Aller au contenu

Photo

Was the Inquisitor an interesting character to you?


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
223 réponses à ce sujet

#1
Majestic Jazz

Majestic Jazz
  • Members
  • 1 966 messages

What are your thoughts how you enjoyed the Inquisitor's character?

To me he/she was boring compared to the many other Bioware characters such as Revan, Shepard, The Warden, and even Hawke. I think the Inquisitor is too 1-dimensional and is too diplomatic.

With Shepard and Hawke you can have jerks or saints as seen with the "Shepard is a jerk" type videos. With the Inquisitor I doubt you will see any such videos because the character does not have the same depth. Punching Solas was the most aggression I really saw in terms of conversations and dialog options. The Inquisitor is sort of like making Tim Duncan play a super hero for those who know who Tim Duncan is and the reference I am making.

This is contrast to the companions which are all rich in depth and personality. Even mute Warden and Revan had more excitement going for them.

What is your view on the Inquisitor?

 

 

 

 

motivator42b2afd026acf02e8d4f41c596975e7

/Sarcasm


  • Spooky81, SharlenaSharlena, Quinnzel et 4 autres aiment ceci

#2
Elhanan

Elhanan
  • Members
  • 18 341 messages
My second Inquisitor was a better experience, as I was able to maintain more focus on RP rather than exploring options. But I enjoyed them both.

Also am a fan of the racial and class distinctions in the stories.

#3
agonis

agonis
  • Members
  • 896 messages

I´m not interested in playing a complete jerk which is why I enjoyed roleplaying the Inquisitor very much. The aggressive options are fine for me in certain situations. Evil stupid is not my alignment. I prefer diplomatic/sarcastic/manipulative which the Inquisitor manages just fine.


  • mfr001, cheydancer, scruffylad et 14 autres aiment ceci

#4
sim-ran

sim-ran
  • Members
  • 265 messages
You didn't have the extreme paragon / pschopath options but instead you got to add more nuance and individuality to a sane and realistic character than you probably ever did before. Maybe the Inquisitor is not as exciting as some of the past protagonists but Quizzy is nowhere near one dimensional.
  • Elhanan, Konstantin, Ianamus et 14 autres aiment ceci

#5
Lebanese Dude

Lebanese Dude
  • Members
  • 5 545 messages

I´m not interested in playing a complete jerk which is why I enjoyed roleplaying the Inquisitor very much. The aggressive options are fine for me in certain situations. Evil stupid is not my alignment. I prefer diplomatic/sarcastic/manipulative which the Inquisitor manages just fine.

 

I rather liked the aggressive personality of the Inquisitor.

 

It was less renegade douchebag more no-nonsense pragmatist.


  • Maconbar, cheydancer, agonis et 12 autres aiment ceci

#6
PCThug

PCThug
  • Members
  • 820 messages

Yes, I was very happy with how the character turned out.


  • Ishka et ManleySteele aiment ceci

#7
agonis

agonis
  • Members
  • 896 messages

I rather liked the aggressive personality of the Inquisitor.

 

It was less renegade douchebag more no-nonsense pragmatist.

 

It is nice to tell Stroud and Hawke to shut up in the fade. It is not the time for bickering.

 

Or the tangible frustration everytime he says: I don´t remember!

 

The Inquisitor is a believable protagonist.


  • berelinde, JaegerBane et Shechinah aiment ceci

#8
agonis

agonis
  • Members
  • 896 messages

You didn't have the extreme paragon / pschopath options but instead you got to add more nuance and individuality to a sane and realistic character than you probably ever did before. Maybe the Inquisitor is not as exciting as some of the past protagonists but Quizzy is nowhere near one dimensional.

One like is not enough.

 

Here take a few more.


  • Cecilia L aime ceci

#9
ThreeF

ThreeF
  • Members
  • 2 245 messages

I liked that for the most part I would play as one personality, there were brief moments of psychosis but other than that I've found inquisitor to be down to earth normal person. I didn't liked the extremes of Hawke's personalities, sarcastic Hawke  was funny, but I didn't want to play the character this personality dictated.


  • PlasmaCheese aime ceci

#10
Jawzzus

Jawzzus
  • Members
  • 2 399 messages

Yup



#11
lynroy

lynroy
  • Members
  • 24 526 messages

I´m not interested in playing a complete jerk which is why I enjoyed roleplaying the Inquisitor very much. The aggressive options are fine for me in certain situations. Evil stupid is not my alignment. I prefer diplomatic/sarcastic/manipulative which the Inquisitor manages just fine.

You didn't have the extreme paragon / pschopath options but instead you got to add more nuance and individuality to a sane and realistic character than you probably ever did before. Maybe the Inquisitor is not as exciting as some of the past protagonists but Quizzy is nowhere near one dimensional.

I rather liked the aggressive personality of the Inquisitor.

 

It was less renegade douchebag more no-nonsense pragmatist.

It is nice to tell Stroud and Hawke to shut up in the fade. It is not the time for bickering.

 

Or the tangible frustration everytime he says: I don´t remember!

 

The Inquisitor is a believable protagonist.

I liked that for the most part I would play as one personality, there were brief moment of psychosis but other than that I've found inquisitor to be down to earth normal person. I didn't liked the extremes of Hawke's personalities, sarcastic Hawke  was funny, but I didn't want to play the character this personality dictated.

tumblr_m43fmnEFfl1rqfhi2o1_400.gif

I'll have one of each of these replies.


  • Shechinah et leaguer of one aiment ceci

#12
PhroXenGold

PhroXenGold
  • Members
  • 1 840 messages

I liked the Inquisitor. At first she did seem a little bland, but I came to appreciate the more subtle nuances of them compared to some of Bioware's other PCs.

 

I still consider Hawke to be my favourite though - not so much because of the personalities, which, as ThreeF pointed out, get a little excessive at times, but because of the flawed human nature of him. He's not someone special, he's not the chosen one, he's just an ordinary man doing his best to muddle through extraordinary circumstances. That his best wasn't enough just adds to that feeling of realness. Sometimes, the day simply cannot be saved, no matter how hard you try. Hawke, more so than any other of Bioware's recent PC, felt like a real person, rather than an idealised hero. 


  • friffy, AEve1, TheChosenOne et 2 autres aiment ceci

#13
Phoe77

Phoe77
  • Members
  • 628 messages

I agree that the Inquisitor seems like an actual person rather than a trope or caricature.  I loved sarcastic and aggressive Hawke to bits (I've never played a Waffles), but there's no denying that the degree to which those attributes defined their personalities overshadow other aspects of the character.  I love that my Inquisitor can be commanding, manipulative, earnest, diplomatic, and humorous all in one character without it ever feeling like he's got multiple personalities.  


  • PlasmaCheese, Lebanese Dude, PCThug et 1 autre aiment ceci

#14
Guest_john_sheparrd_*

Guest_john_sheparrd_*
  • Guests

nope he sucked ass probably the worst Bioware protagonist to date

 

almost no RP options (like the warden) or any personality (like hawke)

bland and boring here is hoping Bioware will learn from their mistakes

 

sure it might be realistic etc. but who cares about that? Its a freaking roleplaying game give me options to be ruthless as hell

and sarcastic even though it may be extreme


  • KonguZya, DarkKnightHolmes, Hazegurl et 6 autres aiment ceci

#15
Majestic Jazz

Majestic Jazz
  • Members
  • 1 966 messages

nope he sucked ass probably the worst Bioware protagonist to date

 

almost no RP options (like the warden) or any personality (like hawke)

bland and boring here is hoping Bioware will learn from their mistakes

 

sure it might be realistic etc. but who cares about that? Its a freaking roleplaying game give me options to be ruthless as hell

and sarcastic even though it may be extreme

 

Exactly this

 

Its not like I wanted to be evil/no sense evil like Revan in KOTOR. I just wanted to rule the Inquisition with an iron fist. It seems like no matter what, you were always....diplomatic and bland. Even the harshes judgements and decisions felt as if the Inquisitor was holding back because of his "Herald" status. 

 

We won't be seeing videos like this for the Inquisitor.....

 

Hawke is a Jerk

 

Shepard is a Jerk

 

Inquisitor is Mr. Rogers compared to them


  • Konstantin, PlasmaCheese, KonguZya et 6 autres aiment ceci

#16
Cyonan

Cyonan
  • Members
  • 19 341 messages

I wouldn't say terribly interesting, but then I also don't find Revan, Shep, Hawke, or the Warden terribly interesting because they're all essentially blank slates.

 

Specifically with Revan and Shep I also had the issue where the game's morality feels very black and white most of the time, especially with Revan because Star Wars. You're either full blown sith and pretty much the worst person in the galaxy or full blown jedi and nice to a fault.

 

It would have been nice to have some middle ground. Choosing one dark side then one light side to keep yourself in the grey area just makes it seem like you have multiple personalities.



#17
Gothfather

Gothfather
  • Members
  • 1 400 messages

What are your thoughts how you enjoyed the Inquisitor's character?

To me he/she was boring compared to the many other Bioware characters such as Revan, Shepard, The Warden, and even Hawke. I think the Inquisitor is too 1-dimensional and is too diplomatic.

With Shepard and Hawke you can have jerks or saints as seen with the "Shepard is a jerk" type videos. With the Inquisitor I doubt you will see any such videos because the character does not have the same depth. Punching Solas was the most aggression I really saw in terms of conversations and dialog options. The Inquisitor is sort of like making Tim Duncan play a super hero for those who know who Tim Duncan is and the reference I am making.

This is contrast to the companions which are all rich in depth and personality. Even mute Warden and Revan had more excitement going for them.

What is your view on the Inquisitor?

 

This is a very binary way to look at character options. Diplomatic/Paragon Vs. Jerk/Renegade its simplistic and juvenile. Juvenile as in unsophisticated and overly simple. There is an incredible diversity in the Inquisitor but it is not along the the lines of nice or utter wanker. Yes there are limitations to how your character reacts to the world, just like Shepard was limited to binary choices in the ME series. You could not step outside this very narrow divide of all actions being pigeon holed into either Paragon or Renegade. Is Shepard a warrior poet? You can't really interact with the world based on this idea, Is Shepard a person of faith? Again you can't really react to the world based on that. You can headcanon all you want but you can't respond using those options.

 

The story requires that the Inquisitor be diplomatic because you are a fledgling quasi-religious quasi-military order. The inquisition is very much along the lines of the Buddhist Monks of Japan or the military monastic orders of Europe. In order to survive the Inquisitor can't have the character diversity be determined by how Diplomatic or how psychotic you choose to act. And this isn't the only way to make diverse characters. Your character needs to be someone deeply religious people will follow and someone who can work will other power structures within Thedas this precludes the ability to play a psychotic like Hawke or the warden could be because if you acted like this your own organization would arrest you. So no you don't get to choose to be an absolute prig. But you can choose many other different divergent character traits that can make for an interesting inquisitor that have nothing to do with binary morality.

 

With the inquisitor you can choose your diversity along the lines of Faith, how much do you believe in the Maker? Do you believe you are the herald? Was it providence as Cassandra says that delivered you into the hands of the only organization capable of sealing the breach? All of these Questions allow you to make very diverse characters with regards to FAITH.

 

How much of a hardliner are you? Will you be a traditionalist, reformer or a revolutionary with regards to the Mage question? Will you save the Templars but disband them? Will you save the mages but force them back into the circles? Who will you support as divine? Its not so important for you to answer these questions with the actions you take but more important to ask WHY you took these action in the first place these will very much determine the personality of your character again outside the narrow Realm of Just nice guy vs. mean guy.

 

Judgement seat

 

How do you dispense Justice? How do you punish the guilty? What steps do you take against those whom you have captured? Again there is a wide range of diverse actions that do not run along a rather narrow divide of this is a good/Paragon action and this is a bad/Renegade option. How you deal with these choice goes a great deal into how your personality can be shaped. Are you pragmatic and will use a tool to further the power of the Inquisition? Will your punish people knowing you could lose a potential tool? What punishments will you use? Will you show mercy? Or will you let all know if you cross the Inquisition your head will roll?

 

Will you be an Inquisitor who is scholarly? (aka invest in knowledge perks) Or will you trust in your own personal knowledge to see you through the challenges you face? Will you let your background dictate the direction you will follow or will you forge a new path separate from your heritage?

 

 

There are so many ways you can develop your character that have ZERO to do with the traditional binary morality that most games ham fistedly impose in games. I don't know what it says about gamers in general when they think they have no options for character development because they can't be a psycho.

 

The above said you may not like that you can't be a psycho but that is very different from not having any options for character development.


  • mfr001, sillymonkboy, agonis et 4 autres aiment ceci

#18
WildOrchid

WildOrchid
  • Members
  • 7 251 messages

I love my Adaar and Trevelyan.... though they weren't that interesting as Marian Hawke (or as i call her, the queen of snark) or Jane Shepard.

 

 

But definitely better and more interesting than my warden.


  • AlexiaRevan aime ceci

#19
berelinde

berelinde
  • Members
  • 8 282 messages

It is nice to tell Stroud and Hawke to shut up in the fade. It is not the time for bickering.

 

Or the tangible frustration everytime he says: I don´t remember!

 

The Inquisitor is a believable protagonist.

I liked - no, LOVED - how often I had the opportunity to tell people to stop bickering. I didn't always have to choose between supporting one person or the other. It was such a blessed relief to be able to tell both parties that they needed to calm their tatas. We're saving the world, people. We don't have time to deal with the drama.


  • mfr001, agonis, Shechinah et 3 autres aiment ceci

#20
ComedicSociopathy

ComedicSociopathy
  • Members
  • 1 951 messages

The Inquisitor didn't have the complexity of the Warden because of a lack of diverse options and was for the most part a generally benign character who couldn't be ridiculous vile or cruel. Still, I do prefer voiced over no voice and hope they add more options to the dialogue wheel in DA 4. 


  • Regan_Cousland aime ceci

#21
PlasmaCheese

PlasmaCheese
  • Members
  • 822 messages
Not really, no. Maybe it has something to do with how she sounds like she's giving a lecture majority of the time. Very flat, but I get the reasoning behind it. The reaction wheel is something I hope stays around for good, though. I liked it a lot.
  • AnhedonicDonkey aime ceci

#22
BabyPuncher

BabyPuncher
  • Members
  • 1 939 messages

Nope.



#23
DarkAmaranth1966

DarkAmaranth1966
  • Members
  • 3 263 messages

I didn't find my Elf, Human or Dwarf Quizzies as interesting as my Qunari. He ended up being my cannon. Females I found too unemotional. (No I'm not saying females are more emotional than males, just they generally display emotions more but female Quizzies don't.)



#24
s-jay2676

s-jay2676
  • Members
  • 160 messages

I think the Inquisitor is one of the most boring characters ever created. The most disapponting thing, however, is the missing chemistry between the Inquisitor and other NPCs.


  • Lee T, NoRmAnDy-SR2, Majestic Jazz et 7 autres aiment ceci

#25
Guest_john_sheparrd_*

Guest_john_sheparrd_*
  • Guests

Exactly this

 

Its not like I wanted to be evil/no sense evil like Revan in KOTOR. I just wanted to rule the Inquisition with an iron fist. It seems like no matter what, you were always....diplomatic and bland. Even the harshes judgements and decisions felt as if the Inquisitor was holding back because of his "Herald" status. 

 

We won't be seeing videos like this for the Inquisitor.....

 

Hawke is a Jerk

 

Shepard is a Jerk

 

Inquisitor is Mr. Rogers compared to them

agreed the Inquisitor was a wimp compared to other Bioware protagonists (Hawke, Shepard, The Warden)

I tried to be ruthless but I got the same bland and diplomatic responses

 

huge missed opportunity especially since the Inquisitor has so much power  (many interesting RP possibilities)

I remember people saying that Hawke was limited (he was human for one and also had personality) but in my opinion

the Inquisitor is by far the most limited Bioware protag so far

 

but hey at least the fans that were crazy about races got them right?

no because they are also just a half assed version of DA:O's races

 

thats the main problem with DA:I they tried to appeal to everyone and in the end the game itself is very shallow


  • Hazegurl et Elyunha aiment ceci