560 réponses à ce sujet

[Iakus]

I really liked Kieran's scenes in DAI.  But I still think Redeemer is the best ending for DAO

[Secret Rare]

 

 

It's a win-win for whoever's involved.

People should really get over the win-win or lose-lose scenario based solely on their personal perspective in an rpg games.

everything is a win-win if  is the player decision.

[Secret Rare]

I really liked Kieran's scenes in DAI.  But I still think Redeemer is the best ending for DAO

this is my personal ending love it.

Clear solution 0 gamble and one man redeemed,

Basically the nonsense that someone said    win-win scenario for whoever is involved

[Aren]

Wardens should die as Wardens do.

With soul overdose? that's an honor for a few Wardens, it's like to Ascend into the heaven you die but as a god.

[Br3admax]

People should really get over the win-win or lose-lose scenario based solely on their personal perspective in an rpg games.
everything is a win-win if is the player decision.

No, it's a win win based completely meta game knowledge. There is literally no reason to not do it outside of rping which is what I said.

[Beregond5]

My Male!Mahariel always goes for the Dark Ritual - As much as he loves his clan, he ends up considering himself a Grey Warden first and foremost, so he wants to be sure that someone is left to rebuild the Wardens in Ferelden. The fact that he's romanced Zevran and wants to stay with him doesn't hurt either. And, ultimately, Morrigan is friends with him and she does sound like she's genuinely trying to save him.

My Female Cousland always accepts the Dark Ritual too, for the obvious reason that she wants to stay with Alistair.

 

My Female Amell didn't accept the Dark Ritual. Though friends with Morrigan, she still considered it blood magic, and seeing how it destroyed Jowan and so many others in the Tower, she hated it. Cue Alistair dying and my heart sinking way way down.

I never did get around to complete the other origins, but my guess is they'd accept the ritual.

[andy6915]

Dark Ritual, obviously. I have Aveline's way of thinking (it's about what Aveline thinks of the one she was named after):

 

"Her glory lies in tragedy, but the living Aveline doesn't revere sacrifice: a principled death is still a death."

 

Like that, except it's for my Warden. Grey Warden's glory does very much lie in tragedy and sacrifice, but my Warden's think that dying when you have a way to avoid it is just plain stupid.

[Aren]

, but my Warden's think that dying when you have a way to avoid it is just plain stupid.

Not if the way to avoid one death, help the archdemon as well

The risk/reward ratio are so terrible unbalanced that i'm incapable to see the tempation of the DR,Morrigan has nothing to offer because my warden's life is his own ,glad to have helped Loghain so that he has helped me in return, in my world state Urthemiel can go to sing his song into the Oblivion alongside of his acolyte, the Architect.

[vertigomez]

I really liked Kieran's scenes in DAI.  But I still think Redeemer is the best ending for DAO

That's why I had a normal baby with Morrigan instead.

[andy6915]

 

Not if the way to avoid one death, help the archdemon as well

The risk/reward ratio are so terrible unbalanced that i'm incapable to see the tempation of the DR,Morrigan has nothing to offer because my warden's life is his own ,glad to have helped Loghain so that he has helped me in return, in my world state Urthemiel can go to sing his song into the Oblivion alongside of his acolyte, the Architect.

 

 

Have sex or die... Yeah, really bad risk/reward ratio there . And how in Andraste's name does it help the archedemon? It's dead. Or is the actual old god's soul that isn't even guilty of anything other than getting corrupted by an evil force against its will that you want dead too? That's foolish and horrible. I already don't like you much as a poster, and this post only fueled that opinion.

[Aren]

Have sex or die... Yeah, really bad risk/reward ratio there . And how in Andraste's name does it help the archedemon? It's dead. Or is the actual old god's soul that isn't even guilty of anything other than getting corrupted by an evil force against its will that you want dead too? That's foolish and horrible. I already don't like you much as a poster, and this post only fueled that opinion.

Death is not mandatory even without a DR and honestly i do not care much of what you like or not.  

Yes the "gods" of an empire of slaves deserve only the obliteration, take all the risks of the possibility of what Flemeth/Solas could do with that power to help their own "people"  for one life? All the if and maybe, when you can simply burn on ashes the archdemon once and for all is lunacy.

[andy6915]

 

death is not mandatory even without a Dr, and honestly i do not care much of what you like or not, and yes the "gods" of an empire of slaves deserve only the obliteration, take all the risks for one life with all the if and maybe, when you can simply burn on ashes the archdemon once and for all is lunacy.

Give his soul to a misanthrope like Morrigan and Flemeth or worse Solas is even more folly.

 

 

Yes, never mind that all the old gods being destroyed could have (strongly hinted) unforeseen consequences. Let's just do that and hope nothing bad happens due to your extremely idiotic shortsightedness in thinking that every ancient god dying can't POSSIBLY result in anything bad, there's absolutely NO WAY that could bite you in the ass.

 

Ugh... I'm done responding to your posts. They annoy me and have too much ignorance to be worth the effort in typing a reply to them .

[KaiserShep]

Dark Ritual, obviously. I have Aveline's way of thinking (it's about what Aveline thinks of the one she was named after):

 

"Her glory lies in tragedy, but the living Aveline doesn't revere sacrifice: a principled death is still a death."

 

Like that, except it's for my Warden. Grey Warden's glory does very much lie in tragedy and sacrifice, but my Warden's think that dying when you have a way to avoid it is just plain stupid.

 

While I myself do not have a compelling enough reason to deny the dark ritual, because, well, f*ck sacrifice when there's a clear out where everyone gets to go home, it's simple enough to conjure up a good one for a particular character you have in mind. Like, my city elf was made mostly for a laugh, but I did often make him a serious character that hated magic, trusted no mage and loathed even the idea of the old gods with every fiber of his being, and wanted nothing to do with anything that would preserve even a shred of it, so told her to gets the steppin', and Loghain took one for the team. Thinking back on a character like Fenris, I can see him denying the dark ritual for very similar reasons. The setting gives a pretty good basis for that kind of mindset, especially if you buy into the story of how the Blight began.

[andy6915]

While I myself do not have a compelling enough reason to deny the dark ritual, because, well, f*ck sacrifice when there's a clear out where everyone gets to go home, it's simple enough to conjure up a good one for a particular character you have in mind. Like, my city elf was made mostly for a laugh, but I did often make him a serious character that hated magic, trusted no mage and loathed even the idea of the old gods with every fiber of his being, and wanted nothing to do with anything that would preserve even a shred of it, so told her to gets the steppin', and Loghain took one for the team. Thinking back on a character like Fenris, I can see him denying the dark ritual for very similar reasons. The setting gives a pretty good basis for that kind of mindset, especially if you buy into the Chantry's tale of how the blight began.

 

That is a fine reason. The reasons given by the one I was arguing with... Not so much.

[Aren]

Yes, never mind that all the old gods being destroyed could have (strongly hinted) unforeseen consequences. Let's just do that and hope nothing bad happens due to your extremely idiotic shortsightedness in thinking that every ancient god dying can't POSSIBLY result in anything bad, there's absolutely NO WAY that could bite you in the ass.

 

Ugh... I'm done responding to your posts. They annoy me and have too much ignorance to be worth the effort in typing a reply to them .

Is Solas who has told to you this? Well good luck to believe him(another) liar  Thedas can certainly live well even without the elven gods/old gods.

[andy6915]

but Thedas can certainly live well even without the elven gods/old gods.

 

You assume.

[Aren]

You assume.

 

This is the way in which i role play my heroes, if you play fair i can give to you even the moon and all my trust,if you start to hide the truth in important matters,we cannot go well together,Morrigan is a liar,Solas is a liar they both deserve nothing from my heroes.

[KaiserShep]

You assume.

While it's certainly an assumption, for lack of more compelling evidence to the contrary, the idea of preemptively wiping out these dormant entities isn't a particularly bad one. The Wardens' demon summoning to destroy the old gods was foolhardy, but I feel only because of the demon binding part and being dupes for a Venatori mage. If there was a way they could forge through the deep roads and successfully kill the old gods before the darkspawn had a chance to corrupt them without slitting each others' throats in crazy blood rituals, I'd probably be pretty on board with that plan, Solas be damned. Now, if he actually spelled out a good reason why this would be bad, then I'd be all ears, but "It could be worse" is insufficient.

[Iakus]

That's why I had a normal baby with Morrigan instead.

That's my current ply-thru:  Dead Warden, human (well, half-dwarf) baby, Loghain as a Grey Warden.

[vertigomez]

That's my current ply-thru:  Dead Warden, human (well, half-dwarf) baby, Loghain as a Grey Warden.

I always approve of half-dwarf Kieran.

[Aren]

I always approve of half-dwarf Kieran.

is he the first example of half-dwarf in the series?

[vertigomez]

is he the first example of half-dwarf in the series?

I believe so. I mean, it's said that they're possible, so presumably there are others out there... somewhere.

Luthias Dwarfson was apparently human despite the name (and being shorter and stronger than the average human), and he married a dwarf but I don't know if they had any kids.

So, yeah. Kieran it is.

[Iakus]

is he the first example of half-dwarf in the series?

The first confirmed case.  It's speculated that Sandal might be half human or elven.  Half-dwarves are supposed to be extremely rare.

[Secret Rare]

No, it's a win win based completely meta game knowledge. There is literally no reason to not do it outside of rping which is what I said.

Again,everything is a win win if it is the player decison including the Ultimate sacrifice.

[Aren]

The first confirmed case.  It's speculated that Sandal might be half human or elven.  Half-dwarves are supposed to be extremely rare

 

 

In the case of the DR performed with a Dwarf Morrigan was capable to succeed at the first try, lmao Impressive!  

The genes of the witches must be superior.