Duncan recruits you because you have potential and yes some skill. You played a very different game from me, and I played it less than a month ago. I was also anything but badass with my standard iron sword fighting darkspawn in the tower.
You might hate being "shoehorned" into being a warden, but replay the origins, my character was barely an adult and this was his first real battle.
You and I will never agree, so it's best we not talk about it. Feel free to go fight the archdemon without levelling your characters, and if you win, we can talk about how the warden started off as a badass.
Yep at the end of the day of course the Warden is also the hero that saves the world (and if done well there is nothing wrong with it) but the path to being a hero feels earned contrary to the Inquisitor
The latter just gets a special mark and is suddenly the leader of the Inquisition
He/she gets all the resources at once, even after their first main base is destroyed they just go around for a few hours and find a new much better one that is a upgrade in every way possibly
Everyone kisses your ass from the start (minus the first few minutes), its just silly especially considering how much power the Inquisitor has after sooo little time
The Inquisition at the end of the game apparently has influence over entire countries and what not and I was just like : C'mon Really?
Compare that to the hardworking Warden who got a rather sad Origin story in most cases, then in Ostagar they got their asses kicked even harder
Its just you and Alistair from there on, it feels like the beginning of a hard Journey, you find more companions as time passes to join your cause and of course more allies through the Warden treaties
Compare again with the Inquisitor who just owns Cory at every turn without much resistance and the last battle just reflects this (lamest end mission ever), that why I felt no connection with my companions in DA:I, they were never needed the Inquisitor already had a big army
DA:I overall is an exaggerated power fantasy and a clear result from the whining of DA2 haters who wanted more "power" and control
God I miss DA:O, time to replay it again I guess