183 réponses à ce sujet

[Kappa Neko]

I agree. He might be more INFP tho. I am not sure, but this is close call. Anyways, its one of 2 - either INFP or INTP. It cant be INTJ or INFJ because, Solas have Ni (introverted Intuition) in his shadow (weak function of him, seeing what he did and how he did, misjudging implications), and this function is main strong side of  INFJ and INTJ types.

No way is he an INFP. He's way way too sure of himself for that *g*

 

Now that I'm home and have done a quick function check, I see what you guys mean about INTP. The function description does fit quite well, oddly the description I read doesn't at all to me. (Socially awkward? Not at all.) The description of an INTJ fits much better for whatever reason...

(Haven't finished the game yet, so I can't comment on his behavior further than Wicked Eyes.)

 

What still bugs me though is P. Again I'm speaking more from personal experience with two INFPs and one ISFP. In connection with what I keep reading about P types. Isn't P always changing their opinion? Never quite certain, doubtful. Needs reassurance. Not organized and much more open to things outside their (belief) system than J types? Less judgmental? "Warmer", for a lack of better word. My ISFP friend is a fuzzy cute chaotic artist girl. My INFP friend is a very warm person too. My best friend describes me as looking at people like observing insects. Like I am not part of human silliness. A bit like Sherlock, only much much more emotional and faaaar less logical *g*

That's why I got the idea of a dark INFJ, but would accept INTJ. This condescending quiet arrogance of his, you know.

I know that P types value autonomy above everything. They care little for society's rules. It *does* fit Solas. But his detached rigidness is something I associate with J. That confuses me. Then again, Solas is pretty wishy-washy about the elves. He sulks, is mopey when you disagree. Yeah, ok,  INTP ;P

 

 

Solas was easy for me - I'm INTP. It was like looking in a mirror.

Do you happen to know the difference to a misguided INFJ in a descriptive way, not function-wise? I'm still curious...

 

 

I agree with Cole as INFP. Dreamy and melancholy, and somewhat childlike? Check.

 

I would say Cullen is slightly extroverted for the same reasons Carmen_Willow stated. Extroverts can be quite private and need quiet time too, like my ENFJ friend, but he's more a sensor. I agree with ESFJ or ISFJ more than ESTJ simply because he's quite the softie, a very warm person. Family matters to him. My mom is an ISFJ and she would NEVER want to be a leader. Nor would I. But I can if I have to. I've been language team lead on projects but I hated the pressure. I was highly stressed. At the same time J types can be pedantic, so I liked things being organized my way *g*

Cullen is at ease in his position I think.

 

Obviously, I'm totally no expert, so I'll just shut up

[MWImexico]

I don' know much about this but I think this description fits for Cullen :

 

http://www.16persona...sfj-personality

 

 

[AtreiyaN7]

If I'm an INTJ like the test said...then I guess I'm in good company with Morrigan on that chart. Reading the analysis did describe me fairly accurately, and I was also left vastly amused by seeing a quote from Harlan Ellison in the analysis (the man has always been one of my heroes as a writer *coughs and points to her own Ellison quote*).

 

Well, this has been quite interesting in terms of personal insights, along with reading the analyses of these characters that other people are coming up with.

[Sah291]

What still bugs me though is P. Again I'm speaking more from personal experience with two INFPs and one ISFP. In connection with what I keep reading about P types. Isn't P always changing their opinion? Never quite certain, doubtful. Needs reassurance. Not organized and much more open to things outside their (belief) system than J types? Less judgmental? "Warmer", for a lack of better word.

Yes...*P types tend to reserve judgment until they have all the facts...that's why we never plan ahead, lol. There are always potentially more facts we overlooked, and other possibilities to consider, so we have to constantly revise our theories.

[Blackstork]

You guys must less look on main letters and more deeper into the functions. Different intepritations are not that accurate as certain function analysis, both primary and shadow ones. It's cool to use different descriptions from this or that site as additional  proof, but the functions are things that matter.

I am very confused about Cullen, i didnt went deep with his questes, so one who romanced him should have own analysis cause he knows him "better".

He can be ISFJ too. I incl;ined now he is either ESFJ or ISFJ now, but thats require certain digging.

 

 

 

What still bugs me though is P. Again I'm speaking more from personal experience with two INFPs and one ISFP. In connection with what I keep reading about P types. Isn't P always changing their opinion? Never quite certain, doubtful. Needs reassurance. Not organized and much more open to things outside their (belief) system than J types? Less judgmental? "Warmer", for a lack of better word.

 

@Kappa Nekko - i think you using descriptions that are usable towards any type, and are falling out of scope of MBTI classification. Any one can be warm, every one need reassurance. Even ISTJ - he need reassurance in his own emotions and feelings of others towards him, because he do not understand emotions of others, while other time will need other type of reassurance. MBTI are not deviding into cold/warm. Anyone can be anything, in different parts of their life/phase. The simple who got which methods, how percieving world, what one see immideately, and what things remain invisible to same person. You cant tell X is cold, Z is warm, this will be utter  wrongness. I'ts just about  different ways that will be required for different people to reach same point. Excuse me, but that is sure misintepritation of whole meaning of MBTI. Simple each one have different lenses and tools. What each one do with their tools and lenses - its their buisness. Generally, you can do anything, simply, only some things are easier for one, while others - for another. Eveyone warm in some scope, simply each one have different scopes and places to be warm , hehe :V

 

 

Solas is INTP, for sure. Check Jungean functions in matching into each one of 8 slots you will see. He is Ti guy, Ive said he is INTP before, and i return to that point firmly now.

again ,those different site interpritations are fancy, but firstly  functions provide much accurate analysis, while some interpritations could be actually misguiding.

\Please read this - this resource provides VERY deep MBTI analysis (the functions go in backwards order - starts iwht 8th shadow, ands with 1th primary

:

http://www.sociotype...types/ILI-INTp/

[MWImexico]

...

I am very confused about Cullen, i didnt went deep with his questes, so one who romanced him should have own analysis cause he knows him "better".

He can be ISFJ too. I incl;ined now he is either ESFJ or ISFJ now, but thats require certain digging...

 

I have romanced him once, I'm not sure but by elimination, I think he's ISFJ.

[Blackstork]

I have romanced him once, I'm not sure but by elimination, I think he's ISFJ.

does this fit?

www.sociotype.com/socionics/types/ESI-ISFj/

pls start to read from bottom, because primaries re at bottom at that site, and shadow on the top

 

btw i dug shadow functions of ISFJ, and if we remember what been of Cullen in Circle of Magi in DA:O ... well, another pointer that ISFJ might be true for him.

[Panda]

I don' know much about this but I think this description fits for Cullen :

 

http://www.16persona...sfj-personality

 

That's the site I was originally choosing and I chose ISFJ for him then ^^ However I wonder how Cullen's leader part of personality and self-confidence works with the type. Otherwise I think he has many ISFJ traits ^^

[MWImexico]

does this fit?

www.sociotype.com/socionics/types/ESI-ISFj/

pls start to read from bottom, because primaries re at bottom at that site, and shadow on the top

 

btw i dug shadow functions of ISFJ, and if we remember what been of Cullen in Circle of Magi in DA:O ... well, another pointer that ISFJ might be true for him.

 

Honestly, I have not read everything carefully, but I think that this description is sufficiently vague to match. XD  Anyway, I have not read a passage that could enter in direct contradiction with the perception I have of his personality, I suppose. Sorry, that's the best I could do giving the circumstances.

[Addai]

What still bugs me though is P. Again I'm speaking more from personal experience with two INFPs and one ISFP. In connection with what I keep reading about P types. Isn't P always changing their opinion? Never quite certain, doubtful. Needs reassurance. Not organized and much more open to things outside their (belief) system than J types? Less judgmental? "Warmer", for a lack of better word. My ISFP friend is a fuzzy cute chaotic artist girl. My INFP friend is a very warm person too. My best friend describes me as looking at people like observing insects. Like I am not part of human silliness. A bit like Sherlock, only much much more emotional and faaaar less logical *g*
That's why I got the idea of a dark INFJ, but would accept INTJ. This condescending quiet arrogance of his, you know.
I know that P types value autonomy above everything. They care little for society's rules. It *does* fit Solas. But his detached rigidness is something I associate with J. That confuses me. Then again, Solas is pretty wishy-washy about the elves. He sulks, is mopey when you disagree. Yeah, ok,  INTP ;P

Detachment really doesn't have anything to do with J/P, however. That's an I/E thing, and rigidity is a T trait.

I also wouldn't say that P's are necessarily warmer than J's. Their reluctance to commit can be downright insensitive. Think of the person who not only forgets your birthday, they're not sure why you should care. Contrast that to an ESFJ who's johnny on the spot with your favorite cookies and the perfect card.

Solas does look for others' ideas, especially in those areas where he's unsure of himself, like the nature of the Breach or how he should approach his long-term goals. I think half his arguments with other companions, like Sera, are him testing ideas, and he's willing to change his opinion if convincingly proved wrong.

 

This is fun, by the way.

[leadintea]

Ugh... This was a painful thread to read at work. So many stereotypes and misunderstandings just being tossed about! I had so much to say but I don't wanna spend a lot of time going over every single poster's arguments about the characters, so I'm just gonna focus on Cullen and Solas. Now, I believe that before people start tossing out analyses on characters using the MBTI, they should probably do a little research and understand how the system works. Fact of the matter is that Cullen cannot be any type of FJ because he has absolutely no Fe. Fe is all about being in harmony with the feelings, morals, and mood of the society a person is in. Does this sound like Cullen at all? No, absolutely not. If you say "Yes," you completely ignored his interactions with others and his entire character throughout the game. We're talking about a character that disregards an important institute in Thedas, that everyone reveres, when it gets in the way of his job and has no problems getting confrontational with a key member of said institute, a character that absolutely hates a culture that is built around a political ideology that consists of being able to adopt various personae in order to manipulate your fellow neighbors and to come out on top, a character that constantly disregards the most tactful way to go about a mission, even at the request of the client and will always follow the way he personally thinks is best, and so on and so forth.

 

On the other hand, we have a character with dominant Fe in Josephine. She is someone who completely understands and uses Fe in her interactions with others that even Cullen says he can't understand or agree with her way of doing things. This is because Cullen follows his own inner feelings, Fi, to decide what his own feelings, morals, and mood are about things. In every example I've given in the above paragraph, Josephine does the exact opposite. Even though she may agree that the Chantry and Roderick are holding the Inquisition back, she's able to use Fe to realize that they will be a problem if not dealt with adequately and tactfully, and she brings up the same concerns during the Wicked Eyes and Wicked Hearts quest. With that said, Cullen is NOT an ESFJ, ISFJ, or any type of Fe user. He doesn't use it, he hates using it, and he completely ignores it. His feeling function is Fi - end of story.

 

So now that we know what he's not, what exactly is he? As I've said before I get both ISTJ and ISFP from him, but I myself am not 100% sure of what he is. I can see ISTJ because Si seems like a crucial part of his character. He is constantly comparing the state of the present to the state of the past, using his experience in the Circle Tower to guide him into being more vigilant as a Templar from DAO to DA2, and using Meredith's abuse of lyrium into giving up lyrium himself. I can also see Se since a lot of his war table mission solutions go for the most straightforward path with absolutely no thought to the future and just taking things at face value. He also seems to be more Se in DAI than in the previous DAs. His next functions are Fi-Te which are constants for him, and his weakest functions are either Ne if ISTJ or Ni if ISFP which I can't recall him using too much. In fact, the only time I've seen him use his weakest function is Ni, when tracking Wilmod in DAII, though that could also be because of Si depending on how well he knew Wilmod. Overall, I'm leaning towards ISFP since his feeling function is more in the forefront and he comes across as much more softer than Cassandra, who is definitely ISTJ, though his Si seems to be very well developed and he seems much blunter in DAI than the previous DAs which could mean higher Te.

 

For Solas, I typed him as INFJ because I thought that balanced his feeling and thinking function well, though as I said, his Ti is definitely his strongest function so INTP makes more sense than INFJ. Thinking about it, he also has terrible Ni, as someone with higher Ni would be able to connect the dots and figure that what he did wasn't the smartest thing to do.

[Arahnea]

Okay, so I've been thinking... A lot of people seem to think ( myself included) that Solas is either INTJ or INTP but we only know him as Solas, after all the stuff he has done. Could it be possible that Solas is in fact an ENTJ and that his current INTP-like behavior are actually his shadow functions taking over because of all the stuff that happened after he woke up from his slumber?

 

I can imagine that the whole waking up after many years and seeing how the world has gone to **** because of your actions would change the way someone looks at himself.

 

Not too much evidence to back up but small glimps when Solas' speaks about himself when he was younger. He sounded more extraverted then..

The things he might have done as Fen'Harel are totally up an ENTJ's alley 

[Cerulione]

I don' know much about this but I think this description fits for Cullen :

 

http://www.16persona...sfj-personality

 

Well, the description's really Cullen IMO...

[Cosmia]

OP has been updated! Shout-out to everyone for their fascinating character analyses.

[Addai]

Ugh... This was a painful thread to read at work. So many stereotypes and misunderstandings just being tossed about! I had so much to say but I don't wanna spend a lot of time going over every single poster's arguments about the characters, so I'm just gonna focus on Cullen and Solas. Now, I believe that before people start tossing out analyses on characters using the MBTI, they should probably do a little research and understand how the system works.

The forum is as good a place as any to learn, and it all leads to discussion of the characters so in my book it's all good.

For Solas, I typed him as INFJ because I thought that balanced his feeling and thinking function well, though as I said, his Ti is definitely his strongest function so INTP makes more sense than INFJ. Thinking about it, he also has terrible Ni, as someone with higher Ni would be able to connect the dots and figure that what he did wasn't the smartest thing to do.

I think some of that is just maturity. They say when you get older you start to operate more out of the Tertiary (which for Solas would be Introverted Sensing, comparing his experiences to past memories and forming a sense of place in the present, which also fits him to a tee) and in general most people mediate. Not all, of course.

[Carmen_Willow]

INTP's are always seeking new data. They can be perceived as unsure because they are willing to apply new data to a given theory. Perceivers are Forest People not Tree People. They see possibilities They see big pictures, not details. Once they conceive, perceive something in their head, they have little need to bring into reality because for them, it already exists to their satisfaction. INTPs are great in think tanks because they are always coming up with ideas, many of them quite out of the box. Solas could be an INTJ, he's pretty certain of his stuff, but that may be  because all the data he has to this point confirm his present hypothesis about the Fade. Faced with new data, he might change his mind. He would give little thought to physical comfort, hence sleeping in ruins, and he wouldn't care much about his clothes other than that they function well. Form should follow function in the mind of an INTP.  He wouldn't remember things like birthdays or anniversaries unless someone really made an issue of it. His way of showing love and affection is sharing his ideas.

 

INTPs are not necessarily shy - in fact, when sure of their data, they are quite willing to tell you about it.  People never see me as shy or introverted because I can be quite gregarious and don't mind talking to people at all. But I do alone time to recharge and regroup. Hope this helps.

 

Oh, and INTPs can be very blunt and aggressive when their beloved theories and ideas are challenged.

 

I've taken the test three times in my life, once when I was in my twenties and the last time as a woman of a "certain age." My type has never changed over the course of my life.  In other surveys that measure the same sorts of things I also show the same traits. Personality is a pretty stable thing.

[Carmen_Willow]

I can see your argument for T over F, but why I over E?

[MWImexico]

....

So now that we know what he's not, what exactly is he? As I've said before I get both ISTJ and ISFP from him, but I myself am not 100% sure of what he is. I can see ISTJ because Si seems like a crucial part of his character. He is constantly comparing the state of the present to the state of the past, using his experience in the Circle Tower to guide him into being more vigilant as a Templar from DAO to DA2, and using Meredith's abuse of lyrium into giving up lyrium himself. I can also see Se since a lot of his war table mission solutions go for the most straightforward path with absolutely no thought to the future and just taking things at face value. He also seems to be more Se in DAI than in the previous DAs. His next functions are Fi-Te which are constants for him, and his weakest functions are either Ne if ISTJ or Ni if ISFP which I can't recall him using too much. In fact, the only time I've seen him use his weakest function is Ni, when tracking Wilmod in DAII, though that could also be because of Si depending on how well he knew Wilmod. Overall, I'm leaning towards ISFP since his feeling function is more in the forefront and he comes across as much more softer than Cassandra, who is definitely ISTJ, though his Si seems to be very well developed and he seems much blunter in DAI than the previous DAs which could mean higher Te.

....

 

Frankly, I'm not convinced about the ISFP, that would mean that Cullen's dominant function is "Introverted Feeling" and I don't think that this function is what is dominant in his personality. "Introverted Sensing" as dominant seems more accurate to me.

[Blackstork]

Solas is INTP - as i and leadintea mentioned - he have horrible Ni, and he can not be any of INXJ types! 

[Blackstork]

Also i have another claim - Josie is not ENFJ!

I will proof it later. I htink it been deicided by people who do not look into fucntions and assign type just using main letters and some interpretation sites. 

This is not correct. If you check deeper Analysis you will find that Josie is not ENFJ , as she do not have Fi in her shadow! She have Fi in primary.

ENFJ have Fe in primary, and Josie not! Its clear. The weak spots of Josie and Leliana - they are different. Leliana is clear ENFJ , with shadow functions going to surface during DA:I. Josie is some E with Fi in Primary!

Pick that i think for her might be ESFP. 

 

• E – Extraversion preferred to introversion: ESFPs often feel motivated by their interaction with people. They tend to enjoy a wide circle of acquaintances, and they gain energy in social situations (whereas introverts expend energy).^[6]
• S – Sensing preferred to intuition: ESFPs tend to be more concrete than abstract. They focus their attention on the details rather than the big picture, and on immediate realities rather than future possibilities .^[7]
• F – Feeling preferred to thinking: ESFPs tend to value personal considerations above objective criteria. When making decisions, they often give more weight to social implications than to logic.^[8]
• P – Perception preferred to judgment: ESFPs tend to withhold judgment and delay important decisions, preferring to "keep their options open" should circumstances change.^[9]

 

Dominant: Extraverted Sensing (Se)[edit]

Se focuses on the experiences and sensations of the immediate, physical world. With an acute awareness of the present surroundings, it brings relevant facts and details to the forefront and may lead to spontaneous action.[12]

 

Auxiliary: Introverted Feeling (Fi)[edit]

Fi filters information based on interpretations of worth, forming judgments according to criteria that are often intangible. Fi constantly balances an internal set of values such as harmony and authenticity. Attuned to subtle distinctions, Fi innately senses what is believed to be good and what is bad in a situation.[13]

 

Tertiary: Extraverted Thinking (Te)[edit]

Te organizes and schedules ideas and the environment to ensure the efficient, productive pursuit of objectives. Te seeks logical explanations for actions, events, and conclusions, looking for faulty reasoning and lapses in sequence.[14]

 

Inferior: Introverted Intuition (Ni)[edit]

Attracted to symbolic actions or devices, Ni synthesizes seeming paradoxes to create the previously unimagined. These realizations come with a certainty that demands action to fulfill a new vision of the future, solutions that may include complex systems or universal truths.[15]

 

[Hellion Rex]

"The Myers–Briggs Type Indicator (MBTI) assessment is a psychometric questionnaire designed to measure psychological preferences in how people perceive the world and make decisions," (wikipedia). There are 16 'types' total, based on the following dichotomies:

 

Introversion (I) or Extroversion (E)

Intuition (N) or Sensing (S)

Thinking (T) or Feeling (F)

Judging (J) or Perceiving (P)

 

I thought it would be fun to get a discussion going on what Myers-Brigg type each companion and advisor could be! Here's a free test if you're curious about your own.

 

Here's a link with brief descriptions of the different types! 

 

As an aside- this isn't science, and it isn't perfect. But it's fun. So why not?

 

Cassandra: ISTJ, probably!

 

Solas: Some say INTJ, some say INTP, some say INFJ! 

 

Varric: ENTP

 

Josephine: ENFJ

 

Cullen: ISFP, probably.

 

Leliana: ENFJ, probably.

 

Sera: ESFJ

 

Iron Bull: ESTP

 

Blackwall: ISFJ?

 

Cole: INFP

 

Dorian: ENFP

 

Vivienne: ESTJ

 

I'll update this thread once we get some discussion going!

Yes, I totally pegged Cole as the INFP.

 

Just like me.

[Seraphim24]

The descriptions are combinations from what I have read in various sites about the types. Characters that are paired with the types is my interpretation and they are up to debate

 

I see Merrill quite F since she lets her emotions to affect her much. Anders.. well actually I have Awakening Anders in my chart XD I feel like DA2 Anders personality is combination of his and Justice's. I think Justice is ISTJ. Leliana's I'm not sure.. I think she appeared in DAO as ENFP but was that mask of bard or attempt to be redempt herself and act like a goodie? Probaply.

 

I just think that Fenris, Architect and Varric are more thinking types. ISFJ wouldn't fit to Fenris, INTP's type label usually is Architect XD and Varric.. well I'm not as convinced about him but I think the description of ENTP is best.. at least to DA2 Varric.

 

Well see I think you could argue they're all Ts. I was kind of sort of implying that in the end. Plus I think figures like Leliana/Merril were an attempt at creating an F type perhaps.. they seem more distant/intellectually driven to me.. for whatever reason.

 

The fact is though while I was interested in MBTI for awhile I ended up ripping apart the methodology by the end because I was dissatisfied with it..

 

It started with J and P which just never worked and then I and E which I thought was also bunk. I think "having tons of friends and being totally connected socialite" is often the mark of a sublimely shy and distant person. "Introverted" people usually have harmonious and congenial relations, thus they are not afraid of the quiet hours.

 

N was a really interesting concept though so I sat on that.. and same with T. So I can definitely see like Morrigan/Anora/Solas all as kind of INTJ types. Varric/Cullen/Wynne/Most DA characters I just see as kind of like STJ types.

 

The other problem though is like you are either thinking or feeling? That seems off. Plus it has weird things like if aren't intuitive you are a senser! It's like well what if you are just a thinker.. not really either one.. /shrug.

[Blackstork]

Well see I think you could argue they're all Ts. I was kind of sort of implying that in the end. Plus I think figures like Leliana/Merril were an attempt at creating an F type perhaps.. they seem more distant/intellectually driven to me.. for whatever reason.

 

The fact is though while I was interested in MBTI for awhile I ended up ripping apart the methodology by the end because I was dissatisfied with it..

 

It started with J and P which just never worked and then I and E which I thought was also bunk. I think "having tons of friends and being totally connected socialite" is often the mark of a sublimely shy and distant person. "Introverted" people usually have harmonious and congenial relations, thus they are not afraid of the quiet hours.

 

N was a really interesting concept though so I sat on that.. and same with T. So I can definitely see like Morrigan/Anora/Solas all as kind of INTJ types. Varric/Cullen/Wynne/Most DA characters I just see as kind of like STJ types.

 

The other problem though is like you are either thinking or feeling? That seems off. Plus it has weird things like if aren't intuitive you are a senser! It's like well what if you are just a thinker.. not really either one.. /shrug.

You should avoid such perception on MBTI , simply. I think you misinterpret its meaning and misjudging it, from your own subjective perspective.

 

I think that if you read the function meaning, not those confusing words and letters in the name of type, you will get it in more deeper, complete form. The problem same term of "judging" can be perceived and be interpreted by different people in different ways. So, to avoid subjective interpretation, just better to check what those things REALLY mean in their scientific, not popular-sociologic-interpritations form.

 

There is certain meaning for 8 function, while meaning of names and letters is quite vague, esp. if its perceived  by different subjects differently.

Everyone feel, everyone think, Even thinkers have some Feeling function in their primary. The question what it does and when it becomes active.

Stop seeing MBTI is as horoscope or letter shuffling lottery.

 

Solas, by whole sense and reason, if you know what functions and real meaning of MBTI means (if you dont, i suggest  you to check it first before forming assuptions with MBTI) you can never assign INTJ for Solas, because its transparent, obvious that he does not have any drop of NI. Ni is his weak spot actually, Ni is his shadow, meanwhile its obvious that he uses his Ne alot. 

 

@Panda i really request to recheck and restate Josie as ESFP. She is clear evident shot ESFP and she have alot of uncommon things with ENFJ. She is very different to ENFJ , actually. Especially if you dig the serious function analysis. Leliana is ENFJ, and Josie is SeFi at its finest!

[FiveThreeTen]

Yes, I totally pegged Cole as the INFP.

 

Just like me.

I'm usually very skeptical about these psycho socio thingies that try to tell you what you are and how you behave but I did saw a lot of Cole in me and I'm an INFP according to some tests (which I find odd, hence my waryness regarding those tests).

 

For Solas, I would say INTP over INTJ.

[Panda]

@Panda i really request to recheck and restate Josie as ESFP. She is clear evident shot ESFP and she have alot of uncommon things with ENFJ. She is very different to ENFJ , actually. Especially if you dig the serious function analysis. Leliana is ENFJ, and Josie is SeFi at its finest!

 

I haven't commented anything to Josie though . I agree that she fits with ESFP from what I have seen which isn't that much since I haven't played DAI yet ^^