I disagree though now reading back I didn't word it very well, what I meant was having the solution randomly generated. If it has a rhyme or reason to it then that's fine but randomly generated failings based on nothing other than chance wouldn't be all that fun imo, not when it comes to that kind of choices.
By the way you forgot your wish.
I just want things like that to be different each playthrough. I want the same action to have different outcomes the next time I play. I want there to be uncertainty in outcome even when I know the game. If there are three possible ways to answer to someone, or do a quest, and one of them is "correct" (i.e gives you the best outcome), I don't want it to necessarily be the same one every time. I don't want to be able to "figure it out". When I play the game for the 10th time, I want there to be things happening that I didn't expect. Of course the outcome should always be logical and consistent with what is happening, but it shouldn't always be the same....
Whoops, so I did...
I wish the female protagonist actually has some muscles instead of the twigs FemShep had for arms.