You do realize that cultures across the world have home countries where the opposite is true? And most of those countries don't welcome people of other cultures at all? Do you know progressive Canada actually is? It's amazing.
Honestly, if you're an outsider to a majority culture, there's a minority effect. There are stereotypes and, sorry to say it, a lot of those stereotypes exist because people play into them... I mean look at rap culture, video after video of black people singing about killing police and dealing drugs... well, it is really a shock that an upper middle class white person who sees that crap daily and it's 90% of what they see about the culture then thinks "okay, maybe they deal drugs and run in gangs?".
I mean how many guys like Dr. Dre get filthy rich off that image? Love his music, love his headphones, serious doubts about how beneficial he's been to black culture in general. And then some well meaning hard working black kid applies for a job in that white person's office against 5 well meaning hard working white guys, whose that upper middle class white person going to hire based on a 10 minute interview? I mean forget America, what kind of message are guys like Dr Dre sending to the entire world?
And honestly, none of the characters in dragon age would be more engaging if they looked a bit more like I do or had different voice actors. They're great characters, and game of thrones has great characters (and I know for a fact my culture will never appear in that either... and it doesn't matter, because it's another culture's story). People should just let a writer share his or her vision, and judge it based on quality.
1) I realize there's the rest of the world out there, yeah.
And yes, of course other cultures exist. BUT, world being what it is, none of those cultures exist in a vacuum. And I don't think there's much dispute that English-speaking probably-mostly-US media and pop culture is widely distributed, consumed, and idolized.
Do those cultures turn the tables on white folks? I'm sure some do. But that can happen in spite of, or even because of, the prevalence of "Western" pop culture. As in, you see your kids obsessed with that damn American singer, maybe you cling to your own music and sneer at all Americans.
And no, it isn't always true that home-culture equals higher-prestige-culture. That talk about Nigerian kids' lit, earlier, right? Nigeria certainly has (possibly many) cultures of its own, BUT kids read about and then write about white people. Cosmetics shops in India sell skin-bleaching stuff, because whiteness equals beauty. Maybe it's more common in former colonies, I dunno. But it's there.
(Confession: In my experience, after a few weeks in brown-people-country, yeah, white people definitely stand out -- in a bumbling fish-out-of-water kind of way. I'll admit to some covert snickering on my part. I never said I was nice!)
2) No. The it's-their-own-fault thing? No. Again, culture doesn't crop up in a vacuum.





Retour en haut







