Omg tldr. I felt a need to write. Skip to bottom.
The argument here is highly western. Take away the idea of what you think is woman/man and you get a character that either has a soul or doesn't. Then the main messages in the content
the witcher, despite all its powerful female characters (who are shown falling over the male lead like the majority of our female side characters in dominant media), still shows women made for men, to be oogled at, seduced, saved, bedded. the games messages thus arent any better than main messages in our media. Perhaps I'm wrong, I only looked at pics and read some articles. there are interesting engaging points being made in game, but the image of the sexy, powerful, yet seduced woman is there. Create the image of her and hold her up, show her off, analyze her...and put the man in the middle. What are they really making? What, as a consumer, are you eating up?
Its a trait of their product, that their women have been objectified as much as they've been 'empowered'. The hero does heroic acts in a sexy manner- to enjoy a hot romance -to save sexy women. You play a bad ass man. Its very american. They made this game, they want sex, they want to use women, they want a hot man for the main lead, and he gets all thier love and praise and hate too. So hot. Right?
So this is a moral question. But it is not asking, is sex bad or is nudity bad. Its Not, Is romancing fict characters like this, this indulgence, bad? No.
Are men just making games for men and recreating messages we've seen about men and women?
is this objectification wrong? Is this porn where women are on display and violence a problem? Is dominant women really feminist women?
Most importantly, Are these stories for better, or worse? Both? Can we really accept this media, as it is, despite its praise? Are these stories, the way its told, the messages we're making, worth having still?
Dragon age is also for consumers but they more openly test boundaries that the witcher still upholds- the sexualization of women- The consumption Of women. Dragon age is very sensitive to this cause. I dont know another group of writers this dedicated in gaming, who work as consciously, that are also this popular. They're making more diverse images. The ones I want to play and see exist in our world.
In my compartive lit class my professor said the main heroes of western societies are entrepreneurs since we're mostly consumer culture. I agOmg tldr. I felt a need to write. Skip to bottom.
The argument here is highly western. Take away the idea of what you think is woman/man and you get a character that either has a soul or doesn't. I.e. the character comes alive or doesn't. move on from this and see the messages. The roles the characters play.
the witcher, despite all its powerful, hot sexy female characters who are shown falling over the male lead (like the majority of our female side characters in dominant media), their creation still falls short because they are made for men, to be oogled at, seduced, saved, bedded. their messages arent any better than main messages in our media. Perhaps I'm wrong, I only looked at pics and read some articles. I'm sure there are interesting engaging points being made in game. But the image of the sexy, powerful, yet seduced woman. Create the image of her and hold her up, show her off, analyze her. and put the man in the middle. What are they really making? What, as a consumer, are you eating up?
Dragon age is also for consumers but they more openly test boundaries that the witcher still upholds. the sexualization of women. The consumption Of women. Dragon age is very sensitive to this cause. I dont know another group of writers this dedicated in gaming, who work as consciously, that are also this popular. They're making more diverse images. The ones I want to play and see exist in our world.
the writers are making stories that deserve to exist in our world and are as such. Those of us that refuse it can do so, that these messages are out there now, that they are even openly talked about; but its happening. Theyre building something thats evidence of our generations voice. It is so much better than the witcher in that regard.
To sum
I'd play the witcher if it wasn't so obviously made for the male players fantasy of power over an idealized powerful woman; if their women weren't so idealized and victimized that way. what story is left for them to write if the sexualization of woman wasn't so stressed? Is the story still as great? Content would change drastically wouldn't it?
Bioware was clunky in execution, but their messages are spot on. They can learn a lot from the witchers quest execution, and realize whats not worth having from its content.
Ugh I just need to post this cause I put time writing it. Lol.
-
AllThatJazz, 5ubzer0 et Panda aiment ceci