One of the problems of being invested in something (I understand this) is you see the faults, even the small ones.
Folk who are less invested think it's all great because to them it is.
I can't tell the difference between a great wine and an ok wine - it tastes nice and if I drink enough I fall over.
That's how games are for most people.
And those folk are the majority - they buy the games.
How can DAI be both GOTY and have issues?
Because most 'normal players' think it's terrific, and it is.
But the invested ones see where it could be better and get angry when those concerns are unaddressed.
I can see where DAI could have gone further.
It does not disappoint me, I accept it and understand it and I enjoy a great game for what it is.
I do feel the Frostbite 3 implementation was (let's not use blame) responsible for many systems being reworked
and not all of them are back to the standards of the Eclipse engine (many others surpass the prior engine).
For that reason, in DLC and DA4 I think we will continue to see forward motion in good way
and there is no reason to be disheartened.