Qunari, Dragons blood, and Ogres.
#1
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 03:11
#2
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 04:08
If the qunari are created by mutation with dragon's blood, one must wonder why their women are not larger, bigger, stronger and more aggressive than the males.
#3
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 04:08
I still am saying that Qunaris are just original 'Dragonborns' that is all ![]()
#4
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 04:31
If the idea of people creating Kossith is true, the Kossith would have had to exist long enough to (well) exist, reproduce, rebel against their creators (maybe), leave Thedas, create an entire community and way of thinking outside Thedas, return once to Korcari Wilds 1400 years ago (also a long way from their supposed creators as you suggest, basically the opposite area of Tevinter), not return again until the Qun has been established only to try and take over large areas of Thedas...
... all to not be written about once in Ancient Tevinter?
Humans came from outside Thedas, so Kossith did too. Qunari is just the name of beings that follow the Qun (right?) it jsut so happens that majority are what used to be called Kossith. I stands to reason that if Kossith or Dragon experiment version of them did exists, it was done outside of Thedas....
..
In my thinking anyway.
#5
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 04:57
You are making the assumption there that humans are involved when there is really no indication of such. From Iron Bull's dialog, it would appear more likely that it was the Kossith, which look nothing like the Qunari we know, that did the experiments upon themselves. My guess is they may have had tried to make their slave or poor more useful and compliant. Something like a slave revolt probably brought them to our part of the world.
#6
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 05:02
If the idea of people creating Kossith is true, the Kossith would have had to exist long enough to (well) exist, reproduce, rebel against their creators (maybe), leave Thedas, create an entire community and way of thinking outside Thedas, return once to Korcari Wilds 1400 years ago (also a long way from their supposed creators as you suggest, basically the opposite area of Tevinter), not return again until the Qun has been established only to try and take over large areas of Thedas...
... all to not be written about once in Ancient Tevinter?
Humans came from outside Thedas, so Kossith did too. Qunari is just the name of beings that follow the Qun (right?) it jsut so happens that majority are what used to be called Kossith. I stands to reason that if Kossith or Dragon experiment version of them did exists, it was done outside of Thedas....
..
In my thinking anyway.
1. Arlathan fell before humans were an issue.
2.Elve or more of the case there gods use to make artificial animals.
"Ghilan'nain kept herself apart from the People. She used her power to create animals none had ever seen. The skies teemed with her monsters, the land with her beasts. Andruil hunted them all, and after a year of killing, approached Ghilan'nain with an offer: the gods would share their power with Ghilan'nain, but only if she destroyed her creations, for they were too untamed to remain among the People. Ghilan'nain agreed and asked for three days to undo what she had made.
On the first day she struck down the monsters of the air, except those she presented to Andruil as a gift.
On the second day she drowned the giants of the sea, except those in deep waters, for they were too well-wrought, and pride stopped her hand.
On the third day she killed the beasts of the land, except the halla, whose grace she loved above all else.
This is how Ghilan'nain was made youngest of the gods.
-- story of the elven god Ghilan'nain, author unknown"
http://dragonage.wik..._of_Ghilan'nain
#7
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 05:11
couple things:
- Iron Bull I think says something along the lines of [the kossuth] probably didn't look anything like what qunari do
- cassandra mention's dragon hunters who used dragon's blood growing scales, horns and becoming violent.
- Iron Bull's whole reveal about the Qunari reverence for dragons
seems pretty clear that the Qunari are related to dragons either through forced mutation or something else
#8
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 05:27
couple things:
seems pretty clear that the Qunari are related to dragons either through forced mutation or something else
- Iron Bull I think says something along the lines of [the kossuth] probably didn't look anything like what qunari do
- cassandra mention's dragon hunters who used dragon's blood growing scales, horns and becoming violent.
- Iron Bull's whole reveal about the Qunari reverence for dragons
There's also Cory and Kieran's dialogue with regards to the qunari Inquisitor.
#9
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 05:56
It could be that the early Qunari that were corrupted could have been bigger than modern ones, closer to the dragons and all that.
#10
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 06:38
You are making the assumption there that humans are involved when there is really no indication of such. From Iron Bull's dialog, it would appear more likely that it was the Kossith, which look nothing like the Qunari we know, that did the experiments upon themselves. My guess is they may have had tried to make their slave or poor more useful and compliant. Something like a slave revolt probably brought them to our part of the world.
#11
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 06:42
If the idea of people creating Kossith is true, the Kossith would have had to exist long enough to (well) exist, reproduce, rebel against their creators (maybe), leave Thedas, create an entire community and way of thinking outside Thedas, return once to Korcari Wilds 1400 years ago (also a long way from their supposed creators as you suggest, basically the opposite area of Tevinter), not return again until the Qun has been established only to try and take over large areas of Thedas...
... all to not be written about once in Ancient Tevinter?
Humans came from outside Thedas, so Kossith did too. Qunari is just the name of beings that follow the Qun (right?) it jsut so happens that majority are what used to be called Kossith. I stands to reason that if Kossith or Dragon experiment version of them did exists, it was done outside of Thedas....
..
In my thinking anyway.
#12
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 06:43
It could be that the early Qunari that were corrupted could have been bigger than modern ones, closer to the dragons and all that.
...i never considered that the earlier ones might have simply been bigger!
I really hope it's not that simple.
#13
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 07:07
...i never considered that the earlier ones might have simply been bigger!
I really hope it's not that simple.
Well, it was my first thought on the subject. If they did introduce hybrid dragon/Qunari in the beginning then I would suspect that they were much bigger in the past. Each subsequent generation would have "watered down" the dragon blood and probably resulted in smaller descendants.
#14
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 07:29
Regarding the time-scale we can safely assume that the ancient magisters didn't have anything to do with qunari creation and Corypheus words shoudln't be taken that he means that their creation was a mistake but at what he simply states. The Qunari aren't a species. They are a culture. A culture composed of many different people from many different backgrounds is something completly opposite than the tievintian culture, where some families can trace their lineage back a thousand years.
The qunari claim that they arrived on Par-Vollen from another contintent accross the sea and that they lost contact with their homeland. Although the Ben-Hassrath might simply have invented this story I don't see a reason culture-wise to lock the knowledge of their creation away unless it would reveal that they were a small minority on their home continent and had to evacute to Par-Vollen because they were slaughtered by those who wouldn't follow the Qun or weren't dragon-cross-breeds.
But so far everything we learned about them has been Ben-Hassrath filtered.... so how much of this is the truth? So far they have shown to be extremly willing to everything that would grant them an advantage.
#15
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 07:36
Well it could be that a small group of magisters,like the ones who entered the black/golden city,created theQunari in secret, to be their personal slaves.Then after they created them the whole enter-the-fade-and-become-darkspawn thing happened. Then the rest of tevinter would have no idea where the Kossith came from.
From the way Bull talks about it, it sounds more like the Kossith were the original race, and that the Qunari were a result of them mixing with something (maybe dragons, maybe something else) - I suppose that mixing could have been Tevinter-driven, but it could just as easily have been elf-driven or driven by the Kossith themselves (that's what it sounded like based on that dialogue, although admittedly it was very vague).
I came away from it with the notion that it sounds like the Qunari came to human lands after they'd split from the Kossith, but I suppose we don't know yet one was or the other.
#16
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 08:56
Well, it was my first thought on the subject. If they did introduce hybrid dragon/Qunari in the beginning then I would suspect that they were much bigger in the past. Each subsequent generation would have "watered down" the dragon blood and probably resulted in smaller descendants.
yeah that does make sense, the effects of the dragon blood becoming less intense over the generations, watered down as you say.
#17
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 09:02
From the way Bull talks about it, it sounds more like the Kossith were the original race, and that the Qunari were a result of them mixing with something (maybe dragons, maybe something else) - I suppose that mixing could have been Tevinter-driven, but it could just as easily have been elf-driven or driven by the Kossith themselves (that's what it sounded like based on that dialogue, although admittedly it was very vague).
I came away from it with the notion that it sounds like the Qunari came to human lands after they'd split from the Kossith, but I suppose we don't know yet one was or the other.
It could be that the elves are responsible, given what we've find out about them. Warring against themselves, could be that one of the elven gods created them, and when Tevinter showed up to pick up the pieces of Arlathan, Corypheus learned about the creation of the Kossith.
#18
Posté 14 janvier 2015 - 09:07
Regarding the time-scale we can safely assume that the ancient magisters didn't have anything to do with qunari creation and Corypheus words shoudln't be taken that he means that their creation was a mistake but at what he simply states. The Qunari aren't a species. They are a culture. A culture composed of many different people from many different backgrounds is something completly opposite than the tievintian culture, where some families can trace their lineage back a thousand years.
The qunari claim that they arrived on Par-Vollen from another contintent accross the sea and that they lost contact with their homeland. Although the Ben-Hassrath might simply have invented this story I don't see a reason culture-wise to lock the knowledge of their creation away unless it would reveal that they were a small minority on their home continent and had to evacute to Par-Vollen because they were slaughtered by those who wouldn't follow the Qun or weren't dragon-cross-breeds.
But so far everything we learned about them has been Ben-Hassrath filtered.... so how much of this is the truth? So far they have shown to be extremly willing to everything that would grant them an advantage.
I should clarify, when i wrote Qunari i was actually referring to the Kossith race, not followers of the Qun, sorry about that.
I had similar thoughts about why they had to leave their homeland, maybe they where persecuted by those who did not follow the Qun...or maybe the Kossith that remain in their homeland turned into something far worse!
#19
Posté 15 janvier 2015 - 08:44
The qunari claim that they arrived on Par-Vollen from another contintent accross the sea and that they lost contact with their homeland. Although the Ben-Hassrath might simply have invented this story I don't see a reason culture-wise to lock the knowledge of their creation away unless it would reveal that they were a small minority on their home continent and had to evacute to Par-Vollen because they were slaughtered by those who wouldn't follow the Qun or weren't dragon-cross-breeds.
But so far everything we learned about them has been Ben-Hassrath filtered.... so how much of this is the truth? So far they have shown to be extremly willing to everything that would grant them an advantage.
It would be terrifying : a minority of the kossith would have been able to stand its own for decades against almost all of Thedas. Still,n it is a possibility that i would like to expand upon in a future game.
#20
Posté 15 janvier 2015 - 09:45
From Iron Bull's dialog, it would appear more likely that it was the Kossith, which look nothing like the Qunari we know, that did the experiments upon themselves. My guess is they may have had tried to make their slave or poor more useful and compliant. Something like a slave revolt probably brought them to our part of the world.
Ogres exist as Darkspawn, it is thought, because the Kossith that arrived in Korcari Wilds were deformed. The ogres have horns and grey skin, much like Qunari. Kossith probably had horns. If experiment took place, it would have occured far before they landed and if by the Kossith themselves, why/how would Cory know?





Retour en haut







