Not to interrupt the echo chamber that everyone had built up here so beautifully, but the idea that there's any meaningful social commentary coming out of any side of this is laughable.
There's no meaningful intellectual discourse. On one side, we have a a group of people advancing some simple ideas connecting with gender equality that are mostly truisms without the academic background to really put together a critique. And on the other hand you've got a bunch of largely ignorant gamers whose grasp of even those basic criticism are beyond them, and their address of any social issue is almost an embarrassment to the idea.
Then we have the trolls, of course, and the fact that gamersgate has managed to become populated with such a virulent pack of openly mysoginistic trolls that the entire label is DOA. And I'm not talking about the meaningless rhetoric: I mean the deluge of death and rape threats.
All I know is that watching everyone play hot potato with the toxic new gamer audience has been hilarious. "You guys take the tumblr rageoholics!" "Oh yeah, well you guys get to have the MLG pro crowd"
Meanwhile, what little credibility or relevencne games journalism, or many online news media in general, continues to go right down the drain. They were a joke and punchline before ((Anyobody remember slowpoke kotaku?)), and now that a call for them to get their **** together led to them proclaiming every gamer as dead and anyone who uses the term gamer a sexist pig, they've become a no-doubt laughing stock of everyone.
Forums, imo, killed review sites. Why would I read an article by someone who doesn't even finish the game and can't go 5 sentences without bringing up "muh social issues" and then bans everyone from commenting when I can get an in depth analysis of story, gameplay, and game mechanics, by an entire group of people, and see the counter points raised and discourse unfold, in real time, for free?