Aller au contenu

Photo

The good, the bad and the ugly list


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
107 réponses à ce sujet

#51
Aimi

Aimi
  • Members
  • 4 616 messages

Dorian's cliche storyline.


loool

#52
(Disgusted noise.)

(Disgusted noise.)
  • Members
  • 1 833 messages

Love:

Dorian

Cassandra

 

Like:

Cullen

Vivienne

Josephine

Cole

Sera

 

Indifferent:

Blackwall

Varric

Leliana

Iron Bull

 

Dislike:

Solas

 

Hated:

Mother ****** Giselle



#53
rda

rda
  • Members
  • 933 messages
Thank you, someone else who dislikes Solas. Everyone else is like, "he's so awesome!"

I think he's an arrogant tool with no redeeming qualities whatsoever.

#54
(Disgusted noise.)

(Disgusted noise.)
  • Members
  • 1 833 messages

Thank you, someone else who dislikes Solas. Everyone else is like, "he's so awesome!"

I think he's an arrogant tool with no redeeming qualities whatsoever.

I'm not like "Kill Solas!!1!" about it, but yeah, we just do not get along. And since I'm not really interested in elves or spirits, which are his biggest selling points, I just can't really find a reason to talk to him most of the time.



#55
TheKomandorShepard

TheKomandorShepard
  • Members
  • 8 489 messages

Thank you, someone else who dislikes Solas. Everyone else is like, "he's so awesome!"

I think he's an arrogant tool with no redeeming qualities whatsoever.

How solais is a tool if he have own plans and goal and isn't controlled by anyone or at least we don't know he is.



#56
rda

rda
  • Members
  • 933 messages

How solais is a tool if he have own plans and goal and isn't controlled by anyone or at least we don't know he is.


I used tool in the sense that he's a dick, not tool in the sense that he's easily manipulated.
  • duckley aime ceci

#57
Eagle Pusuit

Eagle Pusuit
  • Members
  • 532 messages
Liked:
Cassandra- I like her badass with a soft side schtick
Iron Bull- he has many facets and is endlessly interesting
Vivienne- I expected to dislike her, but she turned out to be classy and polite, even when insulting people. I like that.
Sera- I also expected to dislike her, but she's just too much fun, even when excessively violent
Cole- I like his enigmatic way of speaking
Lace Harding- I hope she is a companion in DA4
Ser Barris- another potentially cool companion

Disliked:
Blackwall- I expected to like him, but even before I learned his secret, he was kind of a dick
Dorian- he sounds like a John Cleese impersonator and I find his casual indifference irritating

Meh:
Varric- I don't care for new melancholy attitude and secretiveness, but he still has some jokes
Solas- if I didn't need to refer to his encyclopedia brain, I probably wouldn't have anything to talk to him about
Cullen, Josephine, Leliana- I just didn't feel like I could connect to them very well

#58
Lukas Trevelyan

Lukas Trevelyan
  • Members
  • 2 238 messages

Loved:
- Cole
- Cassandra

 

Liked:

- Josephine

- Dorian

- Leliana

- Cullen

- Solas

- Vivienne

 

Meh:

- Varric

- Blackwall

 

Disliked:
- Sera

- Iron Bull



#59
DarthEmpress

DarthEmpress
  • Members
  • 774 messages

Liked:

Cole

Cassandra

Solas

Dorian

Vivienne (I feel like I'm the only one...)

 

Disliked:

Leliana

 

Meh:

Blackwall

Sera

The Iron Bull (I was really looking forward to him...)

Cullen

Josephine

Varric (he's better with Hawke... I just didn't feel it with him in this)



#60
ParagonStovus

ParagonStovus
  • Members
  • 68 messages

 Favourites:

       -Solas

       -Cassandra

       -Cole

       -Varric

       -Morrigan

 

 Liked:

        -Josephine

        -Hawke

        -Loghain

        -Cullen

        -Dorian

        -Blackwall

 

  Mixed feelings:

         -Iron Bull

         -Leliana

         -Vivienne

         -Sera

         -Corypheus :P



#61
teh DRUMPf!!

teh DRUMPf!!
  • Members
  • 9 142 messages

Thank you, someone else who dislikes Solas. Everyone else is like, "he's so awesome!"

I think he's an arrogant tool with no redeeming qualities whatsoever.

 

I also think he is an arrogant tool, but he is a fascinating one who was quite easily the star of the game. Try as I might to minimize him and his crazy views, he is still someone who absolutely rocked his time on the screen and stuck with me more than any other character not named "Vivenne."



#62
Colonelkillabee

Colonelkillabee
  • Members
  • 8 462 messages

How solais is a tool if he have own plans and goal and isn't controlled by anyone or at least we don't know he is.

He's a tool because he doesn't ride our balls and isn't a character who revolves around us, lol.

 

If someone disliked what he says with low disposition I could understand. Though that's like... "Duh".

 

But "No redeeming qualities whatsoever...." ???

 

Yea, not taking that seriously.



#63
Ignoble

Ignoble
  • Members
  • 27 messages

It depends if you mean 'did the inquisitor like them in game' or 'do you think they are good characters'. For instance Vivenne would fail at the former - my inquisitor disliked her - but I think she is a great character (and that the game would be poorer were she not present).

 

I actually didn't dislike anyone. Cole I found a bit of a boring (in the books too) though his quest was cool; Cullen I just never found terribly interesting (though I have no problem with him).

 

Everyone else I liked. Solas was fascinating, one of those characters I know I will remember. Cassandra was great too. And I always have had a soft spot for Leliana.



#64
Ecol-i

Ecol-i
  • Members
  • 38 messages

Liked:

Vivienne (I feel like I'm the only one...)

Not at all, I'm actually surprised at how many people like her; personaly, 3 PTs in and I still haven't found anything I can say I like about her; I didn't get Sera the 1st time around, we started clicking in the 2nd; but by the 3rd PT I "got" her and she became my main sidekick.

 

As for the rest, I find several things to like/ dislike about them:

- Varric is a little too dry on DAI (he does make a better character with Hawke around)

- Solas has great heartwarming moments, but can be a ****** sometimes (I personally hate the way he calls Varric "child of the Stone")

- Bull is great, and I absolutly love Krem and the chargers; though he did not turn out what I expected him to be, but that's not a bad thing...

- Blackwall has some of the funniest party banter actually, but his personality comes off as a bit flat

- Dorian is great, I agree his story is a bit generic, but his personality more than makes up for it; he's definitely the kind of person I'd hang out with in real life.

- Cole has got to be one of the most original characters of the trilogy; I absolutely love Cole and the concept behind his existance.

- I already liked Cass in DA2, she only got better in DAI

- I've always liked Leliana, and I softened her up on DAI; she was my sidekick in DAO (we both specialzed in DW and Arch, and we where just extremely deadly) and I can never erase that image of her giving the high dragon the final finishing blow... god she was so sweet in DAO... good times.

- Cullen has always been a hit or miss for me, I wanted to slap him around in DAO; In DA2 he got some cred points for standing up to Meredith at the end, but I still somehow found his anti-mage stance a bit too overzealous; I like what he has become though, and I like how his character grew (this growth is actually very noticable); that's the reason I created a human female mage to romance him on my 2nd PT, cause he's someone that I actually grew to like... BTW the Cullen romance was very touching (he deserved a circle mage girl after all right?)...

- And what's not to like about Josephine? I mean seriously, just looking at her speak while waving that pen of hers is reason enough to adore her



#65
I present Chuck Bass

I present Chuck Bass
  • Members
  • 788 messages
Dislike-
Sera, Vivienne.

Indifferent-
Dorian, Blackwall,

Like-
Varric, Cassandra, Josephine, Cullen, Leliana, Iron Bull, Solas, Cole.

#66
RobRam10

RobRam10
  • Members
  • 3 266 messages

Loved:

- Cassandra

- Cole

- Dorian

 

Like:

- Solas

- Iron Bull

- Varric

- Blackwall

- Cullen

 

Indifferent

- Josephine

- Leliana

 

-Meh

- Sera

- Vivienne


  • Warden Commander Aeducan aime ceci

#67
Snook

Snook
  • Members
  • 17 341 messages

Loved - 

 

Varric - Didn't expect him to be anywhere else, really. Even if he wasn't quite the friend to the Inquisitor as he was to Hawke, I still really felt like he was a grounding presence in our merry band of misfits. 

 

Leliana - Had to be here. My favourite character in the series, I thought her crisis of faith was well-done, her story becoming increasingly heartfelt and tragic, her references to my romanced Warden and the letter she received from her continue to give feely-feels, and her softened path was one of the more gratifying things this game. Overall, I was pleased with Leliana this game, and consider her one of the most well-rounded characters in the series. Don't like her Divine ending very much, and prefer not to do it, but I don't care much about that. I can ignore it. Leliana. :3

 

Dorian - Just an all-around endearing character, and befriending him lead to some pretty touching dialogue. 

 

Solas - Downright fascinating character, romance arc that's beautifully gut-punching, and without a doubt one of the most interesting companions we've ever had after that final reveal. 

 

Cole - His way of speaking, how incredibly unique he is, the fact that he's probably the most sincere companion we've had in the series thus far...great character, love him to bits. His relationship with Solas and Varric was pretty endearing.

 

Like - 

 

Cassandra - Excellent character, love her strong take-charge personality, and her sincere desire to strive for better, how devoted she is to her faith, while not being blinded by it. She's my preferred choice for Divine, and striking up a friendship with her was really rewarding. Lived up to all my expectations.

 

Blackwall - I dig redemption stories. I feel like there should have been a bit more to his character arc, especially after the reveal, but overall I thought he was well done. He really shines once you start getting banter between him, Cole, Sera etc. 

 

Vivienne - The grandmaster of sass. Fabulous. 

 

Bull - Just a fun character tbh. His banters are always entertaining. 

 

Cullen - Someone who definitely grew on me. Had my doubts about him before, but this game he had some great character development, and certainly proved himself to be a competent commander. 

 

Morrigan - Ah, Morrigan. Me and her have had the most rocky relationship in the series by far. While I adored her friendship arc with my Warden to bits (really wish there were more references to that. They called each other sisters.  :crying: ) her attitude could often grate on me in DA:O. This game, however...man, who would have thought Kieran would change her that much. Loved her interactions with Flemeth, particularly. 

 

Mostly indifferent towards - 

 

Josephine - She's cute, endearing, all of that, but...she's just boring, honestly. 

 

Sera - Fun at times, but got on my nerves too often for me to put her any higher. Still, she's alright. 

 

Hated - 

 

Nobody. Seriously. 



#68
EggplantRed

EggplantRed
  • Members
  • 644 messages
Not bearing romances in mind:

LOVED
- Iron Bull
- Dorian
- Cole (he really grew on me)
- Cassandra
- Cullen

LIKED
- Sera
- Vivienne
- Josephine

MEH
- Blackwall
- Solas
- Varric
- Leiliana (I'm pretty indifferent about her character in this game; maybe I hardened her a bit too much in my PTs)

#69
Nymeria Stark

Nymeria Stark
  • Members
  • 160 messages

Love:

Dorian

Cullen

 

Like:

Cassandra

Blackwall

Cole

Sera

Solas

Varric

Leliana

Josephine

 

Dislike:

The Iron Bull

Vivienne



#70
Warden Commander Aeducan

Warden Commander Aeducan
  • Members
  • 2 278 messages

Loved:

- Cassandra

- Cole

- Dorian

 

Like:

- Solas

- Cullen

- Varric

- Blackwall

- Josephine

 

Indifferent:

- Iron Bull

- Leliana

 

Hated:

- Sera

- Vivienne 


  • RobRam10 aime ceci

#71
Qun00

Qun00
  • Members
  • 4 353 messages
I could try and make a list, but I actually love most of them. Even a list for "indifferent" would be rather short.

Vivienne probably is the only exception. Arrogant, entirely self-serving and power hungry.

#72
BronzTrooper

BronzTrooper
  • Members
  • 5 014 messages

Liked:

Iron Bull

Varric

Cole

Solas

Dorian

Cassandra

Josephine

 

Mixed feelings:

Vivienne

Sera

Leliana

Cullen

 

Disliked:

Hawke

 

Indifferent:

Stroud (only mention him because he has a bigger role in DA:I than he has in DA2)



#73
BSpud

BSpud
  • Members
  • 1 039 messages

Liked everyone, really. Loved Cassandra, Dorian, and mother Morrigan. Only one I truly disliked was the hammy cartoon villain version of Leliana. Even Viv gets a pass because she was well written and meant to be unlikeable. But hardened Leliana near the end of the game... way over the top.



#74
Qun00

Qun00
  • Members
  • 4 353 messages

Not at all, I'm actually surprised at how many people like her; personaly, 3 PTs in and I still haven't found anything I can say I like about her; I didn't get Sera the 1st time around, we started clicking in the 2nd; but by the 3rd PT I "got" her and she became my main sidekick.

As for the rest, I find several things to like/ dislike about them:
- Varric is a little too dry on DAI (he does make a better character with Hawke around)
- Solas has great heartwarming moments, but can be a ****** sometimes (I personally hate the way he calls Varric "child of the Stone")
- Bull is great, and I absolutly love Krem and the chargers; though he did not turn out what I expected him to be, but that's not a bad thing...
- Blackwall has some of the funniest party banter actually, but his personality comes off as a bit flat
- Dorian is great, I agree his story is a bit generic, but his personality more than makes up for it; he's definitely the kind of person I'd hang out with in real life.
- Cole has got to be one of the most original characters of the trilogy; I absolutely love Cole and the concept behind his existance.
- I already liked Cass in DA2, she only got better in DAI
- I've always liked Leliana, and I softened her up on DAI; she was my sidekick in DAO (we both specialzed in DW and Arch, and we where just extremely deadly) and I can never erase that image of her giving the high dragon the final finishing blow... god she was so sweet in DAO... good times.
- Cullen has always been a hit or miss for me, I wanted to slap him around in DAO; In DA2 he got some cred points for standing up to Meredith at the end, but I still somehow found his anti-mage stance a bit too overzealous; I like what he has become though, and I like how his character grew (this growth is actually very noticable); that's the reason I created a human female mage to romance him on my 2nd PT, cause he's someone that I actually grew to like... BTW the Cullen romance was very touching (he deserved a circle mage girl after all right?)...
- And what's not to like about Josephine? I mean seriously, just looking at her speak while waving that pen of hers is reason enough to adore her


Adding ";" randomly and repeatedly doesn't make one sound smarter.

#75
AlexiaRevan

AlexiaRevan
  • Members
  • 14 733 messages

Who's Sprout, Alex?

lol...thats the warden that take Alistair place if alistair is dead or drunk or king  :lol: I dont remember his name..so Sprout it is !