Sera - Poorly done IMO, Refuses to learn or change no matter what. I don't recruit her.
Vivienne - power hungry snob but, at least she has reasons for being that way beyond "everything is stupid."
Solas - I respect him, don't like him but he does have reasons and, he is well educated.
Cassandra - not bad but she hides who she really is, I don't care for that.
Josephine - could be a playful Isabella (minus the raider stuff) but puts on the aire of nobility. Useful but it comes off as an act.
Cullen - honest, real, I like him
Varric - well we all know Varric has his faults and can never tell the same exact story twice, he's a habitual liar but, he does try and, does see what he is.
Blackwall - I like him but, I'd like him better if we simply rescued him form the noose as Tom Ranier.
Cole - I like him left as a spirit, he has a different way of seeing the world and, it doesn't fit making him more human.
Iron Bull - I like the brute, he's got some depth to him, all be that a bit kinky, he has a big heart if you let him show it.
Dorian - intelligent, has a lot of insecurities but, uses snark and humor to cover them, and other emotions. Also prone to drinking himself to oblivion. Not too bad but, he needs a counselor.
Lilieanna - Good spymaster if you soften her. Death happy ruthless b***h if you don't.