I haven't read every post in this thread, nor do I intend to, but coming from the last page and reading the current argument, I will say this:
I once randomly ran into a study posted on the boy types of men that women find attractive, vs the body types of men that men think women find attractive. Suffice to say, the results were usually very different.
The men surveyed tended to think that the men that were more muscular and had less body fat were the ones that women would go for, yet that wasn't really the case.
Here's the link if anyone is interested:
http://foxhoundstudi...uys-want-to-be/
What's even funnier is when I read the comment on a male bodybuilding forum. The level of butthurt was...asstronimocal.