Aller au contenu

Photo

Constructive Criticism...


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
79 réponses à ce sujet

#1
N7 Tigger

N7 Tigger
  • Members
  • 1 581 messages

...or, How to Improve Dragon Age Inquisition Multiplayer.

 

I've been pretty vocal about my disappointment with Dragon Age Inquisition Multiplayer. To be blunt I think, in it's current state, it's terrible. But this has nothing to do with bugs. BioWare are aware of these bugs and they will be fixed. But once every bug is fixed we will still be left with a pretty bad game.

 

So, BioWare, you wanted constructive feedback? Here it is...

 

 

General Problems

 

-Characters are uglier than a hobo’s balls.

 

-The camera is zoomed out too far (to avoid seeing how fugly characters are?). Needs to be the same as SP.

 

-We can’t pick a faction but are forced to pick a map.

 

-We can’t see other players equipment or Prestige (or whatever the DAMP version of N7 Rank is).

 

-No countdown when three players ready up. (AFK hosts should be drawn and quartered.)

 

-No armor crafting preview. See ‘The Loot System’ for why this shouldn’t actually be an issue. But right now we need it.

 

-Terrible maps. Lose the ‘procedurally generated’ maps. Have set maps but make them bigger, better looking, more creative and more unique. Enough with the ruins.

 

-Characters move way too slow.

 

-Class doors. If you insist having them at least give us a consumable to open them if we don’t have the right class.

 

-Get rid of the pots. Instead give us the gold for completing the zone.

 

-Make treasure rooms a little harder/longer to complete but give us a decent reward. As it stands breaking three pots gives you the same reward as defeating a Revenant.

 

-Teleportation needs to be removed. Three players want to clear a treasure room but the fourth just runs forward and teleports them to the next zone. Change it so three out of four players must be in the recovery font room before the door to the next zone will open. Or two out of three. Or both if a duo.

 

-Which would make it even more important to have a two minute idle kick in public matches.

 

-The guy who sells the chests. Look at him. You just know he'd call you 'brah'. This is a merchant...

 

RE4_Merchant.png

 

 

The loot system!!!

 

Is broken. After two months of ME3 I had maxed my commons and never saw another Shuriken in a pack. After two years of DAMP I will still be getting level 1 Raider Greatswords from chests.

 

-Remove weapon and armor crafting. Remove Salvaging. Do it now. It’s stupid.

 

-Each character should have a set (basic version plus three variations) of Common, Rare and Unique armor. Why on earth do the Katari and Necromancer have one set of Rare and three sets of Unique armor and the Reaver and Elementalist have one set of Common and two sets of Rare?

 

-Each tier (Common, Rare and Unique) of weapons should have three or four weapons in each category (Bows, Staffs etc.)

 

-Weapons should level from I – X each time you get one from a chest.

 

-Weapon and armor mods should be permanent not consumable just like weapon mods in ME3.

 

-Rings/Belts/Amulets should have tiers. For example, Bleed on Hit might be Common, +Strength might be Rare and Heal on Kill might be Unique. These would upgrade from, for example:

 

     HoK Ring I – 2% to HoK Ring V – 10%.

     Enhanced ability rings I – V would be 6% - 12% - 18% - 24% - 30%.

 

-Mods and Rings should level from I – V each time you get one from a chest.

 

-Weapon mods need to be streamlined. Each weapon should have one mod slot and one rune slot. All weapon types can be said to have a 'Grip'. A dozen or so Grips with various effects could be leveled from I - V. Some examples:

 

     +5% - 25% damage to Guard or Barriers

     +5% - 25% Attack or Armor Penetration

     +2% - 10% Critical Chance

     +5% - 25% Critical Damage or Flanking Damage.

 

-Armor mods need to be streamlined. For example:

 

     Arms – Ranged and Magic Defence (again I – V would be 2% - 10%)

     Legs – melee defence and health (2% and 40 health - 10% and 200 health).

 

-Each type of armor could also have class specific bonuses. For example, add the offensive attribute to the arms and defensive to the legs. So we might end up with the following for an Archer:

 

     Rogue Arms V - +10% Ranged Defence +10% Magic Defence + 10 Dexterity

     Rogue Legs V - +10% melee defence +200 health +10 Cunning.

 

-Runes should be permanent not consumable. All should be Unique. Damage for level I – V would range from 5 – 25.

 

-Chests should now function like ME3 packs. For example, a large chest would contain a guaranteed two Rares with a chance at Uniques in those two slots.

 

-Once a weapon, ring or mod reaches it's maximum level, be it V or X, we should never get another from a chest.

 

-Cold, Electrical, Fire and Spirit Resistance Tonics need to be rolled into one Elemental Resistance Tonic.

 

 

 

These things would be challenging, but not impossible to implement.

 

I honestly believe that so many terrible decisions were made because the devs didn’t want to be accused of just copying ME3. The problem is that ME3 spent 2 years figuring out how to do these things right. If you refuse to learn from someone who’s doing it right you end up doing it wrong.

 

 

Thanks, BioWare, and let me know when you've finished.

 

 Untitled6.png


  • Beerfish, SoulRebel_1979, Laughing_Man et 21 autres aiment ceci

#2
Jeremiah12LGeek

Jeremiah12LGeek
  • Members
  • 23 893 messages

"Liked" mainly for including the merchant from Resident Evil 4.


  • Kenny Bania aime ceci

#3
akots1

akots1
  • Members
  • 1 222 messages

Moslty good suggestions, very reasonable.


  • Denante1 aime ceci

#4
Kinom001

Kinom001
  • Members
  • 2 573 messages

"Liked" mainly for including the merchant from Resident Evil 4.

I liked it for the "hobo's balls" statement. Purty funny.


  • Jeremiah12LGeek et Courtnehh aiment ceci

#5
Kenny Bania

Kenny Bania
  • Members
  • 2 896 messages

There's apparently an official thread for great ideas such as these. You can post them there.


  • Beerfish, Jeremiah12LGeek, 21T09 et 3 autres aiment ceci

#6
Jeremiah12LGeek

Jeremiah12LGeek
  • Members
  • 23 893 messages

I liked it for the "hobo's balls" statement. Purty funny.

 

That, too. :P



#7
ALTBOULI

ALTBOULI
  • Members
  • 2 704 messages
Op is a rabblerouser
  • Cette, 21T09, N7 Tigger et 2 autres aiment ceci

#8
N7 Tigger

N7 Tigger
  • Members
  • 1 581 messages

There's apparently an official thread for great ideas such as these. You can post them there.

 

Post a link if you like.



#9
Kenny Bania

Kenny Bania
  • Members
  • 2 896 messages


Post a link if you like.

 

Here you go...



#10
Angry_Elcor

Angry_Elcor
  • Members
  • 1 652 messages

 

Don't forget to give him credit, now.



#11
Kenny Bania

Kenny Bania
  • Members
  • 2 896 messages

Don't forget to give him credit, now.

 

That's the OP's job.



#12
Angry_Elcor

Angry_Elcor
  • Members
  • 1 652 messages

That's the OP's job.

 

Of course. My bad.



#13
Puffy9999

Puffy9999
  • Members
  • 104 messages

How many Hobo's balls did you compare against?


  • Cette et TBJack aiment ceci

#14
N7 Tigger

N7 Tigger
  • Members
  • 1 581 messages

 

A link to this thread in yours! Scrub.


  • ALTBOULI et Jeremiah12LGeek aiment ceci

#15
N7 Tigger

N7 Tigger
  • Members
  • 1 581 messages

How many Hobo's balls did you compare against?

 

I don't want to talk about it.


  • DragonRacer, Aetika, Jeremiah12LGeek et 1 autre aiment ceci

#16
Kenny Bania

Kenny Bania
  • Members
  • 2 896 messages

A link to this thread in yours! Scrub.

 

Ah! The OP appears to have abandoned that thread, so I'll step up to the plate.



#17
Beerfish

Beerfish
  • Members
  • 23 869 messages

Is this the same Tigger that has a cold or something and can't talk or use a mic at this time?



#18
N7 Tigger

N7 Tigger
  • Members
  • 1 581 messages

Is this the same Tigger that has a cold or something and can't talk or use a mic at this time?

 

There is only one Tigger. But I think you have me mixed up with someone else. My voice and my mic are working just fine.



#19
Rackham

Rackham
  • Members
  • 8 messages

I agree with almost everything except 

 

 

 

Weapons should level from I – X each time you get one from a chest

 

I still play ME3 multi from day one and I still don't have most ultra rares past like V. No thank you on that grind again. 



#20
holdenagincourt

holdenagincourt
  • Members
  • 5 035 messages

The maps are not really procedurally generated except in the most minimal sense of the term. There are a few options available for each x/5 area (e.g. Elven Ruins has three possible options for the first room) but those options can't occur anywhere else. And the Destruction DLC maps are not procedural at all.

 

I agree with a few things here but disagree vehemently on the removal of crafting and stretching out the grind to include multirank weapons. I would prefer that the 90% of uniques that suck just get buffed at the baseline. As long as base damage is king, multirank won't matter because the existing handful of best weapons will remain on top of the pile. As for the removal of crafting, we should just be patient and wait for the addition of schematics to the game, which a great many people were looking forward to when they started playing.

 

Your suggestion of making runes reusable is not consistent with how things work in the Dragon Age universe since DA2. I doubt they'll go back on that decision and I don't think there's much reason to since runes of all tiers and varieties drop like candy.


  • Shinnyshin aime ceci

#21
Cette

Cette
  • Members
  • 349 messages

I don't want to talk about it.


40,000 for a full set.

#22
Kenny Bania

Kenny Bania
  • Members
  • 2 896 messages

I still play ME3 multi from day one and I still don't have most ultra rares past like V. No thank you on that grind again. 

 

How is this even possible?



#23
Jugger nuggss

Jugger nuggss
  • Members
  • 3 746 messages
Rrtodqk_zpsz9xu1igb.gif
  • Kenny Bania aime ceci

#24
Mushgrump

Mushgrump
  • Members
  • 12 messages

Rrtodqk_zpsz9xu1igb.gif

liar, he read it. 



#25
hong

hong
  • Members
  • 2 012 messages
n7rankmeansnothing.jpg