That depends on who's around you lady wise and what your mindset is for what you're hoping for.
Some women ooh and ahh at bigger muscles. They'll overlook other details as long as you have that.
Other women don't care for big muscles or a good core body and look for personality, charisma, behavior, mannerisms, etc etc.
Some women care more for elements that make a man "what" he is. Tall? Short? Muscular? Slim? Chubby? Ethnicity? Job? Funding?
Other women care more for elements that make a man "who" he is. Kind? Generous? Caring? Thoughtful? Open-minded? Brilliant? Focused? Determined?
People, men and women included, look for elements of both who and what someone is, though they'll naturally put more importance on some over others.
For example, if a woman is looking for a guy who's a gym nut that drinks protein shakes often, is constantly pushing the limits of his physical body, and has a good jawline, she might overlook that he's a complete tosser and douche bag to everyone outside of his immediate family.
Another woman could be looking for a guy who's a book reader, real quiet and introverted, not a people person, but very much a fantastic guy in a one on one relationship, not even noticing that he needs all the help in the world with some basics in life.
Thats one of the reasons I make a point physically, mentally, spiritually, and psychologically to be the best me that I can be for myself, those closest to me, and the people of the world.
You have to be mindful of how your partner will treat you.
You have to be mindful of how your partner will treat others.
You have to be mindful of how your partner will treat the world.
As those are big and important ways of understanding the person you're connecting or not connecting with.
Too many people get swayed by the charismatic jackass who plays nice to them but treats everyone and everything else, sometimes even them like garbage.
Other people pursue the good guy who's actually a good guy but is incapable of performing some usual tasks and needs some help getting better at performing them.
Its all down to each individual's perceptions, opinions, wants, desires, and life experiences.
I know that no matter what I do, I won't win over everyone. But thats not the point;I have to win over myself first, making sure to stay humble and kind, happy and committed, willing to share positive energy with others. You don't need the biggest arms, the fastest legs, the most expensive college degree, or a million dollar job to do that,
You just need to try being the best you that you can be. Follow that, and the rest will fill in itself. May not be today or tomorrow, may not be in the next year or decade, but being pretty good at being you is a hell of a way to start.