I don't play games with magic and swords and all kinds of sex. I only play games with space magic, space swords, and all kinds of space sex.
Actually, I ran the numbers, and if the DAI can slightly out-damage the GI with a normal BW setup (including debuffs from Recon Mine and Proxy Mine). Without the debuffs considered, the GI does slightly more damage... unless the Drell has Melee Synergy active, in which case, the GI can't keep up in any situation.
That is a theoretical calculation which has nothing to do with practice, though.
Since the GI doesn't have to wait anything for his debuff to work, while the DI needs to wait like, 3 seconds? That's an awfully huge difference. Plus, you didn't account for the damage done by PM, as the DI's debuff doesn't do damage at every cloak cycle, or if it does you lose the debuff and have to wait another whole 3 secs to get it again, not to mention that it completely messes with your cloak timing. So in practice, the GI is still superior.
Plus, you compared both of them with a BW. If you gave the GI a Javelin there wouldn't even be a contest.
Black Widow is like a four stars Hotel: consistently luxurious and awesome, but a Javelin headshot is like a 5 stars diamond luxury Hotel: an average guy can enjoy it only every once in a while but when it happens nothing can beat the sound of SQUILCH of a Javelin headshot.
****** well said.
Most satisfactory shots of my ME3 career were Javelin headsots.