Aller au contenu

Photo

Smaller scale next time, please.


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
33 réponses à ce sujet

#26
JosieRevisited

JosieRevisited
  • Members
  • 111 messages

The biggest problem with the game isn't its size, it's the linear path you have to take to advance the story. When it's blocked out the way it is, you get sick of places like the hinterlands. There isn't any true open world exploration because half the world is gated behind story. 

 

Dump that whole idea, make it a true open world, and maybe there will be less complaints. Skyrim quests weren't all that much better when you picked them apart, but the world wasn't closed off to your character so you didn't even notice. 



#27
Zeratulr

Zeratulr
  • Members
  • 60 messages

With the exception of Haven, Coryfishstick's temporary successes are only due to his victims being even more incompetent (Templars using red lyrium, mages siding with Tevinter, grey wardens siding with Tevinter). Even in those cases, he is thwarted at every turn, and in the end, he delivers himself to the Inquisitor's doorstep with almost no backup.

Grey wardens were not incompetent. Neither were templars and mages. Warden heard the calling and believed that they all had to start a long walk (one of their most important and sacred traditions) which meant the world would be defenceless when the next blight come. That made them open to cooperation with whoever was ready to offer help. Mages and templars fell victims to the fact that they spent all their lives in mutual distrust and fear. Corypheus used a deep understanding of how his enemies think to devise very smart plans to make them submit to his will. Compare it to Archdemon who only used darkspawns who had no other choice but to follow his orders and never made a single attempt to use any tactics other than "go forward, kill everyone you see".

 

 

Also, the Archdemon never showed up at Ostagar. Even if it lost that battle, it would have left the enemy forces devastated and demoralized, while it's own forces could, as far as we know, be easily replenished.

So he is competent because his forces are virtually infinite and he can waste them without any regard for efficiency or military strategy? What was the point of attacking Denerim, very defensible fortress before defeating separated enemy forces anyway?

 

 

Finally, you neglect the fact that Loghain and his supporters are also antagonists, and Loghain is a morally grey villain, while Coryfishstick is obviously evil.
 

He wanted power and he didn't care about anything else. How is he morally grey?



#28
9TailsFox

9TailsFox
  • Members
  • 3 715 messages

He wanted power and he didn't care about anything else. How is he morally grey?

He care about his daughter. And Cailan was fool. And you so sure they win battle with Loghain army? And tell me few more games where you can recruit main antagonist  as companion.



#29
Koneko Koji

Koneko Koji
  • Members
  • 265 messages

 

He wanted power and he didn't care about anything else. How is he morally grey?

 

Although I dislike Logain, I can see how he is a grey area character - he firmly believed that families like the Couslands were being influenced by Orlesians, then you have Arl Eamon having married one - and he's uncle to Cailan, who intended on having the Orlesian Wardens join them at Ostagar. We must remember that Logain spent his youth in a brutally occupied Fereldan, and fought alongside Maric to remove the Orlesians from the land - his 'concern' (to put it lightly) that they would take back Fereldan was the driving force behind his push for power - in a twisted, self-justifying way - he was doing what he thought was right for the country.

However, his actions and those of power-mongers like Howe are morally questionable if one does not agree with him, and the way his ends justified his means.

 


  • 9TailsFox aime ceci

#30
JosieRevisited

JosieRevisited
  • Members
  • 111 messages

The Grey Wardens absolutely were incompetent if they didn't all realize that getting the "call" at the same time was fishy. They were even stupider for taking the convenient 'help' that was offered - they seriously thought that carving one another up as sacrifices for blood magic was a great idea? By the end of Inquisition I was pretty sick of the Grey Wardens. 



#31
Koneko Koji

Koneko Koji
  • Members
  • 265 messages

The Grey Wardens absolutely were incompetent if they didn't all realize that getting the "call" at the same time was fishy. They were even stupider for taking the convenient 'help' that was offered. By the end of Inquisition I was pretty sick of the Grey Wardens. 

 

This was something that didn't sit well with me - they took an order that I liked and respected, and turned it into an utter joke and a pathetic mockery of its self. I mean just on a basic level, the idea of reaching an untainted Old God and slaying it, aside from the Darkspawn threat, is totally impossible - ALL Wardens are TAINTED with the BLIGHT ... as soon as they approach the dragon it would become an Arch Demon and trigger the next blight.


  • 9TailsFox aime ceci

#32
Saphiron123

Saphiron123
  • Members
  • 1 497 messages

People did, yes. I didn't. I've never really thought exploration was necessary in an RPG myself.

I like exploration, but story matters more, dialogue matters more... give me some of each, rather then big empty environments that simply don't matter.



#33
ichbintot

ichbintot
  • Members
  • 26 messages
I don't think it was large enough... Skyrim has really spoiled me as far as game world size goes.

#34
eyezonlyii

eyezonlyii
  • Members
  • 1 715 messages

This was something that didn't sit well with me - they took an order that I liked and respected, and turned it into an utter joke and a pathetic mockery of its self. I mean just on a basic level, the idea of reaching an untainted Old God and slaying it, aside from the Darkspawn threat, is totally impossible - ALL Wardens are TAINTED with the BLIGHT ... as soon as they approach the dragon it would become an Arch Demon and trigger the next blight.

The same thing happened with ME's Cerberus. Well...kind of. They started off as a rogue Alliance Black ops division in the first game, then became a "humanity centered Council defying (not)terrorist organization. And finally the red templars (using Reaper indoctrinating technology on themselves) of the ME Universe. So really not the first time this has happened.