Aller au contenu

Photo

Pillars of Eternity did better than Inquisition on metacritic


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
53 réponses à ce sujet

#26
mousestalker

mousestalker
  • Members
  • 16 945 messages

Pillars of Eternity is the bestest game ever! One of our cats had scrofula and she lept onto the keyboard during game play and was cured instantly. My cousin's husband's bald dentist was playing PoE and regrew all of his hair! Our niece's teacher was so impressed by her game play that our niece graduated high honours on the spot!

 

Fact.


  • Hiemoth, Heimdall, TheRealJayDee et 9 autres aiment ceci

#27
wolfsite

wolfsite
  • Members
  • 5 780 messages

Any of these areas, perhaps? :P

http://blog.estately...es-for-hippies/

 

No, I just grew up in a small town.



#28
Farangbaa

Farangbaa
  • Members
  • 6 757 messages

Pillars of Eternity is the bestest game ever! One of our cats had scrofula and she lept onto the keyboard during game play and was cured instantly. My cousin's husband's bald dentist was playing PoE and regrew all of his hair! Our niece's teacher was so impressed by her game play that our niece graduated summa ****** laude on the spot!
 
Fact.


Hilarious obscenity filter.

#29
Althix

Althix
  • Members
  • 2 524 messages

in the DAO during first 30 minutes you learn about the world, you also may manage to decide destiny of several characters with a possible outcry in the future, experience sense of defeat, betrayal and loss.

 

in DAI you climb a god damned mountain for 40 minutes...

 

and PoE is just a better game than DAI. Just like DOS is.

 

it's because DAI is a trash game.



#30
Giorgio Tsoukalos

Giorgio Tsoukalos
  • Members
  • 69 messages

Pillars of Eternity is the bestest game ever! One of our cats had scrofula and she lept onto the keyboard during game play and was cured instantly. My cousin's husband's bald dentist was playing PoE and regrew all of his hair! Our niece's teacher was so impressed by her game play that our niece graduated high honours on the spot!

 

Fact.

 

"It cures baldness."

 

I'd put that on the box tbh.



#31
mikeymoonshine

mikeymoonshine
  • Members
  • 3 493 messages

I don't think I really even care which game is better, both are doing completely different things. I wouldn't want to lose either. XD 


  • Lethaya aime ceci

#32
DarkKnightHolmes

DarkKnightHolmes
  • Members
  • 3 605 messages

Not that metacritic matters but 2014 was a horrible year for gaming. Buggy big games everywhere.


  • Teddie Sage aime ceci

#33
Seival

Seival
  • Members
  • 5 294 messages

Metacritic is not a good source of users' reaction on a game. Couple of thousands votes per game is nothing. I prefer to trust some more reliable sources, for example PSN users' likes and ratings on PSN itself.


  • Heimdall et jeromefiefdom aiment ceci

#34
Kaiser Arian XVII

Kaiser Arian XVII
  • Members
  • 17 286 messages

Metacritic user rating tells that Civilization: Beyond Space, Borderlands: The Presequel and The latest Call of Duty were mediocre.

 

It was true.

 

Another reason not to dismiss Metacritic.



#35
The Hierophant

The Hierophant
  • Members
  • 6 932 messages

Metacritic is not a good source of users' reaction on a game. Couple of thousands votes per game is nothing. I prefer to trust some more reliable sources, for example PSN users' likes and ratings on PSN itself.

Oh ****? You're still alive!

 

Yes.


  • Dermain aime ceci

#36
Cyonan

Cyonan
  • Members
  • 19 373 messages

lol Metacritic.

 

Then again I've played both games so the only opinion that actually matters to me in deciding which game I think is better is my own.

 

Plus Dragon Age saw a pretty significant change in the style of the game since Origins so quality of Inquisition aside, it probably pissed off a lot more people than PoE did.



#37
Br3admax

Br3admax
  • Members
  • 12 316 messages

in the DAO during first 30 minutes you learn about the world, you also may manage to decide destiny of several characters with a possible outcry in the future, experience sense of defeat, betrayal and loss.

 

in DAI you climb a god damned mountain for 40 minutes...

 

and PoE is just a better game than DAI. Just like DOS is.

 

it's because DAI is a trash game.

You're telling me the first game in a series introduces the world to you, while the one that takes an hour just to set the world up before you playing, while also being the third game in the series doesn't? Wow. And you can't decide the fate of anyone. Except for one person in one origin. 

 

I haven't played DA:I since December, and even I find that kind of logic asinine. 

 

PoE is also better than DA:O. Mostly for the same reasons it's better than DA:I. 


  • jeromefiefdom et blahblahblah aiment ceci

#38
AventuroLegendary

AventuroLegendary
  • Members
  • 7 146 messages

Ocarina of Time has a 99, therefore it's objectively better than anything 'cause a bunch of enlightened critics said so.

 

Gah, I hate number rating scales...


  • Teddie Sage et jeromefiefdom aiment ceci

#39
Guest_TrillClinton_*

Guest_TrillClinton_*
  • Guests

Metacritic is broken. The uses reviews are a clusterfuck


  • Alan Rickman, Teddie Sage, jeromefiefdom et 1 autre aiment ceci

#40
jeromefiefdom

jeromefiefdom
  • Members
  • 298 messages

I realized there is Metascore for actresses too!

 

http://www.metacriti...helle-rodriguez

 

BTW, if that Majority say this is a great game, then it is a great game:

 

http://www.metacriti...cities-skylines

 

Yeah, but they said Bioshock Infinite and GTAV were great games, while saying Alpha Protocol and Pathologic were terrible ones



#41
Kaiser Arian XVII

Kaiser Arian XVII
  • Members
  • 17 286 messages

Metacritic is broken. The uses reviews are a clusterfuck

 

I know, right?

But the conclusive score is kinda trust-able.

 

For example

 

Cities XXL

 

is a remake of Cities XL, which is no good. The user rating is 1.5 which is too sad, but it shows how disappointing the game is.

 

On the contrary there is

 

 

 
Both Critic score and User scores are around 9/10 which means it is quite innovative, brilliant and well done.

 

You should have the art of interpretation of ratings!

 

 

Yeah, but they said Bioshock Infinite and GTAV were great games, while saying Alpha Protocol and Pathologic were terrible ones

 

I don't waste my time on exceptions.



#42
jeromefiefdom

jeromefiefdom
  • Members
  • 298 messages

 

 

I don't waste my time on exceptions.

 

I could say the very same thing.



#43
jeromefiefdom

jeromefiefdom
  • Members
  • 298 messages

Ocarina of Time has a 99, therefore it's objectively better than anything 'cause a bunch of enlightened critics said so.

 

Gah, I hate number rating scales...

 

 Im personally a fan of the Jack the Ripper rating scale. IE: Apolypse Now is 12 dead prostitutes, while AMerican sniper is two dead prostitutes



#44
TheRealJayDee

TheRealJayDee
  • Members
  • 2 950 messages

And second of all this game is beeing idolized because of nostalgia goggles, don't get me wrong it is a great game. But lets not get carried away on all fronts just because it triggered some good childhood memories. 

Well, I tried playing both Baldur's Gate games around release and didn't make it even an hour into either of them. I retried playing them again and again over the years, the last try being made about two years ago after I bought them on GOG. I made it a little further, but not much. That was about when I also tried Planescape: Torment for the first time, which I finished after a rather excessive playthrough and loved.

 

I'm now about 15 hours into PoE, and I'm enjoying it immensly. Do I think it's the bestest ever? No, but I still don't find too many things I dislike. No nostalgia and no childhood memories involved.


  • Akrabra, Dermain, Il Divo et 2 autres aiment ceci

#45
Cyonan

Cyonan
  • Members
  • 19 373 messages

I know, right?

But the conclusive score is kinda trust-able.

 

For example

 

Cities XXL

 

is a remake of Cities XL, which is no good. The user rating is 1.5 which is too sad, but it shows how disappointing the game is.

 

On the contrary there is

 

 

 
Both Critic score and User scores are around 9/10 which means it is quite innovative, brilliant and well done.

 

You should have the art of interpretation of ratings!

 

And every once in a while you get an Out of the Park Baseball 2007 on PC with a critic rating of 96 and a user rating of 2.6



#46
Degenerate Rakia Time

Degenerate Rakia Time
  • Banned
  • 5 073 messages

And every once in a while you get an Out of the Park Baseball 2007 on PC with a critic rating of 96 and a user rating of 2.6

so people hate baseball?



#47
Teddie Sage

Teddie Sage
  • Members
  • 6 754 messages

Superman 64 could have a score of 100%, I still wouldn't like the game or consider it the best video game ever. Also, this game is for PC only while Inquisition is more accessible on multiple platforms, which explains why it got so many different scores everywhere. I don't know what the actual sales numbers are for PoE and I personally don't care. What matters is what you enjoy, the score is just superficial. If you like the game, good. I guess one of the few people who's tired with scores to describe something. The value of a video game shouldn't be measured with a score in my strict opinion. You either like it or you don't.  :huh:


  • Akrabra, Dermain, BigEvil et 1 autre aiment ceci

#48
bEVEsthda

bEVEsthda
  • Members
  • 3 612 messages

If the Metacritic helps selling the game to the right persons, then all the power to it.

 

I enjoy both DAI and PoE immensely. Though they have the same sort of roots, they are rather different today. But both are very good games, and both could be better.

 

As for Metacritic, no it's not worthless. You can understand the scores.

But the scores are not comparable between games.

The thing is, that those who purchased PoE, first knew what they were buying, secondly weren't disappointed.  On the contrary, they were delighted. And every time that happens, the game gets great ratings. Not so strange, really. If you think about it.

 

The case of DA:I is more multifaceted. No one knew exactly what they were buying. And despite the fact that DA:I follows DA2, rather than DA:O, a lot of people want to punish DA:I for what it's not, rather than judge what it is. That pulls down the score.

 

Overall, I have to say that DA:I is fairly the better game. Thing is, though, PoE excels in the design of those parts that DA:I wants to gloss over.

 

Two great games. But at the same time also two sad examples of that the RPG genre really haven't evolved since BG. Not in its own right.

That's really the thing, RPG-specific gameplay and content haven't moved forward. At all.


  • Dermain aime ceci

#49
Althix

Althix
  • Members
  • 2 524 messages

You're telling me

then i suggest you to replay... let say dwarven origin. good example when your character can - kill a guy(or not to), have threesome, kick some ass in the arena, make an example of bad politic, being accused in a murder and escape.

 

all of that in just one origin, first 30 minutes.

 

when in DAI your character is surrounded by people with IQ bellow 80, enduring a conversation with some priest (badly written conversation by the way), you as player will also suffer from horrible animation of the characters at the same time. and you also should travel to the mountain top in order to close some portal because you are the chosen one(!111). amazing.

 

killing few demons here and there, closing minor portals. for 40 minutes. even Varric can't save you from this amount of facepalms.

And this trash is GOTY. And this is just first 40 minutes, when the best part is ahead of you. And by that i mean fetch quests, boring main quest line.

 

I had this feeling that DAI was supposed to be a MMO game. But EA become aware of the TESO's failure, and they turned MMO game into SP game.



#50
Lukas Trevelyan

Lukas Trevelyan
  • Members
  • 2 238 messages
^ dat hyperbole.

On a more serious note the origins quests in DAO were arguably the best part, whereas DAI starts rather slow. DAI did main quests much better imho. Not only does your choice of Templar vs Mage give you two different outcomes (pretty significant too) but the main quests themselves design wise are excellent. The areas are spacious but not daunting, there is fun combat but not execesive, there are less moments to make a choice, but there are more options that are morally grey and lead to again significant differences. Also each quest gives you a unique experience, whether it's the Templar vs Mage showing you a darker future for the inquisition in their own different ways, In Your Heart Shall Burn which is centered around your Inquisitors rise to power, Here Lies The Abyss that show a completely different side of the wardens as well as centering around your army assaulting the wardens, Then The Winter Palace which is largely a political quest that reveals a bunch about how corrupt Orlais's leadership is, in addition it allows you to practice the game and rewards you if you successfully do it, and finally the Arbor Wilds -> temple Of Mythal that was one massive lore gasm.

All in all DAI plot, role playing opportunities and choices are present and pretty well crafted, anything else regarding that is subjective. It's real issues lies in a creating a larger world, without expanding and adding more meaningful side quests(they aren't completely absent though).
  • Akrabra, Dermain, bEVEsthda et 2 autres aiment ceci