Aller au contenu

Photo

Why was Jack a LI only for Male Sheps?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
177 réponses à ce sujet

#101
Mordokai

Mordokai
  • Members
  • 2 036 messages

Also this:

 

No aliens.

 

Aliens are meant to be killed, not boinked.

 

3592_2d72_500_1.jpeg

 

7773_bc38_1.jpeg

 

Make love, not war!

 

And for my buddy Daemul... kinda NSFWish, mind you, even if it only shows a lot of naked skin.

 

Spoiler

 

Hope you'll appreciate this when I get banned :P Done by incredibly talented asarimaniac.


  • Bowie Hawkins, blahblahblah et Kynare aiment ceci

#102
StayFrosty05

StayFrosty05
  • Members
  • 1 349 messages

Jack never should have been a love interest for anyone. She's really, really messed up. I really like Jack, I think she's probably a top 7 maybe top 5 Mass Effect character ever. But she's so damaged that it never made a lot of sense to make her a romance option. 
 
Side note. 
 
Miranda was originally intended to be a bisexual romance option. But they changed it.

Which is interesting, given how unstable Miranda also is.

#103
spockjedi

spockjedi
  • Members
  • 748 messages
I think it was because there are already many lesbian/asari romantic options in the Mass Effect universe, and some hetero women were necessary to keep the balance.
femshepm.png
  • Rasande, Milana et StayFrosty05 aiment ceci

#104
von uber

von uber
  • Members
  • 5 523 messages
Many = 1?
Asari don't count, and Kelly is willing to take anything.

#105
Display Name Owner

Display Name Owner
  • Members
  • 1 190 messages

And for my buddy Daemul... kinda NSFWish, mind you, even if it only shows a lot of naked skin.

 

Spoiler

 

Hope you'll appreciate this when I get banned :P Done by incredibly talented asarimaniac.

 

Kinda NSFW-ish? Haha, anyone reading this, I'd save this for home if I were you.



#106
Daemul

Daemul
  • Members
  • 1 428 messages
3204840swsw.gif

#107
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

Which is interesting, given how unstable Miranda also is.

 

Miranda isn't unstable at all. 



#108
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

Oh, you're one of THOSE people. 

 

And let's not bring up the god awful Tomb Raider reboot.  That's just a huge can of worms right there. 

 

One of what people? Are you calling me a man? I'll send you an angry message in clouds if you are!

 

I thought the Tomb Raider reboot was amazing. 



#109
prosthetic soul

prosthetic soul
  • Members
  • 2 068 messages

One of what people? Are you calling me a man? I'll send you an angry message in clouds if you are!

 

I thought the Tomb Raider reboot was amazing. 

Spoiler



#110
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

I think it was because there are already many lesbian/asari romantic options in the Mass Effect universe, and some hetero women were necessary to keep the balance.
femshepm.png

 

On technical terms, you have a disparity on what is actually straight, bi, or gay.

 

Miranda, Ashley, Jack, Tali, Jacob, James, Garrus, Thane, and Javik are all straight. Granted, two of those characters are more bonus flings added on through DLC (with one of them essentially being an easter-egg joke), while another two character's relationships end no matter what you do.

 

Kaidan, Kelly, Allers, Liara, and Samara are the Bi options (one more with one of those characters being more of a bonus fling from DLC), and arguably two of these relationships go absolutely nowhere (one has basically no content, the other is more or less a fling). So in some ways, you only have 2 Bi options.

 

Traynor and Cortez are the gay options. 

 

But yeah, you have 4 unambiguously straight female LI's, and 5 unambiguously straight male LI's.

 

5 bisexual LI's.

 

And two homosexual LI's.

 

I think there should have been more male LI's. Especially human. All-in-all, females really only get 4 real (2 of whom aren't exclusive) LI's in ME3, whereas males get 7 (with 5 of them being male only).

 

So yeah, there's massive inequality.



#111
Vazgen

Vazgen
  • Members
  • 4 967 messages

Male

5 Straight - Ashley, Jack, Miranda, Kelly, Allers

2 Gay - Kaidan (ME3), Cortez

3 Alien - Liara, Tali, Samara (Citadel DLC)

 

Female

3 Straight - Kaidan, Jacob, James (Citadel DLC)

3 Lesbian - Kelly, Allers, Traynor

5 Alien - Liara, Thane, Garrus, Samara (Citadel DLC), Javik (Citadel DLC)

 

Overall, females have 11 romance options, males have 10. ME3 changes the numbers by killing Thane and making Jacob a cheater. Female Shepards are left with 2 straight, 3 lesbian and 4 alien romance options. Male Shepards are left with 5 straight, 2 gay and 3 alien romance options. 



#112
von uber

von uber
  • Members
  • 5 523 messages
The problem is vazgen, if you knock out the shared / dead / ephemeral crap (e.g. allers, james) then femshep as down to 2 - either lesbian or alien.

#113
fhs33721

fhs33721
  • Members
  • 1 251 messages
Overall, females have 11 romance options, males have 9. ME3 equalizes the number by killing Thane and making Jacob a cheater. Female Shepards are left with 2 straight, 3 lesbian and 4 alien romance options. Male Shepards are left with 4 straight, 2 gay and 3 alien romance options. 

Are we really counting James and Javik as actual romance options? I mean that's kind of like saying that Isabella is actual romance for all Wardens. If we are counting it though, you should probably also count Shaira and Morinth for all Shepards.



#114
Rasande

Rasande
  • Members
  • 201 messages

Ignoring the total number of romance options, there are 2 male romance options in ME3, one had to survive the first game and the other had to be romanced in the second.

 

Lame...


  • God aime ceci

#115
Vazgen

Vazgen
  • Members
  • 4 967 messages

Let's see. Removing romances that don't count towards Paramour achievement in ME3

Male

4 straight - Ashley, Jack, Miranda, Kelly

2 gay - Kaidan, Cortez

2 alien - Liara, Tali

 

Female

1 straight - Kaidan

2 lesbian - Kelly, Traynor

3 alien - Liara, Thane, Garrus

 

8 vs 6, or rather 5 since Thane dies. That sucks. On the other hand, only one romance option of those 5 has no pre-Earth romance scene - Kelly. Males have 3 of those - Jack, Miranda, Kelly. 

I do agree that female romance options are lacking as a whole, and not only straight/lesbian options. Hopefully that'll change in ME:Next. I would like these proportions for romance options (for both sexes) - 4 straight, 2 gay, 2 alien



#116
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

But you have to discern the amount of content and the nature of the content.

 

On paper, yeah, Femshep has more numerical LI's.

 

But look at how most of them turn out:

 

James is really a fling during the Citadel DLC; more appropriately, Shepard gets really drunk and borrows his penis for the DLC.

 

Jacob cheats on you and is completely closed off, even if the game implies that he still has feelings for you (actually, Dr. Cole explicitly says that Jacob still loves Shepard), which is full of all sorts of unpleasant implications (Jacob, the black guy, ditches you for another woman and knocks her up, but is implied to still be in love with you, which may potentially lead to him ditching his baby momma to get back with you). But past that, yeah, Jacob got iced as a character. 

 

Thane gets some decent romantic content (IMO), but ultimately ends up as the deceased LI, cutting off that branch.

 

Javik is a flat-out joke 'LI' that was added more for humor than romance in a DLC(similar to James, although there's at least some semblance of courtship with him). 

 

Samara gets some nice content, but it's a DLC bonus with some UST that will ultimately never lead anywhere. You really can't call her an LI.

 

Kelly is basically an ME2 consolation prize, the hot assistant you had that you get to take advantage of if you have no one else. In ME3, she all-but disappears from existence after, with no content past a kiss and walking into a shed. 

 

And Allers isn't an LI so much as she is a fling. It's been stated that it's not a serious relationship at all, just a mutual attraction that turns physical.

 

A lot of these can't really be called Love Interests in the sense of the word here. I'm not going to argue about the problem of inequality here (I'm a Male Shep player who exclusively romances Miranda with a few female liaisons on the side prior to that (and more if Miranda is willing to experiment), and I'd say the best possible LI for Femshep would be Male Shep.) I'm just acknowledging that it does indeed exist.



#117
fhs33721

fhs33721
  • Members
  • 1 251 messages

 

 I'd say the best possible LI for Femshep would be Male Shep.

What? How...?  I can't even.....

 

Well, guess I'll need to buy this book here after all.

 

how-to-even-for-dummies.jpg



#118
God

God
  • Members
  • 2 432 messages

Shepardcest. One of my two canon romances.

 

MaleShep: Miranda

 

FemShep: MaleShep

 

MaleShep, Miranda, Femshep trio?

 

You hit the sweet spot.

 

Throw in Kelly and Doctor Michel too for extra redness. 

 

As a redhead, you can never have enough redheads.


  • DeathScepter et blahblahblah aiment ceci

#119
berrieh

berrieh
  • Members
  • 669 messages

Why are people still arguing about this? ME2 has been out for five years (well on the 26th of this month it will be 5 years old) . Jack experimented but she ended up not liking it. You can watch videos on YouTube of her character explaining this (or you can see it for yourself when you play the game), that she is not interested in Femshep sexually, because Jack identifies as being straight. 

 

I think part of the OP's curiosity might come from the fact that it's fairly common to see the Jack dialogue where she mentions having sex with at least one woman (though technically, it was a couple) as well as men but it's more obscure to see the conversation where she basically says ladies aren't her thing. (It requires talking to her at more specific parts, whereas the other one is one of her basic conversation options IIRC and a very early conversation.)

 

I agree with you that the character IS straight (and by the way, you can help her just as much without romancing her anyway, so a male Shep doesn't "save her" with a magic penis trope, because whether Jack gets her head screwed on right or not depends on loyalty - the result in ME3 is a positive, more functional Jack either way if she is loyal and survives - or maybe honestly if she just survives, though she does have a tendency to die easily if not loyal). 

 

However, I wouldn't assume everyone has seen her point out ladies are not her cuppa. I have played ME2 multiple times as both Sheps and only saw that conversation in like a 3rd or 4th playthrough where she was friendly and seemed to assume my FemShep was hitting on her (not the intention, actually) and she talked about it. 



#120
Andres Hendrix

Andres Hendrix
  • Members
  • 1 424 messages

I think part of the OP's curiosity might come from the fact that it's fairly common to see the Jack dialogue where she mentions having sex with at least one woman (though technically, it was a couple) as well as men but it's more obscure to see the conversation where she basically says ladies aren't her thing. (It requires talking to her at more specific parts, whereas the other one is one of her basic conversation options IIRC and a very early conversation.)

 

I agree with you that the character IS straight (and by the way, you can help her just as much without romancing her anyway, so a male Shep doesn't "save her" with a magic penis trope, because whether Jack gets her head screwed on right or not depends on loyalty - the result in ME3 is a positive, more functional Jack either way if she is loyal and survives - or maybe honestly if she just survives, though she does have a tendency to die easily if not loyal). 

 

However, I wouldn't assume everyone has seen her point out ladies are not her cuppa. I have played ME2 multiple times as both Sheps and only saw that conversation in like a 3rd or 4th playthrough where she was friendly and seemed to assume my FemShep was hitting on her (not the intention, actually) and she talked about it. 

I don't agree with this, if you try to romance Jack as a Female Shepard, just as a male Shepard would, it is contingent to circumstance that she lets you down. Therefore, to get the conversation in question, all you have to do is persue the romance with Jack as a female Shepard. The only way you miss it is if you either speed skip the conversation, or stop trying to romance Jack befor said conversation. Also, I'm not sure why you say "and by the way" (as though you are telling me something I don't already know), as part of my reasoning behind why the magic penis trope is stupid was that sex had nothing to do with helping Jack's psychological problems.


  • Valmar aime ceci

#121
StayFrosty05

StayFrosty05
  • Members
  • 1 349 messages

Miranda isn't unstable at all.

O.o...you have an unusual perception...and so we can agree to disagree.

#122
StayFrosty05

StayFrosty05
  • Members
  • 1 349 messages

Many = 1?
Asari don't count, and Kelly is willing to take anything.


From the Asari point of view it doesn't count, but from a Human point of view it does.. to the Human mind and eye the Asari are simply blue women, there is nothing masculine about them but they are certainly very female, thus a ManShep with one is in his minds eye a hetro style relationship, whereas a FemShep in her minds eye she is in a lesbian style relationship.

#123
78stonewobble

78stonewobble
  • Members
  • 3 252 messages

I have no idea, why the Jack character turned out, the way that she does.

 

But my personal preferences in the regards of npc and li's.

 

I rather prefer the writer thinks up some well developed characters and that includes a set sexuality, even if it's something that ie. gets discovered during the story and / or over time. I dislike the idea of characters getting moulded to fit some weird requirement of diversity, that diversity should be included from the get go.

 

As a guy I think F/F romance and more is pretty boring, because it has nothing to do with me. However, it can be the basis of a great and truely platonic friendship and I think there are room for such stories even in computergames.

 

I agree with other posters, that not every npc should drool over the playercharacter. I also believe that for li aspects to be improved in the future, it should be based somewhat on character traits or approximation of personality matches like ie. not everyone would be with a paragon player char and not everyone would be with a renegade.



#124
teh DRUMPf!!

teh DRUMPf!!
  • Members
  • 9 142 messages

O.o...you have an unusual perception...and so we can agree to disagree.

 

Miranda is not unstable, she is insecure. There is a difference.


  • DeathScepter, God et blahblahblah aiment ceci

#125
StayFrosty05

StayFrosty05
  • Members
  • 1 349 messages

Miranda is not unstable, she is insecure. There is a difference.


Instability is not always as in your face obvious as Jacks...though you and I obviously have rather different perspectives of Mirandas behavior and choices.