Aller au contenu

Photo

Your preconceptions of characters Vs what they actually turned out to be like


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
43 réponses à ce sujet

#26
duckley

duckley
  • Members
  • 1 857 messages

Here is my take

  • Cass - I wasn't expecting to like Cass, but I do
  • Dorian is fine - I wasn't expecting to like him - but I do.
  • Solas - neutral before, neutral after - but given the end, next play through will pay a bit more attention.,
  • Iron Bull - wasn't interested in him  and nothing has changed. 
  • Cole - thought I would hate him, but I love his character.
  • Sera - thought I would love her - not so much - so annoying!
  • Vivienne - didn't care and still don't
  • Blackwell - thought I would like him lots - but not at all.
  • Varric - well loved him then and love him now.
  • Cullen - Best. Romance. Ever,
  • Leliana - found her annoying before, but now I find her annoying and bitter.
  • Josephine - thought she might be interesting but I really find her boring and silly. 

  • Adribr91 aime ceci

#27
keepthebeat929

keepthebeat929
  • Members
  • 20 messages

I was pleasantly surprised by how relatable Cassandra was.  She's very hard on herself, as am I, and the Swords and Shields scene was priceless. :)

 

I'm going to catch some heat for this, but I thought Solas was a complete ******.  At the start of the game, he's very welcoming and pleasant, but from Haven on he basically takes digs at you at every turn if you don't agree with him that the world revolves around all things elven.  I could do with never seeing him again.



#28
SleepyBird

SleepyBird
  • Members
  • 206 messages

 

And yeah I also thought Vivienne would be more important to the plot, I was kind of disappointed with how underused she was used, she didn't really feel like part of the group and didn't go through much character development. 

I was surprised how ... irrelevant she seemed after how prominent she was in the marketing campaign. I like her, her voice actress is amazing, but in the end it just seemed like she didn't really bring anything important to the story or have as deep or meaningful character moments as the others do. (Yes I did the snowy Wyvern heart quest, it's good, just shorter and less impactful as any of the other character quests, IMO)



#29
The Oracle

The Oracle
  • Members
  • 606 messages

I, like many above, tried to avoid too much spoilering(my word for it) ahead of launch, especially with characters.

 

Cass - I was initially curious just to see if she would be similar to her previous representations. Overall I'm very impressed with her character. Love her dialogue, her indecision, her strength and her weaknesses. She's just such a well rounded and relatable (wish spellcheck would stop making me question my grasp of the English language) character, superbly written and nuanced.

 

Iron Bull - Not gonna lie, I was kinda hoping for more of a Sten. Bloody loved Sten from DA:O and I wanted to see that kind of stoic but sarky character make a return. IB though is still good, if not a bit one dimensional (especially if you side with the Qun in...well...you know the quest). Otherwise he has the occasional good line or observation.

 

Blackwall: Again, had a stupid hope that we'd maybe get a Duncan style character (Oh geez, sad confession time but I had a complete character crush on Duncan. That voice, that beard...all gentlemanly and such...*sigh*) In the end he was quite boring. I mean, we all know later why he's reserved but even after that and all the party banter I still found him boring. Found his romance to be bland too, which was sad.

 

Sera: Had no idea what she was going to be like going in. She's a strange mixture of funny but incredibly annoying and as stubborn as hell. She has such little character development which in a way makes sense but also makes her so frustrating. There should be a "head slap" option for her, ala NCIS Gibbs style.

 

Vivienne - First time through and I barely spoke to her. Didn't even complete her character quest with the Wyvern heart. Ooops. She's just far too much work with little gain, especially when the other two mages are so great.

 

Dorian - Like Vivienne I had no idea what he was going to be like going in and I totally love him (who doesn't though?) Just wanna hug him  and then give him a smack on the backside and a cheeky wink. Make this a thing Bioware!!!

 

Varric - Varric is well, Varric. He's awesome. Enough said.

 

Cole - Cole broke my heart in the books and then had the good grace to help put it back together in this game. He's just so...so...hugable. Why isn't this an option? I just want to feed him up and smoosh his smooshy little face. When folk are mean to him it makes me want to go on a blood-soaked rampage. 

 

Solas - Had no idea what he'd be like but I was a bit surprised by the concept art. Usually Bioware tries to make their Elf men very hot but he looked slightly like a drawing with all the proportions gone wrong. And then in game, woosh. Quiet, interesting, passionate and intriguing. Sometimes a bit of snark, sometimes unexpectedly kind and other times furious. I just loved his character and his interactions with others. He's a constant party member because he has the most interesting things to say. Also, his romance was equal parts wonderful and devastating. There had better be a DLC with Solas or Bioware will find a Nug head under their covers one day.

 

Cullen - Boy, he's had a journey and a half. He's a much more likeable character now and far more grown up in this, which I'm pleased with. I'm glad they gave a good amount of dialogue with him and his romance is a wonderful pile of fluffy, purring kittens after the heart-break of Solas.

 

Josie - Meh, she's nice, very sweet but a bit...well...meh. I'd have liked to see a bit more character from her and a few more emotions than, friendly, flustered and fretting.

 

Lelianna - Boy has she gone brittle. Complete character 360 and it made me sad to see her so different to what she once was. Also, hadn't figured out that she could harden/unharden and at the end of the game I was worried she would snap and slit everyone's throats during the night. I'm going to see her unhardened in my next playthrough and see what she's like then.


  • Adribr91 aime ceci

#30
Guest_Raga_*

Guest_Raga_*
  • Guests

I thought I would thoroughly detest Vivienne.  I ended up liking her if not trusting her.

I was never too excited about Iron Bull's physical appearance (cow horns, seriously? and is he wearing an inflatable muscle suit?) but I expected him to be moderately interesting.  Instead he ended up being Mr. Bland Pants.

Cassandra seemed likely to be boring, but I ended up liking her quite a bit.

 

The others I was neutral about so nothing about them really surprised me. 



#31
Lord_Caledore

Lord_Caledore
  • Members
  • 287 messages

I was pleasantly surprised by Bull. I thought he'd be a more shallow character, but he had some depth to him I appreciated. He wasn't my favorite character by any means, but I liked him and I hadn't expected to.

 

I expected to dislike Cole, and while he was my least favorite companion (not counting Sera, who I didn't recruit), I grew to like him a lot more than I thought I would have.

 

Leliana certainly broke my expectations towards the end.

Spoiler



#32
sH0tgUn jUliA

sH0tgUn jUliA
  • Members
  • 16 812 messages

Cassandra - I thought I would hate her, but I ended up loving her. I want to see her as the Divine. I take her everywhere.

Blackwall - I thought I would like him, but it turned out that I really don't. I spoke to him a couple of times, and it was a real turn off.

Cullen - I thought I would dislike him, but it turned out that I really like him. Even though I've sided with the mages, I'm pursuing a romance.

Varric - Well, once I got Vivienne in the party, I haven't used Varric much anymore. He doesn't fit. I need two mages. He's kind of an assh*le. He's Hawke's friend. I agree with Cassandra. He shouldn't have held back.

Solas - Hello, rift mage? Solas is a fascinating character. I'm not huge on all things elven, but he does have interesting things.

Vivienne - She gets on my nerves, but then I don't want to be surrounded by "yes men and women." Just don't take it too far, Viv. I can't seem to find her in the castle. But I need her in the party.

Leiliana - Well, she's Leiliana. Let's see what we have.

Sera - she's got a lot to say about stuff. Just out for people stuck in the middle of things. She's never in the party because she doesn't fit.

Cole - Just got Cole. He seems to be very interesting. Cassandra doesn't like him. We'll leave him at the keep.

Dorian - Nice mage. An alternative for when I get tired of Viv's banter with Solas.


  • Adribr91 aime ceci

#33
Celtic Latino

Celtic Latino
  • Members
  • 1 347 messages
I honestly thought Iron Bull would be Inquisition's Black Whirlwind or Zaeed, tough, brutal and amoral. Very surprised when it turns out how he's a big papa bear and incredibly kind/caring. In a blunt, Vega, mercenary-Qun sort of way.

Blackwall I thought would be the next Duncan, was pretty surprised that hes more dour and vulgar than initially thought.

Vivienne seemed like she'd have far more plot relevance given her marketing and advertising, but she actually seemed one of the least relevant characters. I also thought shed be far more condescending and arrogant, though it turns out she's just classy and poised.

Cassandra was the major shocker. I thought shed be a raging alpha woman. She's actually very vulnerable and wears her emotions a lot. Much more likable than I thought shed be.

Dorian didn't surprise me as he looks vain and full of himself (yet also very insecure). He's actually more likable than I thought though, especially when you get on his good side. (Romanced him twice, a rarity in my BW runs).

Sera I knew would be bratty but I didn't think she'd actually dislike her own race (she claims she's more people-people but you can't deny that she has some prejudice towards her own kind). Also didn't think she would talk so strangely. I can understand her but I can see how shed get irritating quick.

Honestly thought Solas would be nicer than he is. He's got his moments but he's incredibly surly, full of his own opinions and pompous at times. Though if the ending is any indicator I can see why he's like that, having been around for that long.

Varric still remained Varric though I'm very surprised dwarven PCs have next to nothing in terms of reactivity with him. Still, he's the Garrus of Dragon Age, someone you're supposed to like because he has little that's oppositional or glaringly unlikable about him.

Cole's the only one who didn't surprise me. Didn't like him before the game, still don't like him.

#34
rpgfan321

rpgfan321
  • Members
  • 1 311 messages

I went into the game thinking Blackwall is gonna be one those regular soldier characters. I would like him, but he was sitting on the lower scale. 

 

But after his personal quest, I definitely changed my mind about him and what he said before the quest happened. He surprised me and I liked it. 

 

I really like all the characters for DAI. Well, I never really hate a character in video games (other mediums are another story), but not all of them quite reach the status of "love." But DAI managed it this time for me. 



#35
Chernaya

Chernaya
  • Members
  • 5 136 messages

My intuition seemed mostly correct, actually. 

 

I'll always love Varric, but I have to admit aside from a few moments I didn't feel like he shined much in this game.

 

I was quite relieved Iron Bull wasn't just 'the muscle' and was actually a very intelligent and witty person. Yes, he's hedonistic as I expected from the pre-launch info on him, but he's more than just the 'frat-boy' which was refreshing, and he was really actually quite kindhearted. I liked that his lifestyle was kinda hypocritical in a way, but he didn't care. 

 

I didn't know what to expect of Cole, but ultimately found his character really interesting, and his insight and banter amusing. I do better understand now why some people have a protective instinct for that character, though. His personal quest was what really locked in my liking of Cole.

 

I was really intent on romancing Sera, but sadly, although I still adore her character, she ended up feeling like a younger sibling. Just can't get the LI feel for her, though I love her to bits. I can understand how some find her annoying, but when a good portion of my team has a stick up the butt at times, I find Sera to be a great escape.



#36
d-boy15

d-boy15
  • Members
  • 1 642 messages

I was pleasantly surprised by Bull. I thought he'd be a more shallow character, but he had some depth to him I appreciated. He wasn't my favorite character by any means, but I liked him and I hadn't expected to.

I expected to dislike Cole, and while he was my least favorite companion (not counting Sera, who I didn't recruit), I grew to like him a lot more than I thought I would have.

Leliana certainly broke my expectations towards the end.

Spoiler


You know that there are two version of her right?

One hot ruthless mistress and Cute sister who technically Josie 2.0

#37
Basement Cat

Basement Cat
  • Members
  • 9 642 messages

A lot of people have pointed how Vivienne turned out not to be as relevant to the plot as the advertising campaign suggested, but I think that's actually brilliant. It's Vivienne talking in those ads. The lady has an over inflated sense of her own importance and she can talk big, but she's really a minor player. One could almost call her irrelevant. ;)


  • Aravasia aime ceci

#38
Efvie

Efvie
  • Members
  • 510 messages

I, too, stayed away from the hype. I like to get things firsthand.

 

So, you may imagine my surprise when the only thing I’d seen of Sera was the clip where she walks slowly in a field, hand brushing the plants. Elfy elf, innit?

 

I adore Sera.

 

All in all, every character was a bit deeper than I had anticipated, but especially Solas and Cass. I went everywhere with those three, with frequent quick visits by the rest of the cast. Especially Cole, such a sweet boy. And Varric, obviously—I thought his somberness was very well realized.

 

Cullen was kind of surprising, too. I could not understand why people were excited about him because at least in my DA:O and DA2 he’d been an utter d|(|<. In this one, he was quite pleasant.

 

Blackwall was exactly as boring as I expected.

 

The biggest surprise after Sera? Leliana. I thought I had her unhardened in the Keep, but apparently not, and whoa… This new playthrough with a romanced, unhardened Leliana already seems much better. I swear she even looks different. Less gaunt.



#39
BronzTrooper

BronzTrooper
  • Members
  • 5 014 messages

Blackwall:  I was expecting him to be more of the grizzled veteran-type Warden, but he surprised me.  A few times, actually.

 

Cassandra: I wasn't really expecting to like her as much I do, especially after seeing the scene with Varric's book.  I was also expecting her to be pro-Templar, but she actually seems to be more sympathetic towards mages than I would've thought.

 

Cole:  Honestly, I wasn't sure what to expect with him, but he's actually my second-favorite character in DA:I (first being IB).

 

Cullen:  I wasn't expecting him to be as fleshed out as he turned out to be in DA:I.  He also seems to have calmed down about mages after DA2.

 

Dorian:  I wasn't expecting him to be as dynamic and hilarious as he was.

 

Iron Bull:  I was expecting him to be a bit of a meathead, kind of like James Vega in ME3, but he was actually more thoughtful and intelligent than I would've thought.  I also wasn't expecting him to hook up with Dorian.

 

Josephine:  I was expecting her to be a bit on the naive side, but she turned out to be pretty mature and practical when she needed to be.

 

Leliana:  I was expecting her to be like Liara in ME3, but she actually seemed.... darker and less forgiving.  She was also a lot more cynical than I expected, yet still very idealistic.

 

Sera:  I was expecting to really like her, but her attitude towards anything 'different', 'weird', or 'elfy' really annoyed me.  She seemed unwilling to adapt and wanted everything to stay the same mostly so that she could go back to having her 'fun'.  She turned out to be my least favorite character in DA:I.

 

Solas:  I was expecting him to be reserved and kind of nerdy, but he really surprised me.  And that's not even including the post-credits scene.

 

Varric:  He seemed.... different than he was in DA2.  He was irritable at times depending on the subject (Kirkwall's recovery comes to mind) and a bit confrontational.  However, he was also surprisingly like a bigger brother to Cole and we also got to meet the actual Bianca, so those are both big bonuses.

 

Vivienne:  I thought that I wouldn't like her much, but I found myself understanding her reasons for her views, even if she was kind of annoying with her "this is why magic is dangerous" and "mages who don't receive 'proper' Circle training are weak and incompetent" comments.  At the very least, I like her as a character, but not as a person.

 

Hawke:

Spoiler



#40
karushna5

karushna5
  • Members
  • 1 620 messages

A lot of people have pointed how Vivienne turned out not to be as relevant to the plot as the advertising campaign suggested, but I think that's actually brilliant. It's Vivienne talking in those ads. The lady has an over inflated sense of her own importance and she can talk big, but she's really a minor player. One could almost call her irrelevant. ;)

 

Except, you know, default divine. My fiance meant it to be Cassandra, argued for Cassandra, but didn't do the war table mission and it became Vivienne.



#41
Aravasia

Aravasia
  • Members
  • 224 messages

Vivienne: met my expectations, I did not think I would like her, and in my first playthrough, well, she full on hated me until I managed to get her into an uncaring neutral. I can still appreciate her character, however. In this instance, I miss the DA2 rivalry system, where I really would have loved to be rivals with Vivienne, while still remaining amicable.

 

Varric: As much as I loved him in DA2 -and he was my favorite character in that game- in DAI I just found him to be rather..bland. I knew that he would never be as close with the Inquisitor as he had been with Hawke, and that he would be more grim. But his personality just came across as more stale than bitter, which I think I would  have actually preferred, because at least it's something. I still love Varric, of course, but had I only known him for this game, I likely would not have connected much. 

 

Dorian: I underestimated my love for this character pre-game, he easily became one of my favorite characters in the series. I laugh at nearly everything he says, and I loved the emotional moments he had in his personal quest, the voice acting was wonderful. 

 

Iron Bull: I thought I would end up liking him much more than I did. Not that I disliked him or anything, I just never quite connected. I feel as though many of our conversations, especially at the beginning, are too formal, rather than friendly. 

 

Leliana: Definitely surprised me the most. She was one of my favorite characters in DAO, and the entire game I just felt so incredibly..sad for her. Of course, I made the mistake of accidentally hardening her at the beginning, and playing through her personal quest was, surprisingly, the saddest moment in the game for me (given, I didn't have a Warden Alistair or Loghain import, so it didn't have much to compete with.) But, I wouldn't actually care if she brutally murdered people, while still remaining perfectly happy, (that is what the majority of our companions do, after all) but you can just tell how incredibly miserable she is inside, and it broke my heart. 

 

Sera: What a surprise for me. I didn't think I would like her at all, she came across as having a very black and white view of the world in the early previews, and well, she does. Along with not liking elves or mages (I was an elf mage by the way.) She's also extremely immature and I really don't agree with her about anything, even remotely. And yet.. I just love her. I have no idea what it is, maybe it's because I tend not to really take her seriously, but I think she's probably my favorite female companion in Inquisition. She isn't the type I'd have a heart-to-heart with, but I loved spending time with her. 

 

Cole: I knew I would love Cole from the start, and he lived up to all of my expectations. I didn't like the way he seemed to see the world in black and white at first, kind of like Sera,"bad things should happen to bad people," but I really love the way this changes when you take the human path. Before reaching that quest, I was almost certain I would choose him as a spirit instead, but having seen both versions, I completely prefer human. Perhaps it's because as a human, he has flaws, and flaws are what makes me love these characters. 

 

Blackwall: I was the least interested in him pre-release, and that remained the same. Something about him is just so dull, even with his personal quest, which you'd think would make him interesting. I really want to give him a try, and I do like him slightly more on my second playthrough (although he still calls me a criminal after getting him out of jail, yeah thanks.) Like Varric says, he's just like Sebastian. He's my least favorite character, not because I dislike him in the slightest, he just doesn't add anything to the story. 

 

Solas: I knew I would love and I did. Being open-minded and having a 'shades of grey' type of perception are traits I love in both people and characters. But wow, was he unexpected. I thought he would be shy and socially awkward, having lived away from society. But instead, he's highly confident and clearly socially skilled, he's even rather an elitist at times, and condescending when you don't agree with him, which makes since once you know the reveal, but definitely unexpected. Most of all, he's just really unknown, you can tell that his polite persona certainly doesn't match up to the malicious smirks he gives you off-screen, along with his reputation, which is likely at least part-true. He's the mysterious Morrigan-like character that I've been craving, but that he is was completely unexpected. 



#42
Bugsie

Bugsie
  • Members
  • 3 609 messages
I think my expectations of Iron Bull were very high, and I am a little disappointed in what I ended up getting. I like him well enough though, just a little blander than I thought.

Viv, I feel most disappointed by. Thought I would love her, but I dont. I don't detest her, just feel a bit meh about her.

I thought I wouldn't be at all interested in Blackwall, but I've been surprised how much I like him, his story arc and the romance.

#43
SleepyBird

SleepyBird
  • Members
  • 206 messages
Seems like almost everyone here was surprised by Iron Bull, although I think it's really interesting that we're split on whether he's better or worse. Looks like lots of us thought he was going to be a big dumb frat-boy brute and are pleasantly surprised to find him to be intelligent and feeling. On the other hand, it also seems like a lot of people were expecting Sten 2.0 (now with dick jokes!), and are very disappointed to see him doubt the Qun and have emotions.

I just think it's interesting to see how wrong we all were about him for both good and ill based on how he was presented in the lead up to the game.

#44
Adribr91

Adribr91
  • Members
  • 8 messages

Well, I just completed my first gameplay and it was like:

 

Cassandra: she was ok to me pre-game with her badassness and distant demeanor. Ended up becoming the LI for my first inquisitor cause, 1- she was a companion and 2- way more endearing than I thought. The poetry scene got me amused.

 

Vivienne: as expected, she was just the ice-queen momma I expected her to be. Loved her both now and before. Didn't agree with her on many things, but she and my inquisitor treated each other with some degree of genuine care.

 

Sera: such as she is, lunatic, immature, and unintelligent to the point of stupidity. If she was meant to be a jovial, refreshing character from the more controlled, older ones - in my opinion - they overdone it. I hardly ever take her. The only moment i enjoyed her presence was at the endgame party. 

 

Cole: left me intrigued in assunder, loved him on this one. If one of the companions shall make to DA4, both for plot and personal reasons, I believe and hope he's one of the strongest candidates. 

 

Iron Bull: his cool/merry nature impressed me. Bull ended up becoming a bro, even if he had some awkward moments (like after killing the first dragon). I have to say that the mayhen has been worth.

 

Solas: have to take him more with me in the next playthrough. For now I can only say that he's more sympathetic than I though. That post credits scene, though :blink:

 

Thom (A.K.A. Blackwall): may take more time to know him. He was as unninteresting as previously believed. Happily, his condition made vivienne considerations about the wardens to feel less offensive.

 

Varric: his plot and his personality lost a bit of it's shine, specially the weak quest about Bianca. He's still one of my favorite companions, lightening the mood and delivering a refreshing moment way better than Sera.

 

Dorian: had great expectations for him before the game release. His plot is well-written and did not aproach the character as overly flamboyant or reduced him to his sexuality as many other authors have been doing. Will have to create an inquisitor to romance him. 

 

Leliana and Morrigan: Renewed my love for the red - although she could be humming a song at the rookery sometimes. I was afraid of indicating her for the post of Divine, but, accordingly to Morringan, she  has been a female version of pope Francisco. Morrigan, as much as I loved to hate her in DA:O, also won my heart this round. She's lovelly  and more appealing than her flanderized "wicked witch" self of the first game. Perhaps Kieram may become a companion in future installments?

 

Cullen: another one i'll to create an inquisitor to romance. I haven't interacted with him much, but he seems more conscious and better suited to make decisions than in previous games. A fine commander and a nice guy.

 

Josephine: she feels more distant than I thought she would be. That said, I have no problem recognising her importance for the inquisition (I study International Relations myself) neither with her softer, more disneylike romance. In fact, she almost reaches the manga/anime levels of clumsiness to understand that the inquisitor is interested in her, which I find quite funny.

 

Thanks to the thread creator, btw.