Aller au contenu

Photo

How would you say David Gaider's story in the games, compares to his story writing in his books?( I Never read any of his books)


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
31 réponses à ce sujet

#26
BabyPuncher

BabyPuncher
  • Members
  • 1 939 messages

Actually, I say its the opposite. DG loves all those groups. Through hardship, suffering, and personal flaws, a writer makes a group interesting. If there are no conflicts involved with a group then readers/players won't be interested in them. Its all about that drama.

 

Not quite. That's only half of it.

 

You also need a resolution. Without a resolution, it's all just pointless nonsense.

 

There seem to be an awful lot of writers who don't focus on that as much they need to.



#27
AresKeith

AresKeith
  • Members
  • 34 128 messages

Not quite. That's only half of it.

 

You also need a resolution. Without a resolution, it's all just pointless nonsense.

 

There seem to be an awful lot of writers who don't focus on that as much they need to.

 

You're a writing expert now David?


  • Lukas Trevelyan aime ceci

#28
themageguy

themageguy
  • Members
  • 3 176 messages
I enjoy his writing and his books.

He is writing another novel which will feature Fenris :)
  • Aren aime ceci

#29
Carmen_Willow

Carmen_Willow
  • Members
  • 1 637 messages

I think David is at his best writing male characters for the game. It is my understanding that he wrote Alistair, Fenris and Nathaniel, my three favorite guys, and he did a great job on each of them.

 

His books are enjoyable and they certainly add to the lore, but he really shines in male characterization.



#30
Aren

Aren
  • Members
  • 3 491 messages

I enjoy his writing and his books.

He is writing another novel which will feature Fenris :)

I usually do not read DA books and comics,but for Fenris i will gladly make an exception.



#31
VelvetV

VelvetV
  • Members
  • 263 messages

I read two of the books (The Calling and Asunder) to get more insight into characters, but the books didn't do much for me. I liked the same characters in the games a lot, a lot better. So I'd say I greatly prefer the in-game writing to novels (provided he was the one who adapted his characters for the games, that is).

 

I also have a problem with how both novels were structured. They felt more like written games than novels: a party going on a quest somewhere far, needless description of details of their journey, random fights along the way that don't matter to its plot, etc. And I didn't really like any characters while reading, apart from Shale in Asunder, but that's because of amusement factor.

 

Don't let that deter you from reading. These are highly subjective opinions.


  • Heimdall aime ceci

#32
Panda

Panda
  • Members
  • 7 456 messages

I think his writing is pretty similar to games, in parts he wrote games like some characters and quest lines. I like his writing little more than Weekes, I like his characters more and Weekes english is heavier to read.