15839 réponses à ce sujet

[nfi42]

What do you mean, it's eating itself? (I haven't yet ventured over to that side of the forums as of yet).

 

 

I erred in participating.    I feel dirty.

[slimgrin]

So I found the sword as I was wondering the countryside. Got it from a certain lady in a lake. Very cool nod to TW1. As I was chilling in my villa I thought how cool would it be if Ciri was still hanging around, as I hadn't seen her for a couple days. Literally right then she waked in the door and went up to bed.

 

*mind blown*

[nfi42]

So I found the sword as I was wondering the countryside. Got it from a certain lady in a lake. Very cool nod to TW1. As I was chilling in my villa I thought how cool would it be if Ciri was still hanging around, as I hadn't seen her for a couple days. Literally right then she waked in the door and went up to bed.

 

*mind blown*

 

 

This game delivers!

[panzerwzh]

So I found the sword as I was wondering the countryside. Got it from a certain lady in a lake. Very cool nod to TW1. As I was chilling in my villa I thought how cool would it be if Ciri was still hanging around, as I hadn't seen her for a couple days. Literally right then she waked in the door and went up to bed.

 

*mind blown*

And Da music reminds me every second I spent in TW1!

[panzerwzh]

A good example of the current status in MEA forum:

http://forum.bioware...fect-andromeda/

[panzerwzh]

Nuff said...

[Onecrazymonkey1]

That just brings back the memories. Great now I'm sad again, I hate letting good things go.

 

Anyway, I don't know if anyone has seen these figurines but they were news to me and I thought they looked really good, especially for the price. I definitely want to try and snag all of them.

 

http://www.tfaw.com/...Geralt___501736

 

http://www.tfaw.com/...:-Ciri___503882

 

http://www.tfaw.com/...nnefer___503884

 

http://www.tfaw.com/...-Triss___501737

 

http://www.tfaw.com/...Eredin___503883

 

Also, can someone give their opinion about kicking Sarah the godling out of the house. In my previous game I let her stay but after finding out that she meets johnny later if you kick her out.... I honestly think that's better and safer for her. I just feel like a scumbag doing it and I'm at that point again and can't decide. Also does anyone believe that Geralt would help kill the witcher Karadin? I usually like to let him live but I'm trying to stay in character right now and feel confused.

 

I wanted to make a perfect save and now I think I'm over thinking everything.

[FKA_Servo]

A good example of the current status in MEA forum:
http://forum.bioware...fect-andromeda/

Well, you chose the most transparent troll on the whole forum. But I guess in the end, it's still an accurate characterization of the MEA forum.

[panzerwzh]

Well, you chose the most transparent troll on the whole forum. But I guess in the end, it's still an accurate characterization of the MEA forum.

In the end, it turned out to be a meaningful discussion.

[nfi42]

 

Also, can someone give their opinion about kicking Sarah the godling out of the house. In my previous game I let her stay but after finding out that she meets johnny later if you kick her out.... I honestly think that's better and safer for her. I just feel like a scumbag doing it and I'm at that point again and can't decide. Also does anyone believe that Geralt would help kill the witcher Karadin? I usually like to let him live but I'm trying to stay in character right now and feel confused.

 

I wanted to make a perfect save and now I think I'm over thinking everything.

 

 

You feel bad when you kick her out, but you feel real good when you see her with Johnny. I do it 50/50 in my playthroughs.

 

there is evidence both for Jad  Karadin having reformed, and still trading in slaves.  What is clear is that in the past, he did bad things. Even if you do decide to kill him,  how will that impact the adopted kids.  Another grey area.

 

I kill him most of the time anyway because it's what Lambert wants and it's the 14th century.

[Onecrazymonkey1]

You feel bad when you kick her out, but you feel real good when you see her with Johnny. I do it 50/50 in my playthroughs.

 

there is evidence both for Jad  Karadin having reformed, and still trading in slaves.  What is clear is that in the past, he did bad things. Even if you do decide to kill him,  how will that impact the adopted kids.  Another grey area.

 

I kill him most of the time anyway because it's what Lambert wants and it's the 14th century.

 

Yeah, I think I'll kick her out this time just for something different and so Johnny wont be alone. I still have to wait a bit on Karadin to decide; I've been avoiding it like the plague because it's such a difficult decision for me, mainly for the kids.

 

Thanks for helping me out though. I can literally sit staring at the screen for ten to twenty minutes trying to decide on what to pick.

[Hazegurl]

 

Also, can someone give their opinion about kicking Sarah the godling out of the house. In my previous game I let her stay but after finding out that she meets johnny later if you kick her out.... I honestly think that's better and safer for her. I just feel like a scumbag doing it and I'm at that point again and can't decide. Also does anyone believe that Geralt would help kill the witcher Karadin? I usually like to let him live but I'm trying to stay in character right now and feel confused.

 

I wanted to make a perfect save and now I think I'm over thinking everything.

I hate kicking her out and she seems really happy with Corinne so I opt to let her stay. I had no idea she could meet Johnny and it seems like kicking her out would be for the best, if she gets away from humans and meets another Godling, but it would also be metagaming for me as I have no in game proof this is true until after I drive her away....darn it! lol!

 

 

As for Karadin. I always roleplay Geralt as being loyal to Witchers over everyone else except his friends and Triss.  That's why he kept Letho alive and told him to go to Kear Morhan.  However, Karadin was a Witcher who aided in taking another Witcher's life and didn't seem to have the same loyalty as Geralt. This choice took a long time to decide until I came to the conclusion that I didn't feel it was Geralt's place to tell Lambert what to do in this situation. If these people were responsible for the death of Dandelion, Zoltan, Ciri, Triss, or Yen, et al would my Geralt listen to someone telling them how much that person has changed? No. If it were me, I would kill them Witcher or not. So I opted to say I didn't care and Lambert said "F*ck your new life." and that was all the incentive I needed to let Lambert kill him.  However, I didn't hit him, I just used Aard on him and let Lambert kill him. lol! 

[panzerwzh]

How to determine the lesser evil? Judging by the grain of truth, the question of price or the voice of reason?

 

After all, what is witcher's tale without a little sacrifice?

[Onecrazymonkey1]

I hate kicking her out and she seems really happy with Corinne so I opt to let her stay. I had no idea she could meet Johnny and it seems like kicking her out would be for the best, if she gets away from humans and meets another Godling, but it would also be metagaming for me as I have no in game proof this is true until after I drive her away....darn it! lol!

 

 

As for Karadin. I always roleplay Geralt as being loyal to Witchers over everyone else except his friends and Triss.  That's why he kept Letho alive and told him to go to Kear Morhan.  However, Karadin was a Witcher who aided in taking another Witcher's life and didn't seem to have the same loyalty as Geralt. This choice took a long time to decide until I came to the conclusion that I didn't feel it was Geralt's place to tell Lambert what to do in this situation. If these people were responsible for the death of Dandelion, Zoltan, Ciri, Triss, or Yen, et al would my Geralt listen to someone telling them how much that person has changed? No. If it were me, I would kill them Witcher or not. So I opted to say I didn't care and Lambert said "F*ck your new life." and that was all the incentive I needed to let Lambert kill him.  However, I didn't hit him, I just used Aard on him and let Lambert kill him. lol! 

 

 

I know! I hate meta gaming and I'm sorry for spoiling it for you. However I'm just going to justify it by Geralt thinking that she needs to get out of the city quick to get away from witch hunters and he doesn't really know that she'll end up being happy with Corinne I guess.

 

I thought Karadin didn't mean for the other witcher to die though? maybe I'm a dupe. The bolded sounds pretty good, I just might try it that way so I don't feel half so bad lol. I am on deathmarch for the first time, so i wonder if that will be possible for me. I feel like I'm playing dark souls or something; not that I beat dark souls, I kind of gave up on that. :/

[nfi42]

Yeah, I think I'll kick her out this time just for something different and so Johnny wont be alone. I still have to wait a bit on Karadin to decide; I've been avoiding it like the plague because it's such a difficult decision for me, mainly for the kids.

 

Thanks for helping me out though. I can literally sit staring at the screen for ten to twenty minutes trying to decide on what to pick.

 

to be honest, i feel the Jan Karadin quest a harder choice than killing or freeing the tree spirit.  Do I let kids or the Bloody Baron die.  I free the spirit so the kids live.  They are innocent,  despite getting to know the baron,  he was a drunken ass who beat his wife and Anna was a cuckolding shrew who drove the Baron to drink.  It's also  the Barons choice to die, not Geralts.

[nfi42]

 

 

I thought Karadin didn't mean for the other witcher to die though? maybe I'm a dupe. The bolded sounds pretty good though, I just might try it that way so I don't feel half so bad lol. I am on deathmarch for the first time though, so i wonder if that will be possible for me. I feel like I'm playing dark souls or something; not that I beat dark souls, I kind of gave up on that. :/

 

So he says. Even if it's true he was a hired assassin and slave trader in his past.

 

 

I also don't like the way he speaks.

 

Death March is not that hard, the only really difficult battle is the one with the specters in the luberkin quest.  After that, the game gets progressively easier just like the lower difficulty levels.

[Onecrazymonkey1]

to be honest, i feel the Jan Karadin quest a harder chose than killing or freeing the tree spirit.  Do I let kids or the Bloody Baron die.  I free the spirit so the kids live.  They are innocent,  despite getting to know the baron,  he was a drunken ass who beat his wife and Anna was a cuckolding shrew who drove the Baron to drink.  It's also  the Barons choice to die, not Geralts.

 

I have no disagreement with you there, even though I felt sympathy for both Baron and Anna every now and then; albeit unnervingly. Actually this is one of the few quests where I was disappointed with the outcome, because I would have liked to find the kids somewhere, anywhere, safe and sound. Now I just head cannon that those kids I find starving in the shack are them.

 

Witcher 3 seems actually seems to be one of the few games that make kids adorable and not obnoxious in my opinion. If they were skyrim children I probably would have let the crones eat them.

[panzerwzh]

to be honest, i feel the Jan Karadin quest a harder chose than killing or freeing the tree spirit.  Do I let kids or the Bloody Baron die.  I free the spirit so the kids live.  They are innocent,  despite getting to know the baron,  he was a drunken ass who beat his wife and Anna was a cuckolding shrew who drove the Baron to drink.  It's also  the Barons choice to die, not Geralts.

The tree spirit is a far greater evil than three crones, and think about the poor Tamara and poor folks in Downwarren, they are not deserved to ...

The implications of Blood Baron's quest is far beyond a broken marriage. As for the hardest choice in TW3, is Olgierd and Iris's fate for me. 

[nfi42]

The tree spirit is a far greater evil than three crones, and think about the poor Tamara and poor folks in Downwarren, they are not deserved to ...

The implications of Blood Baron's quest is far beyond a broken marriage. As for the hardest choice in TW3, is Olgierd and Iris's fate for me. 

 

 

How do we know that tree spirit is a far greater evil.  As for Downwarren,  that is an unfortunate side effect that I can live with when I remind myself that itt's just a game.  I am biased a bit by the fact that I've still got a youngish daughter, and the orphans have the crones an a psycho Anna.  Geralt raising Ciri knows this as well.

 

Tamara is an adult,  doesn't impact my thinking as mush and neither do the folks of Downwarren (despite there being kids there)

[nfi42]

I have no disagreement with you there, even though I felt sympathy for both Baron and Anna every now and then; albeit unnervingly. Actually this is one of the few quests where I was disappointed with the outcome, because I would have liked to find the kids somewhere, anywhere, safe and sound. Now I just head cannon that those kids I find starving in the shack are them.

 

Witcher 3 seems actually seems to be one of the few games that make kids adorable and not obnoxious in my opinion. If they were skyrim children I probably would have let the crones eat them.

 

About the kids.

 

Spoiler

The kids live!!  In the schoolhouse you go to in Novigrad,  you run across them.  on a note found on a desk in the school building, you see a list of their names as them being left there

[Onecrazymonkey1]

The tree spirit is a far greater evil than three crones, and think about the poor Tamara and poor folks in Downwarren, they are not deserved to ...
The implications of Blood Baron's quest is far beyond a broken marriage. As for the hardest choice in TW3, is Olgierd and Iris's fate for me.

Iris's fate was always pretty easy for me actually. I always take the rose because I think it's far better for her to disappear then be locked in an eternal state of despair, and witcher's lift curses after all. Olgierd's is easy for me as well because as much as I enjoyed Gaunter, I think I would feel dirty not helping Olgierd. I also get bragging rights to say that I outsmarted the devil himself so there's that.

I also agree to a point about the entire village of downwarren, but the first time I played I didn't know they would get killed, whoops! sorry people.... but don't the villagers know what the crones are like? they kind of disgust me in a way sending their kids off to get eaten like that.

I also grew to like the Baron even though he was an ass and his outcome was handled better. Meh I just toss a coin with that quest now, both outcomes have their pros and cons.

[panzerwzh]

How do we know that tree spirit is a far greater evil.  As for Downwarren,  that is an unfortunate side effect that I can live with when I remind myself that itt's just a game.  I am biased a bit by the fact that I've still got a youngish daughter, and the orphans have the crones an a psycho Anna.  Geralt raising Ciri knows this as well.

 

Tamara is an adult,  doesn't impact my thinking as mush and neither do the folks of Downwarren (despite there being kids there)

In the notes and the consequence of Downwarren, it murdered a whole town's population to 'rescue' 9 orphans (my Geralt never see them again). As for Tamara, I don't think she deserved a broken family with mother turned into water hag and suicided father.

[Onecrazymonkey1]

About the kids.
 

Spoiler

The kids live!!  In the schoolhouse you go to in Novigrad,  you run across them.  on a note found on a desk in the school building, you see a list of their names as them being left there

Spoiler

Omg that's crazy! Thanks for that. I actually feel a lot better about that decision now. Hah, the detail is amazing.

[nfi42]

In the notes and the consequence of Downwarren, it murdered a whole town's population to 'rescue' 9 orphans (my Geralt never see them again). As for Tamara, I don't think she deserved a broken family with mother turned into water hag and suicided father.

 

I don't like it either, but that is the lesser evil to me.  read my spoiler post above.

[panzerwzh]

I don't like it either, but that is the lesser evil to me.  read my spoiler post above.

Yup I know that, but given the price of innocent lives,  my Geralt always killed the tree spirit and gave Baron the second chance.