Aller au contenu

Photo

Abominable Wynne (or: Wynnie the "Poo! I am not allowed to have Spoilers in the title")


  • Veuillez vous connecter pour répondre
1396 réponses à ce sujet

#101
Cuddlezarro

Cuddlezarro
  • Members
  • 5 327 messages

ejoslin wrote...

Hmmmm, given RtO's dialog between Alistair and Wynne, does it seem even more hypocritical of her disapproving so strongly of the female Warden having sex with Cammen? I honestly don't get why she would now.


but she approves of me sleeping with Ghenya or whateer her name is so its totally in character despite her getting mad at the female warden!


but her talking about sex with younger men is the creepy dialogue from RtO I brought up earlier... and it is creepy I dont want to know about a 70+ year old womans sex life

#102
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

Cuddlezarro wrote...

ejoslin wrote...

Hmmmm, given RtO's dialog between Alistair and Wynne, does it seem even more hypocritical of her disapproving so strongly of the female Warden having sex with Cammen? I honestly don't get why she would now.


but she approves of me sleeping with Ghenya or whateer her name is so its totally in character despite her getting mad at the female warden!


but her talking about sex with younger men is the creepy dialogue from RtO I brought up earlier... and it is creepy I dont want to know about a 70+ year old womans sex life


Yeh, she just doesn't want the female warden to have fun!  And I agree, the dialog between her and Alistair . . . weird.

#103
melkathi

melkathi
  • Members
  • 1 296 messages

Cuddlezarro wrote...

ejoslin wrote...

Hmmmm, given RtO's dialog between Alistair and Wynne, does it seem even more hypocritical of her disapproving so strongly of the female Warden having sex with Cammen? I honestly don't get why she would now.


but she approves of me sleeping with Ghenya or whateer her name is so its totally in character despite her getting mad at the female warden!


but her talking about sex with younger men is the creepy dialogue from RtO I brought up earlier... and it is creepy I dont want to know about a 70+ year old womans sex life


That RTO banter makes you wonder how come she hasn't hit on your male Warden yet :P

#104
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
Edit: Deleted.  Pointless.  *grin*  I'll have to think of some new Wynne-hate to place here.

Modifié par ejoslin, 08 février 2010 - 02:04 .


#105
melkathi

melkathi
  • Members
  • 1 296 messages

ejoslin wrote...

Edit: Deleted.  Pointless.  *grin*  I'll have to think of some new Wynne-hate to place here.


Not thought of anything yet?

#106
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

melkathi wrote...

ejoslin wrote...

Edit: Deleted.  Pointless.  *grin*  I'll have to think of some new Wynne-hate to place here.


Not thought of anything yet?


Well, no.  But I found if you don't have her in your party when confronted Uldred she can't take the credit for killing him, with, of course, your "help", but then she automatically is waiting there at camp for you.   *grin*  

I think it actually is pretty nice if you do her personal quest, how she's able to finally get away from the circle, but if you don't, she becomes even more of a devotee to it. 

#107
Sabriana

Sabriana
  • Members
  • 4 381 messages
Yep, Melkathi, I too have been waiting for Ejoslin to open up a "Why Wynne sucks" threat for ages now, lol.

But seriously, that always struck me wrong. "With my help"? Heck, my PC did most of the work, and pulled her butt out of quite a few tight spots.

#108
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
Without the Warden, Wynne would have been stuck in the fade, rocking back and forth gripping her knees, mourning that she couldn't save the circle. I find the wording, "I had help," SO obnoxious.  But to Wynne's credit, I think she really did believe it was mostly her!  She certainly thought she could kill the Warden on more than one occasion, which shows she greatly underestimated the Warden's strength.

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 février 2010 - 01:19 .


#109
Feraele

Feraele
  • Members
  • 3 119 messages
I think Wynn meddles too much, and have to say after all the run-throughs I have had so far, never occurred to me to bring Wynne along on the Gauntlet. Most times she stays in camp, and I feed her gifts lol.



She's a bit too grandmotherly for me, and..I have to say I didn't always consider the advice I got from my own grandmother ..as perfect and fitting for everything I was doing. Was always..."time for a grain of salt"



I prefer Morrigan if I am taking another caster with me quite frankly.

#110
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages
Saving the world is not enough, I suppose. My warden needs to not have fun time with a certain elf. Heh, the way she's acting, it's just not fitting for a Grey Warden!
Photobucket

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 février 2010 - 02:31 .


#111
melkathi

melkathi
  • Members
  • 1 296 messages

ejoslin wrote...

Without the Warden, Wynne would have been stuck in the fade, rocking back and forth gripping her knees, mourning that she couldn't save the circle. I find the wording, "I had help," SO obnoxious.  But to Wynne's credit, I think she really did believe it was mostly her!  She certainly thought she could kill the Warden on more than one occasion, which shows she greatly underestimated the Warden's strength.


Stuck rocking back and forth in the Fade? I highly doubt it. Sloth is three floors up. She'd have to get that far first without help :P

#112
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

melkathi wrote...

ejoslin wrote...

Without the Warden, Wynne would have been stuck in the fade, rocking back and forth gripping her knees, mourning that she couldn't save the circle. I find the wording, "I had help," SO obnoxious.  But to Wynne's credit, I think she really did believe it was mostly her!  She certainly thought she could kill the Warden on more than one occasion, which shows she greatly underestimated the Warden's strength.


Stuck rocking back and forth in the Fade? I highly doubt it. Sloth is three floors up. She'd have to get that far first without help :P


You're right.  One demon actually killed Wynne.  Even with the spirit in her, she probably couldn't have made it very far.

#113
melkathi

melkathi
  • Members
  • 1 296 messages

ejoslin wrote...

melkathi wrote...

ejoslin wrote...

Without the Warden, Wynne would have been stuck in the fade, rocking back and forth gripping her knees, mourning that she couldn't save the circle. I find the wording, "I had help," SO obnoxious.  But to Wynne's credit, I think she really did believe it was mostly her!  She certainly thought she could kill the Warden on more than one occasion, which shows she greatly underestimated the Warden's strength.


Stuck rocking back and forth in the Fade? I highly doubt it. Sloth is three floors up. She'd have to get that far first without help :P


You're right.  One demon actually killed Wynne.  Even with the spirit in her, she probably couldn't have made it very far.


Though to be fair, if my character was her age... :innocent:;)

Modifié par melkathi, 10 février 2010 - 05:50 .


#114
Vicious

Vicious
  • Members
  • 3 221 messages
Fun Fact:



A cut part of the game [which can be re-enabled with Mods] has Wynne confronting you in camp if you are a blood mage, and attacking you, forcing you to kill her.



Keep in mind it's perfectly OK for GW's to be blood mages. And she harps over and over about the responsibilities of being a GW. And you saved her and her circle.



It's no surprise they removed it from the game. Left in, Wynne is the most idiotic character in the entire f--ing game.

#115
melkathi

melkathi
  • Members
  • 1 296 messages

Vicious wrote...

Keep in mind it's perfectly OK for GW's to be blood mages. And she harps over and over about the responsibilities of being a GW. And you saved her and her circle.


My blood mage killed Avernus explaining to him that Blood Magic was bad and not even wardens should use it B)
Silly dialogues. My mage wanted to punish him for breaking the Veil and for experimenting on human beings, ot the blood magic part.

#116
soteria

soteria
  • Members
  • 3 307 messages
Meh. From a gameplay perspective, Wynne is actually very powerful, and makes the Uldred fight MUCH easier. She can trivialize every encounter in the game--first because she's a spirit healer, second because of her plot ability, which gives her enough longevity to keep casting for quite some time even without potions.



She *is* an idiot in the Fade, but so are several of the other companions, especially Alistair and Leliana. Comparing her to Sten is kinda harsh, since he's probably the most self-aware of all of them. Even Morrigan seems stuck, despite knowing it's a dream.



As for the whole, "How DARE she comment on my personal life?! She has no right!!" I really think you're overreacting. Learn to take criticism? In real life, and we can imagine in-game, people are going to talk about your "personal life" to some extent. At least Wynne has the courtesy to tell you what she thinks to your face instead of just talking about you to all her friends. And she apologizes, too, which is a LOT bigger than you make it out to be. You just wave it off like it means nothing, but let me tell you, it's hard to admit when you're wrong, and even harder for an older person to apologize to someone they see as a child. Especially when, as she sees it, she's in a position of authority.



I'll add, I don't even like Wynne... her dialogues bore me. I just don't get the hate.

#117
Vicious

Vicious
  • Members
  • 3 221 messages
I personally dislike moralizing old coots.

#118
ejoslin

ejoslin
  • Members
  • 11 745 messages

soteria wrote...

Meh. From a gameplay perspective, Wynne is actually very powerful, and makes the Uldred fight MUCH easier. She can trivialize every encounter in the game--first because she's a spirit healer, second because of her plot ability, which gives her enough longevity to keep casting for quite some time even without potions.

She *is* an idiot in the Fade, but so are several of the other companions, especially Alistair and Leliana. Comparing her to Sten is kinda harsh, since he's probably the most self-aware of all of them. Even Morrigan seems stuck, despite knowing it's a dream.

As for the whole, "How DARE she comment on my personal life?! She has no right!!" I really think you're overreacting. Learn to take criticism? In real life, and we can imagine in-game, people are going to talk about your "personal life" to some extent. At least Wynne has the courtesy to tell you what she thinks to your face instead of just talking about you to all her friends. And she apologizes, too, which is a LOT bigger than you make it out to be. You just wave it off like it means nothing, but let me tell you, it's hard to admit when you're wrong, and even harder for an older person to apologize to someone they see as a child. Especially when, as she sees it, she's in a position of authority.

I'll add, I don't even like Wynne... her dialogues bore me. I just don't get the hate.


She doesn't have the plot ability during the Uldred fight.  And my mage warden which is a blood mage/spirit healer is FAR more powerful.  I find controlling far more powerful than healing, anyway.  If they can't hit you, you don't need healing.

And yes, she had no business with the rude comments, throwing insults at both Zevran (which really has a far different sound than if Alistair or Leliana is the romance partner) and the Warden.  And yes, she does apologize, but she owes the warden an apology, and in the Zevran romance, it happens far later in the game since the romance doesn't turn to love until later in the game.  And Wynne should not be viewing the warden as a child -- that's silly.  The warden is NOT a child, and shouldn't be called such (which Wynne DOES call her in that confrontation).  And you're leaving out the part where you don't have to let her accompany you.  If you respect someone, you don't trash talk them. 

Even Leliana will say that if you trust Zevran, so does she, because you haven't led them astray yet.

To some extent, most of your companions will discuss your relationship in party banter. It may be as little as Alistair questioning Leliana as to what someone sees in Zevran, or it may be Wynne making comments about Alistair and the warden having sex and where babies come from.  Shale, Oghren, and Morrigan will make direct comments about the relationships as well.  It's not like there's this huge secret being kept.  The difference is, no one else is saying that they should end it, and being really rude about it.

Edit: I wonder, though, if Wynne is just so used to being a mentor that it being a bad thing undermining her leader's authority doesn't even occur to her?

Who was the mage warden's mentor anyway?  I actually think it was Irving (Uldred says something about her being Irvings star pupil), but I don't think it's ever really said.

Modifié par ejoslin, 10 février 2010 - 07:20 .


#119
Nonvita

Nonvita
  • Members
  • 2 165 messages

ejoslin wrote...

I find controlling far more powerful than healing, anyway.  If they can't hit you, you don't need healing.


Too true. I always end up dragging Morrigan with me because I build her up with CC spells. I don't even have a healing spell on her, yet I can breeze through most anything with no potions or healing at all. I always *think* things are going to be easier with Wynne on board, then quickly realize I don't need her and throw her back in camp.

I don't *hate* Wynne. Well... ok... I think she's a hypocrite in a terrible way, so it's a trying relationship. Her dialogues, while mostly boring, occasionally strike a nerve with my characters, so I can't say they're all bad. Then again, striking that nerve contributed to my CE wanting to sacrifice herself, so make of that what you wish!

I think the reason I can't finish my first mage character is because she's a lot like Wynne. I feel really naive and short-sighted when playing her... It's weird...

#120
Cuddlezarro

Cuddlezarro
  • Members
  • 5 327 messages

She certainly thought she could kill the Warden on more than one occasion, which shows she greatly underestimated the Warden's strength.


funny thing about that... she underestimated my dogs strength since my dog killed her in my casteless dwarf playthrough when I defiled the ashes before she could draw her staff

As for the whole, "How DARE she comment on my personal life?! She has no right!!" I really think you're overreacting. Learn to take criticism? In real life, and we can imagine in-game, people are going to talk about your "personal life" to some extent. At least Wynne has the courtesy to tell you what she thinks to your face instead of just talking about you to all her friends. And she apologizes, too, which is a LOT bigger than you make it out to be. You just wave it off like it means nothing, but let me tell you, it's hard to admit when you're wrong, and even harder for an older person to apologize to someone they see as a child. Especially when, as she sees it, she's in a position of authority.


have you EVER gotten the relationship "advice" concerning Zevran she is downright RUDE to you and treats you like a 15 year old teenager in lust who would drop all responsibility at the drop of a hat and IM sorry but the Warden is a grown Man/woman and she has no right to view you as a child, also her apology to her pretty much insulting you to your face comes MUCH MUCH later in the game than the others like over a year late

Modifié par Cuddlezarro, 10 février 2010 - 07:46 .


#121
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 816 messages

Who was the mage warden's mentor anyway? I actually think it was Irving (Uldred says something about her being Irvings star pupil), but I don't think it's ever really said.




I always roleplay it as such, since he's the only senior enchanter you encounter who seems to know you that well.



I'm playing a blood mage who just got to the tower and I've already freaked Wynne out by saying that I'm more dangerous than the abominations we're facing. I can't wait to tell her to shove it every chance I get. My last HN ended up being way too nice to her.

#122
Cuddlezarro

Cuddlezarro
  • Members
  • 5 327 messages

SurelyForth wrote...

Who was the mage warden's mentor anyway? I actually think it was Irving (Uldred says something about her being Irvings star pupil), but I don't think it's ever really said.


I always roleplay it as such, since he's the only senior enchanter you encounter who seems to know you that well.

I'm playing a blood mage who just got to the tower and I've already freaked Wynne out by saying that I'm more dangerous than the abominations we're facing. I can't wait to tell her to shove it every chance I get. My last HN ended up being way too nice to her.


do you have dialogue tweaks installed? I would install it just for the Wynn rats you out as a blood mage dialogue

its one of my favorite conversatiosn in the game plus you get to see Irving PWN Wynn (or the other alternitive you get)

Modifié par Cuddlezarro, 10 février 2010 - 08:13 .


#123
soteria

soteria
  • Members
  • 3 307 messages

She doesn't have the plot ability during the Uldred fight. And my mage warden which is a blood mage/spirit healer is FAR more powerful. I find controlling far more powerful than healing, anyway. If they can't hit you, you don't need healing.

And yes, she had no business with the rude comments, throwing insults at both Zevran (which really has a far different sound than if Alistair or Leliana is the romance partner) and the Warden. And yes, she does apologize, but she owes the warden an apology, and in the Zevran romance, it happens far later in the game since the romance doesn't turn to love until later in the game. And Wynne should not be viewing the warden as a child -- that's silly. The warden is NOT a child, and shouldn't be called such (which Wynne DOES call her in that confrontation). And you're leaving out the part where you don't have to let her accompany you. If you respect someone, you don't trash talk them.

Even Leliana will say that if you trust Zevran, so does she, because you haven't led them astray yet.

To some extent, most of your companions will discuss your relationship in party banter. It may be as little as Alistair questioning Leliana as to what someone sees in Zevran, or it may be Wynne making comments about Alistair and the warden having sex and where babies come from. Shale, Oghren, and Morrigan will make direct comments about the relationships as well. It's not like there's this huge secret being kept. The difference is, no one else is saying that they should end it, and being really rude about it.

Edit: I wonder, though, if Wynne is just so used to being a mentor that it being a bad thing undermining her leader's authority doesn't even occur to her?

Who was the mage warden's mentor anyway? I actually think it was Irving (Uldred says something about her being Irvings star pupil), but I don't think it's ever really said.


Ok, a mage PC is always going to be stronger than a mage NPC, tha'ts a no-brainer. With any other character she's a huge asset to that fight since using crowd control really isn't an option. And with her (or a PC spirit healer, w/e) you really don't need crowd control.

Actually, the warden really is a child, relatively speaking. It depends on the origin, but I get the impression from the origins and what I know of history you're not much over 18 if you're even that old. I'm only in my 20's and I consider 18-20 year-old's kids, I can only imagine what it would be like at her age. So yeah, you're a kid. Get over it.

Wynne doesn't undermine your authority--she has that conversation with you in camp, away from the other party members. As a member of the group, she brings up valid concerns about your commitment both to your love interest and to stopping the Blight. Were I in the same situation, with my life on the line, I would be concerned, too. As the leader of the group, the question of whether or not your head is in the game is NOT your "personal business."

She certainly thought she could kill the Warden on more than one occasion, which shows she greatly underestimated the Warden's strength.



funny thing about that... she underestimated my dogs strength since my dog killed her in my casteless dwarf playthrough when I defiled the ashes before she could draw her staff


So does Sten, but you don't seem to have a problem with him? Looks to me like you're just picking at things you wouldn't criticize in other people. As for Dog, I don't think any NPC ever accuses a mabari of being weak. Arl Eamon tells you that you can't have your mabari duel Loghain because then "anyone who owned a mabari would have a shot at the throne," not because he thinks Dog might lose.

Plus, it's not so much an issue of her underestimating your strength as having convictions that are worth fighting or potentially dying for.  Taking on yourself plus two other party members is pretty clearly a losing proposition, but she does it anyway.  A lot of people would consider that sort of conviction and resolve an admirable trait, but you turn it into "underestimating the warden's strength."  Again, taking attributes that aren't really negatives and making them out as bad because you already don't like them.

have you EVER gotten the relationship "advice" concerning Zevran she is downright RUDE to you and treats you like a 15 year old teenager in lust who would drop all responsibility at the drop of a hat and IM sorry but the Warden is a grown Man/woman and she has no right to view you as a child, also her apology to her pretty much insulting you to your face comes MUCH MUCH later in the game than the others like over a year late


As I said before, you're hardly a grown man/woman, and especially not from the perspective of someone Wynne's age. No, I haven't had that conversation with Wynne; I think I killed her the time I romanced Zevran. The point at which she apologizes is not "MUCH MUCH later." It varies, but I think I've had it as soon as the next time I visited camp.

Modifié par soteria, 10 février 2010 - 08:32 .


#124
SurelyForth

SurelyForth
  • Members
  • 6 816 messages

do you have dialogue tweaks installed? I would install it just for the Wynn rats you out as a blood mage dialogue



its one of my favorite conversatiosn in the game plus you get to see Irving PWN Wynn (or the other alternitive you get)




I do! I'm just now to the Fade, so I have something to look forward to when I get out of there.




#125
Cuddlezarro

Cuddlezarro
  • Members
  • 5 327 messages

So does Sten, but you don't seem to have a problem with him?


how would you know that I havnt brought up Sten at all and he has nothing to do with the topic also Sten doesnt try to kill you he tries to take command yes but not kill you

Wynn has several opptunities int he game to outright try and kill you

Actually, the warden really is a child, relatively speaking. It depends on the origin, but I get the impression from the origins and what I know of history you're not much over 18 if you're even that old. I'm only in my 20's and I consider 18-20 year-old's kids, I can only imagine what it would be like at her age. So yeah, you're a kid. Get over it.


funny because I dont see my Noble character being any younger than 25-28 so no he is *not* a child and since your age OR birthdate is never stated its perfectly reasonable to think that

and you cant exactly compare real world history to that of a video game with dragons and magic

As I said before, you're hardly a grown man/woman, and especially not from the perspective of someone Wynne's age. No, I haven't had that conversation with Wynne; I think I killed her the time I romanced Zevran. The point at which she apologizes is not "MUCH MUCH later." It varies, but I think I've had it as soon as the next time I visited camp.


see above for the age thing but im sorry but my character is not a child and Wynn should respect that this aint a stereotypical JRPG with hormonal angst ridden 16 year old brats saving the world

and yes the Apology for treating you like a child is that much later if your romancing Zevran(unless you go to the circle last) because she doesn't apologize till *after* the Talisan encounter and Zevran admits his feelings and thats near the end of the game

and she does treat you badly if your romancing zevran during that talk, unlike Leliena and Alistair where she showing concern in a well meaning manner her manner of talking to you about your relationship with Zev is much harsher in tone and acts like you will drop your responsibilities at the drop of a coin because your having sex with him

Modifié par Cuddlezarro, 10 février 2010 - 08:46 .