Aller au contenu

Photo

Abominable Wynne (or: Wynnie the "Poo! I am not allowed to have Spoilers in the title")


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1396 réponses à ce sujet

#851
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

Addai67 wrote...

Ok, to preface my comments I'm going to quote myself from the Zevran romance thread:

I woke up this morning fuming about Wynne's ridiculous conversation with my character last night.  The story line around my character makes it even more insulting than usual.  My virginal girl has only slept with Zevran, maybe, 3 nights before this.  I think she got over her self-consciousness about 10 minutes in to the first night, of course- it is obvious that Zevran is nothing if not a generous lover- but she still is only just exploring her sexuality for the first time, after a bad history and the "wonderful" nurturance of the Circle.  And even though she doesn't know what's going on with Zevran, she can see his pain.  His refusal was a blow, because she thinks he might end up telling her he needs to move on.  So on the very same night to have that... that woman... try to make it so cheap and tawdry, to tell her that it is beneath her to be involved with him, is insult to lots of injury.

I think she also suspects that it is in part racist, that if she were still with Alistair, Wynne would not be nearly so incensed.  Which is somewhat true, since in the Alistair sermon, Wynne more talks about them getting hurt rather than it being "inappropriate."  Oh boy, if she ever gets to the point where she hears about Aneirin, my elven lass is not going to take it well.  This is all proof to her that it was a mistake to have a Circle mouthpiece in her camp.


Now, what I am thinking about Wynne is this:  Nearly every other character in the game changes, develops, overcomes their weaknesses or at least begins to do that.  Even Loghain. Naturally there are exceptions (Bhelen comes to mind) and a lot depends on the Warden's influence.  But no matter what the Warden does or doesn't do, it seems to me like Wynne is one of the few who never changes, who actually regresses.  If my elf mage ever did hear about Aneirin's story, her own experience with "wynsensitivity" would convince her that Wynne had learned nothing at all.  Rather than be a mentor to my Warden mage, she is still the same overbearing, callous b*tch she was to Aneirin.  If my elf mage were then to see Wynne try to convince Aneirin to go back to the Circle, this conclusion would be doubly confirmed.  Maybe it is just a factor of her age, that being set in her ways, she's just going to be this way and that's that.

I am happy for someone else with a different view of Wynne to show me the error of my ways.


Actually I think you've just scored a major point, there. Zevran learns to trust, Alistair does [a little] growing up, Sten softens up a bit, Lilliana learns she can be whatever she wants and isn't defined by the opinions of others. Loghain realizes what he's screwed up but Wynne? Just keep spouting platitudes.

I sometimes wonder if her psychological brittleness is related to what Loghain says about the mages fleeing the battle and not blowing a hole in the lines for him to get to Cailin. I wonder is she just shoots off her mouth so she doesn't have to deal with the guilt of leaving Cailin and the GW  to die, or taking the responsibility for the fact that her arrogance could have cost Anerin's life. Of all the crazy party members--she takes the least responsibility for her past actions.

#852
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
Not to mention Oghren sobering up a bit, Shale realizing that meatbags aren't as weak and worthles as she thinks they are, and Morrigan is introduced to either friendship or love (even though she eventually leaves anyway).



Wynne...learned that she was wrong about the PC being able to have a love life and still stop the Blight. Although if Alistair is King and does the US, leaving Anora alone on the throne because he's so overwhelmed by love, that's very selfish and she might have a point there.

#853
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

sami jo wrote...

I keep hoping that I can force her to use that Spirit Vessel ability enough times that she will fall over dead. I like her less with every playthrough.


Stock up on healing potions and leave her in camp. I've done it on numerous occassions. As an old lady myself she's making us look bad.

#854
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

Not to mention Oghren sobering up a bit, Shale realizing that meatbags aren't as weak and worthles as she thinks they are, and Morrigan is introduced to either friendship or love (even though she eventually leaves anyway).

Wynne...learned that she was wrong about the PC being able to have a love life and still stop the Blight. Although if Alistair is King and does the US, leaving Anora alone on the throne because he's so overwhelmed by love, that's very selfish and she might have a point there.


Only because you defy her and keep boffing your S/O. That's not learning--that's tolerating.

Also, she's lecturing the MC not Alistair--if she had half a brain she'd be telling him, not you. And she gives you the same speech no matter who you're boffing even Zevran.

Modifié par Swifty, 11 mars 2010 - 06:35 .


#855
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages
Oghren sobers up? Not in my game [at least not 'til the end credits] he just keeps yelling aschchaps and falling over drunk.

#856
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
That's what I hate about the US endings: they always vindicate her. Leliana either commits suicide or goes back to being a bard, Zevran takes over the Crows and never gets over the PC enough to fall in love, and as for Alistair...what was even the point of any of the Ferelden politics if Anora is going to stay exactly where she is with nothing changing? That's the only ending where you KNOW there isn't going to be an heir.

#857
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages

Oghren sobers up? Not in my game [at least not 'til the end credits] he just keeps yelling aschchaps and falling over drunk.




A bit. And he gets his warrior pride back, too, and gets a girl who somehow actually GETS him, which lessens his need to.

#858
Cuddlezarro

Cuddlezarro
  • Members
  • 5 327 messages

Swifty wrote...

Oghren sobers up? Not in my game [at least not 'til the end credits] he just keeps yelling aschchaps and falling over drunk.


the fact he even settles down and has a kid shows development

he does start showing signs during the story though if you make sure to recruit him first and take hm every where (fade dream and ashes are prominent)

plus his friendship speech at the gates during the final battle are pretty touching

#859
sami jo

sami jo
  • Members
  • 2 248 messages

Swifty wrote...

sami jo wrote...

I keep hoping that I can force her to use that Spirit Vessel ability enough times that she will fall over dead. I like her less with every playthrough.


Stock up on healing potions and leave her in camp. I've done it on numerous occassions. As an old lady myself she's making us look bad.


Oh, I do leave her in camp.  She ticked me off so much with my FCE my third playthrough that I was tempted to side with the crazy cultists just for the pleasure of getting rid of her.  She will be staying at the Circle in all future playthroughs.  She is unbearably rude to everyone but Allistair and Lelianna.  All of the other characters have grown on me with subsequent playthroughs.  Sten disturbs me on occasion, but he actually likes it when you stand up to him.  Wynne is the only character I have learned to hate.

#860
sami jo

sami jo
  • Members
  • 2 248 messages

Swifty wrote...

Only because you defy her and keep boffing your S/O. That's not learning--that's tolerating.

Also, she's lecturing the MC not Alistair--if she had half a brain she'd be telling him, not you. And she gives you the same speech no matter who you're boffing even Zevran.


You get a speech no matter who you are romancing, but it is different for each romanceable character.  She is afraid you will hurt Lelianna and Allistair, she goes on about Morrigan being an untrustworthy maleficar, and she is downright nasty about Zevran, calling him "beneath" you.  She apologizes about her nastiness eventually, but it takes the longest for her to apologize about Zevran, and it only happens if you take the earring from him. 

#861
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

sami jo wrote...

Swifty wrote...

sami jo wrote...

I keep hoping that I can force her to use that Spirit Vessel ability enough times that she will fall over dead. I like her less with every playthrough.


Stock up on healing potions and leave her in camp. I've done it on numerous occassions. As an old lady myself she's making us look bad.


Oh, I do leave her in camp.  She ticked me off so much with my FCE my third playthrough that I was tempted to side with the crazy cultists just for the pleasure of getting rid of her.  She will be staying at the Circle in all future playthroughs.  She is unbearably rude to everyone but Allistair and Lelianna.  All of the other characters have grown on me with subsequent playthroughs.  Sten disturbs me on occasion, but he actually likes it when you stand up to him.  Wynne is the only character I have learned to hate.

Then you're nicer than I am because I want to practise my sheild bash on Morrigan if she makes one more snarky comment. I wish we had a dialogue option when her and Alistair start bickering to say, "Shut up already. If I wanted to travel with children, I'd buy a station wagon."

Can you not just use the dialogue option, "I want you to leave"? Though in Wynne's case it might be dangerous because she'll try to talk you out of it until the next power outage blows up your computer.



#862
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

sami jo wrote...

Swifty wrote...

Only because you defy her and keep boffing your S/O. That's not learning--that's tolerating.

Also, she's lecturing the MC not Alistair--if she had half a brain she'd be telling him, not you. And she gives you the same speech no matter who you're boffing even Zevran.


You get a speech no matter who you are romancing, but it is different for each romanceable character.  She is afraid you will hurt Lelianna and Allistair, she goes on about Morrigan being an untrustworthy maleficar, and she is downright nasty about Zevran, calling him "beneath" you.  She apologizes about her nastiness eventually, but it takes the longest for her to apologize about Zevran, and it only happens if you take the earring from him. 


Been there, done that 4x already. This time and last time I just went straight for, "It's none of your business" followed by "I'm not discussing it with you."

If you do that she doesn't apologize.

#863
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
Does it at least cut the lecture short?

#864
sami jo

sami jo
  • Members
  • 2 248 messages
@Swifty: At least on the console version, there is no option to tell her to leave. I would have used it many times over by now if there was. I would have probably reloaded multiple times just to do it again during my first CE run.

#865
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

Does it at least cut the lecture short?


Yeah 2 options and out.

Go for it.

#866
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

sami jo wrote...

@Swifty: At least on the console version, there is no option to tell her to leave. I would have used it many times over by now if there was. I would have probably reloaded multiple times just to do it again during my first CE run.


I dunno I've never actually checked to boot her out. Someone mentioned Morrigan won't leave if you kick her out, either. The next mage I play--she's just soooooooooooo gone.

#867
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages
Oh man I checked and you can't kick her out-aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaargh!



Has anyone tried to NOT take her when you go to leave the tower and the option opens up?



And yes you can boot out Morrigan. How much you wanna bet she still shows up looking for the GodBaby at the end, anyway?

#868
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
If you get the blood magic tattling put back in and convince Wynne it was 'Grey Warden magic' does she still claim that you're 'brave and good' when she tries to use you to ditch the tower? Because that would be one quick turnaround from 'kill the evil blood mage who I don't care just saved us all'.

#869
Sarah1281

Sarah1281
  • Members
  • 15 280 messages
Morrigan totally does, which makes it even stranger that she randomly shows up. The quickest and most efficient way of getting rid of Wynne that I've found is having her in your party and agreeing to side with Cullen. You don't actually have to, but Wynne attacks regardless. It's kind of too bad that once you say you'll side with him and Zevran gives you a very compelling argument on why you shouldn't you can't agree with him. If party members are going to interrupt and have a problem with what you do, you should have the option to be convinced by them.

Modifié par Sarah1281, 11 mars 2010 - 07:37 .


#870
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages
Wow, you blood mage folks seem to have opened up a whole area I know nothing about here?



Also, if you did the mage's tower *last* you wouldn't have to put up with Wynne for so long?

#871
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

Morrigan totally does, which makes it even stranger that she randomly shows up. The quickest and most efficient way of getting rid of Wynne that I've found is having her in your party and agreeing to side with Cullen. You don't actuall have to, but Wynne attacks regardless. It's kind of too bad that once you say you'll side with him and Zevran gives you a very compelling argument on why you shouldn't you can't agree with him. If party members are going to interrupt and have a problem with what you do, you should have the option to be convinced by them.


I agree. And you should have the opportunity to convince them, as well.

In one of the forums asking for ideas on new games I also said that in a situation such as Harrowmount/Bhelan or Alistair/Loghain the MC should be allowed to ask the people who will affected by their decision, plus their companions, questions because good leadership means getting good information and otherwise, the MC is being blindsided.

#872
sami jo

sami jo
  • Members
  • 2 248 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

Morrigan totally does, which makes it even stranger that she randomly shows up. The quickest and most efficient way of getting rid of Wynne that I've found is having her in your party and agreeing to side with Cullen. You don't actuall have to, but Wynne attacks regardless. It's kind of too bad that once you say you'll side with him and Zevran gives you a very compelling argument on why you shouldn't you can't agree with him. If party members are going to interrupt and have a problem with what you do, you should have the option to be convinced by them.


You can be convinced by them (and specifically by Zev), in other areas.  I do wish they would let you tell him that you agree at the Circle, though.  It is a handy way of getting rid of Wynne and still preserving the mages.  I think you can still leave her at the tower when she asks to accompany you. 

#873
ykarie

ykarie
  • Members
  • 9 messages

Sarah1281 wrote...

That's what I hate about the US endings: they always vindicate her. Leliana either commits suicide or goes back to being a bard, Zevran takes over the Crows and never gets over the PC enough to fall in love, and as for Alistair...what was even the point of any of the Ferelden politics if Anora is going to stay exactly where she is with nothing changing? That's the only ending where you KNOW there isn't going to be an heir.


I did not get that from the talks with Wynne. She objected to me and Alistair because she was worried that it would affect our abilities to do what needed to be done. In the end, both of us were willing to do that anyways, he just didn't give me a choice. I don't think that vindicated Wynne at all, it proved her wrong.

Going back and letting You Know Who live, so he can take the fall. I want my "And They Lived Happily Ever After" at least until the next Blight shows up.

#874
sami jo

sami jo
  • Members
  • 2 248 messages

Swifty wrote...

Wow, you blood mage folks seem to have opened up a whole area I know nothing about here?

Also, if you did the mage's tower *last* you wouldn't have to put up with Wynne for so long?


Not an option if you want to save both Connor and Isolde.  Well, you can get the Ashes quest in Denerim and do all but the very last portion of the Redcliff quest, I suppose.

Edit: the blood mage thing only works on PC's with dialogue tweaks for Wynne installed.  CZ links to it earlier in the thread.

Modifié par sami jo, 11 mars 2010 - 07:27 .


#875
Swifty

Swifty
  • Members
  • 201 messages

sami jo wrote...

Swifty wrote...

Wow, you blood mage folks seem to have opened up a whole area I know nothing about here?

Also, if you did the mage's tower *last* you wouldn't have to put up with Wynne for so long?


Not an option if you want to save both Connor and Isolde.  Well, you can get the Ashes quest in Denerim and do all but the very last portion of the Redcliff quest, I suppose.

Edit: the blood mage thing only works on PC's with dialogue tweaks for Wynne installed.  CZ links to it earlier in the thread.


And you want to save Isolde--why? 2000 dead villagers and a bunch of dead knights due to her stupidity--she's not high on some of my MC's lists to save.

{depends on what you're playing I know]