@the eternal question "but why do people have to be pretty"...
Which do you prefer having as the main plant in your garden? (SFW, just spoilered because of size)
Same with games. I mean obviously there are people who love the looks of the first plant, but at least as many people will prefer the second. A lot will want to mix it up a little, but still gravitate towards the second rather than the first.
In very simple words:
People (if I dare make that generalisation, I know it's tricky) like to look at things they perceive as pretty.
This does not mean that "everybody has to look like a supermodel" (the common strawman around here), but simply that some seriously beautiful/handsome characters would be appreciated. This includes both male and female sexes.
DA:I to me seems like
Sure, it's nice. Actually I personally like it quite a bit. But... it's a bit bland tbh. A bit boring, if that's all there is. I'd like a prettier flower in there somewhere.
Also @male standards: Actually I was surprised to find how specific the 'type' of some of you ladies is. Now speaking for myself again only, I don't have any rigid 'type' at all. Short hair, long hair, blonde, dark, red-haired, blue-eyed, dark-eyed, green-eyed, cute nose, classic nose... it's in the combination really, they can all do it for me (again, as long as the contents fits the box, so to speak, so character, (I agree!) voice, movement, etc). I wonder if the statements "... so I don't really care about looks as much as about character" and "... I don't really care as long as the whole is attractive" aren't more closely related than they might seem at first...