of the deterioration by several tiles. She glanced over to check on Abelas; he was lagging behind. The tile behind him shattered. He jumped just in time.
“Careful! Forward and left and go around Ghilan'ain,” she said. “You're faster than me and you're used to this! The path is easy right now!”
“I do not know what your path looks like, but this one is anything but simple,” Abelas answered in a distracted voice. “Please stay quiet until we cross. The path is long and treacherous, and I do not know if we will find an exit at the end, or another path.”
“Stay focused! This is your way out. It has to be! I can get out even without it. Cole will help me. Just hurry! If you fall--”
“I will not fall.” He took a few quick leaps in quick succession; though his path looked the same from her vantagepoint across from him, it did appear to be more complicated. More complicated meant slower. Her friend was in danger.
If she could finish her side quickly, maybe she could stand at the end and guide him forward. She began to run, only to have the path open up into a wide path with several statues in the middle of it. Or maybe her path would get more complicated and she'd make a fatal error. She took a deep breath and considered it for a moment. If she went right, she could weave in and out around the statues, and go back up and forward. But she had to be quick. A quick glance behind her showed the falling tiles catching up to her, and now the statuary was falling, too. There was no safe place to cling to if the tiles fell. She couldn't help Abelas, and he wasn't going to be able to help her, either. She walked more quickly, but the golden tiles behind her were falling more quickly too. A massive wall that once held some statue or other blocked her friend from view. Would he make it? He was more agile than she, and more familiar with the layouts of these paths. More familiar with solving them. It was entirely possible that they had been changed from time to time, so no repeat petitioner would have them memorized. Abelas would be fine, she told herself.
The tile beneath her feet cracked. She jumped to the next as it fell, breaking into a jog. Every tile was now cracking beneath her feet, but she was able to see the end of the path ahead, merging with the path on the other side. She pushed herself harder, and the harder she pushed the faster the tiles cracked beneath her. Just one more tile, one more and she would be at the end. Only one! She gave a quick hop and she was clear, her feet firmly on stable ground.
Abelas appeared beside her from his side of the maze, and leaped lightly to the final tile—just as it dropped. His hands clung to the edge of the floor, digging for purchase. Uth'shiral leaped to action. She lunged for his arm, and gave as solid a tug as she could.
They tumbled backward into an awkward pile. Only then did Uth'shiral have time to wonder how she was able to move an armored man who was considerably taller and more muscular than she was.
“I thought you were the quick one,” Uth'shiral said, prying herself from beneath Abelas.
“My path was more difficult,” he answered, standing abruptly to escape their awkward position. “Thank you, though. I know the way from here. I shall see you on the ship.” He hastily ran to the other end of the room they were in, bounded up a staircase, and vanished through a massive golden door.
Just as she considered following Abelas through the door, Uth'shiral woke.