I'm curious if you'll humor me for the sake of argument for a moment; let's say, hypothetically, Bioware did make the proposed DLC this thread is asking for with the Warden as a protagonist. If they did that - if - would you accept that was what they wanted to do and the story they wanted to tell, or would you denounce it as Bioware caving to the fans?
Honestly, I don't believe this thread has the power to influence Bioware's decision. I personally think Bioware does still have a story to tell with the Warden. I could well be wrong. And honestly I won't be bothered if they don't make the DLC. But if they do, I'll pay money for it.
No, of course I will not consider it caving to the fans. I will think of it as: they thought about a good story to tell, thought about bringing back the warden and managed to fit the warden into the current state of things. I will always think of it as their own decision which fits their narrative.
Im in no way against bringing the warden back. Im simply thinking that it is impossible in a current state and will be much more trouble than it is worth. Of course Bioware may surprise me and create an excellent DLC featuring the warden, and i would gladly pay for it if that ever happened.